Jeans criterion in hydrostatic stratified media
Abstract
The classical Jeans stability criterion neglects spatial gradients in background physical quantities such as density and pressure. Here, we revisit the Jeans analysis for a non-rotating fluid in hydrostatic equilibrium, explicitly accounting for these gradients and deriving a modified dispersion relation governing perturbation propagation. Using physical arguments, we show why the Jeans swindle is not required to derive the Jeans criterion for perturbations that are small compared to the size of the host system. We use linear perturbation analysis alongside an averaging procedure to study the behavior of the local Eulerian perturbations in a hydrostatic medium, showing that background gradients enter the dispersion relation in a highly non-trivial manner, precluding the derivation of a general gravitational stability criterion applicable to an arbitrary hydrostatic system. We demonstrate that, in the local short-wavelength limit, the standard Jeans criterion remains valid despite the presence of nonzero background gradients, and that all local perturbations in a hydrostatic system are stable against local gravitational collapse. We conclude that it is not possible to derive a general local gravitational stability criterion valid for an arbitrary hydrostatic background; however, in the local short-wavelength limit, the standard Jeans criterion remains valid.
Versions
Related
- Exact spherical-wave forward model for radio reflection from stratified media and implications for the anomalous-polarity events observed by ANITA
- Testing the Isothermal Jeans Model for Self-interacting Dark Matter Halos in the Collapse Phase
- Derivation of OH sum rules without Rayleigh--Jeans approximation: a powerful tool for measuring the variation of fundamental physical constants
- Accuracy of electric current inference assuming three-dimensional hydrostatic equilibrium
- UDCT v7.06 - sign audit of a Hessian term absent from the standard MOND equation: action-consistent virial work and conditional Jeans tests in three ultra-faint dwarfs
BibTeX
@misc{roshan2026jeans,
title = {{Jeans criterion in hydrostatic stratified media}},
author = {Mahmood Roshan and Asiyeh Habibi},
howpublished = {arXiv},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
doi = {10.48550/arxiv.2607.23656},
eprint = {2607.23656},
archivePrefix = {arXiv},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.23656},
}
RIS
TY - UNPB
TI - Jeans criterion in hydrostatic stratified media
AU - Mahmood Roshan
AU - Asiyeh Habibi
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/09/09
PB - arXiv
DO - 10.48550/arxiv.2607.23656
UR - https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.23656
AB - The classical Jeans stability criterion neglects spatial gradients in background physical quantities such as density and pressure. Here, we revisit the Jeans analysis for a non-rotating fluid in hydrostatic equilibrium, explicitly accounting for these gradients and deriving a modified dispersion relation governing perturbation propagation. Using physical arguments, we show why the Jeans swindle is not required to derive the Jeans criterion for perturbations that are small compared to the size of the host system. We use linear perturbation analysis alongside an averaging procedure to study the behavior of the local Eulerian perturbations in a hydrostatic medium, showing that background gradients enter the dispersion relation in a highly non-trivial manner, precluding the derivation of a general gravitational stability criterion applicable to an arbitrary hydrostatic system. We demonstrate that, in the local short-wavelength limit, the standard Jeans criterion remains valid despite the presence of nonzero background gradients, and that all local perturbations in a hydrostatic system are stable against local gravitational collapse. We conclude that it is not possible to derive a general local gravitational stability criterion valid for an arbitrary hydrostatic background; however, in the local short-wavelength limit, the standard Jeans criterion remains valid.
ER -