Respectful maternity care among midwifery graduates trained under competency-based versus conventional curricula in Ethiopia: a comparative cross-sectional study.
5 affiliations
- 1CIH LMU, Center for International Health, LMU University Hospital, LMU Munich, Leopoldstraße 5, München, 80802, Germany. [email protected].
- 2Educational Development and Quality Centre (EDQC), University of Global Health Equity (UGHE), Kigali, Rwanda. [email protected].
- 3CIH LMU, Center for International Health, LMU University Hospital, LMU Munich, Leopoldstraße 5, München, 80802, Germany.
- 4Institute of Medical Education, LMU University Hospital, LMU Munich, München, Germany.
- 5Health Workforce Initiatives, Mastercard Foundation, Kigali, Rwanda.
Abstract
Background
In Ethiopia, midwifery education emphasizes theory over practice, limiting clinical competence, including professional behaviors. Debre Tabor University (DTU) adopted a competency-based curriculum in 2013 to address this. This study examined whether graduates trained under competency-based and conventional curricula differed in their observed provision of respectful maternity care (RMC).Methods
A comparative cross-sectional study assessed observed mistreatment during care provided by 68 BSc midwifery graduates (32 trained under a competency-based curriculum and 36 under a conventional curriculum) from third-generation Ethiopian universities. Care was assessed through direct observation using a validated tool. Mean mistreatment scores were compared using t-tests, and the between-group difference was visualised using a Gardner-Altman plot.Results
Overall, the mean mistreatment score was 34.6%. Conventional curriculum graduates had a higher mean score than competency-based curriculum graduates (38.1% versus 30.8%). The difference was statistically significant, t(66) = - 3.75, p < .001, with an absolute mean difference of 7.3% points and Cohen's d = - 0.91 for competency-based versus conventional graduates. Descriptively, poor-rapport scores (36.7% versus 46.5%) and non-response to medical requests (15.6% versus 30.5%) were lower in the competency-based group. Both groups had recorded deficiencies in consent, supportive care, and privacy, as well as instances of verbal abuse.Conclusion
Competency-based curriculum background was associated with lower observed mean mistreatment scores during labour and childbirth. This association does not establish a causal curriculum effect, and lower mistreatment scores do not demonstrate comprehensive RMC. Deficiencies observed in both groups warrant further attention. Longitudinal and multilevel research is needed to examine the contributions of preservice education and workplace conditions.
Related
- Evaluation of a Respectful Maternity Care Train-the-Trainer Workshop
- Advancing Respectful Maternity Care: co-developing the RESPECT National Strategy in Cyprus
- Respectful maternity care and its determinants in public health facilities of thar desert district, India: a mixed methods approach.
- Structural characteristics of maternity care institutions and midwifery workforce capacity: a cross-sectional study from Switzerland
- Evaluation of Tooth Shade Selection With Conventional Methods and Artificial Intelligence-Integrated Methods: A Comparative Study
BibTeX
@article{wondie2026respectful,
title = {{Respectful maternity care among midwifery graduates trained under competency-based versus conventional curricula in Ethiopia: a comparative cross-sectional study.}},
author = {Awoke Giletew Wondie and Matthias Siebeck and Tegbar Yigzaw Sendekie and Martin R Fischer and Markus Berndt},
journal = {BMC medical education},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.1186/s12909-026-10661-5},
url = {https://europepmc.org/article/MED/42928218},
note = {CC BY},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Respectful maternity care among midwifery graduates trained under competency-based versus conventional curricula in Ethiopia: a comparative cross-sectional study.
AU - Awoke Giletew Wondie
AU - Matthias Siebeck
AU - Tegbar Yigzaw Sendekie
AU - Martin R Fischer
AU - Markus Berndt
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/24
JO - BMC medical education
DO - 10.1186/s12909-026-10661-5
UR - https://europepmc.org/article/MED/42928218
AB - Background In Ethiopia, midwifery education emphasizes theory over practice, limiting clinical competence, including professional behaviors. Debre Tabor University (DTU) adopted a competency-based curriculum in 2013 to address this. This study examined whether graduates trained under competency-based and conventional curricula differed in their observed provision of respectful maternity care (RMC).Methods A comparative cross-sectional study assessed observed mistreatment during care provided by 68 BSc midwifery graduates (32 trained under a competency-based curriculum and 36 under a conventional curriculum) from third-generation Ethiopian universities. Care was assessed through direct observation using a validated tool. Mean mistreatment scores were compared using t-tests, and the between-group difference was visualised using a Gardner-Altman plot.Results Overall, the mean mistreatment score was 34.6%. Conventional curriculum graduates had a higher mean score than competency-based curriculum graduates (38.1% versus 30.8%). The difference was statistically significant, t(66) = - 3.75, p < .001, with an absolute mean difference of 7.3% points and Cohen's d = - 0.91 for competency-based versus conventional graduates. Descriptively, poor-rapport scores (36.7% versus 46.5%) and non-response to medical requests (15.6% versus 30.5%) were lower in the competency-based group. Both groups had recorded deficiencies in consent, supportive care, and privacy, as well as instances of verbal abuse.Conclusion Competency-based curriculum background was associated with lower observed mean mistreatment scores during labour and childbirth. This association does not establish a causal curriculum effect, and lower mistreatment scores do not demonstrate comprehensive RMC. Deficiencies observed in both groups warrant further attention. Longitudinal and multilevel research is needed to examine the contributions of preservice education and workplace conditions.
SN - 1472-6920
ER -