Strict ontogenetic control rather than environmental plasticity drives colour morph stability in the common wall lizard
- 1Università degli Studi di Pavia
- 2Museo di Storia Naturale di Milano
- 3Museo di Storia Naturale, Università di Pisa
Abstract
Understanding whether colour polymorphisms reflect fixed developmental programs or plastic phenotypic transitions is central to explaining how these systems are maintained through time. Here, we used a four-year capture-recapture dataset to test if adult common wall lizards (Podarcis muralis) exhibit plastic colour transitions or instead follow a fixed developmental program. Using standardized digital photography and Residual Randomization Permutation Procedures , we evaluated the hue and saturation variation across 167 adult individuals (216 transition events). Our results reveal an exceptional degree of categorical stability, with 97.7% of individuals retaining their discrete colour morph among captures; the rare transitions observed were exclusively unidirectional, involving initially white individuals acquiring pigmentation. Although individual identity accounts for a substantial portion of spectral variation, within-individual differences in hue and saturation are modest and do not allow reliable discrimination among individuals within morphs. However, measurable within-individual variation in colour properties is still present across captures. Phenotypic trajectory analysis demonstrated that as individuals grow, morphs significantly diverge in both colour intensity and direction. Notably, the yellow morph follows a unique, morph-specific maturation path, suggesting a canalized developmental program that enhances signal clarity with age. Unlike the socially induced and hormonally mediated colour transitions documented in U. stansburiana, the P. muralis system appears driven by a fixed ontogenetic commitment. These findings suggest that this polymorphism is maintained by a robust genetic architecture where adult maturation might serve to minimize cross-talk among socio-sexual signals. Highlighting the analysis of adult ontogenetic trajectories as a vital practical tool for deciphering the evolution of complex biological polymorphisms.
Related
- The role of environmental gradients in the ontogenetic shift of wood traits from seedlings to adults in two temperate tree species
- The environmental stress σ subunits render M. tuberculosis RNA polymerase resistant to fidaxomicin by restricting its binding pocket conformational plasticity
- Tracking interannual temperature variation: phenological plasticity and reproductive stability in tropical hornbills
- Conceptualising and quantifying phenological plasticity through latent responses to seasonal environmental progression
- Differing components of plasticity in quantitative genetic threshold traits cause diverging eco-evolutionary responses to spatio-seasonal environmental deterioration
BibTeX
@article{sacchi2026strict,
title = {{Strict ontogenetic control rather than environmental plasticity drives colour morph stability in the common wall lizard}},
author = {Roberto Sacchi and Stefano Scali and Marco A. L. Zuffi and Marco Mangiacotti},
journal = {Scientific Reports},
year = {2026},
month = jul,
doi = {10.1038/s41598-026-63075-0},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-63075-0},
note = {CC BY},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Strict ontogenetic control rather than environmental plasticity drives colour morph stability in the common wall lizard
AU - Roberto Sacchi
AU - Stefano Scali
AU - Marco A. L. Zuffi
AU - Marco Mangiacotti
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/07/01
JO - Scientific Reports
DO - 10.1038/s41598-026-63075-0
UR - https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-63075-0
AB - Understanding whether colour polymorphisms reflect fixed developmental programs or plastic phenotypic transitions is central to explaining how these systems are maintained through time. Here, we used a four-year capture-recapture dataset to test if adult common wall lizards (Podarcis muralis) exhibit plastic colour transitions or instead follow a fixed developmental program. Using standardized digital photography and Residual Randomization Permutation Procedures , we evaluated the hue and saturation variation across 167 adult individuals (216 transition events). Our results reveal an exceptional degree of categorical stability, with 97.7% of individuals retaining their discrete colour morph among captures; the rare transitions observed were exclusively unidirectional, involving initially white individuals acquiring pigmentation. Although individual identity accounts for a substantial portion of spectral variation, within-individual differences in hue and saturation are modest and do not allow reliable discrimination among individuals within morphs. However, measurable within-individual variation in colour properties is still present across captures. Phenotypic trajectory analysis demonstrated that as individuals grow, morphs significantly diverge in both colour intensity and direction. Notably, the yellow morph follows a unique, morph-specific maturation path, suggesting a canalized developmental program that enhances signal clarity with age. Unlike the socially induced and hormonally mediated colour transitions documented in U. stansburiana, the P. muralis system appears driven by a fixed ontogenetic commitment. These findings suggest that this polymorphism is maintained by a robust genetic architecture where adult maturation might serve to minimize cross-talk among socio-sexual signals. Highlighting the analysis of adult ontogenetic trajectories as a vital practical tool for deciphering the evolution of complex biological polymorphisms.
SN - 2045-2322
ER -