Isolating domain-specific and domain-general contributions to global confidence
Abstract
While metacognition - our ability to evaluate our own cognitive processes - has been extensively studied by measuring trial-by-trial self-assessments of task performance (local confidence), real-world decisions often require a broader perspective, drawing on evaluations of performance over wider timespans (global confidence). Despite its pervasive influence on decision-making and mental health, it remains unknown whether global confidence is formed through similar or distinct processes across cognitive domains. Here we employ a novel gamified approach to compare how global confidence is formed in the domains of memory and perception. In memory, we found that both local accuracy and confidence contributed to global confidence, whereas in perception, global confidence was predicted by local confidence alone. By comparing the formation of global confidence across domains, our study provides new insights into the mechanisms underpinning self-evaluation, paving the way for the development of metacognitive interventions in education and psychiatry.
Related
- Domain-specific and domain-general signatures of dyscalculia in computational models of behavior and parietal cortex
- Looking Across Tasks: Domain-General and Task-Specific Gaze Behaviours in Spatial Cognition
- Task-specific theta enhancement and domain-general alpha/beta suppression as oscillatory signatures of cognitive flexibility.
- Benchmarking interface confidence as a selection criterion for computational nanobody design against survivin's BIR-domain groove
- Cross-domain confidence reliability and remappability of frozen single-cell representations
BibTeX
@misc{bavard2026isolating,
title = {{Isolating domain-specific and domain-general contributions to global confidence}},
author = {Sophie Bavard and Andrew McWilliams and Flora Chartier and Karim N'DIAYE and Stephen Fleming and Marion Rouault},
howpublished = {PsyArXiv},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.31234/osf.io/6t9qg_v3},
url = {https://osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/6t9qg_v3/},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - UNPB
TI - Isolating domain-specific and domain-general contributions to global confidence
AU - Sophie Bavard
AU - Andrew McWilliams
AU - Flora Chartier
AU - Karim N'DIAYE
AU - Stephen Fleming
AU - Marion Rouault
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/05
PB - PsyArXiv
DO - 10.31234/osf.io/6t9qg_v3
UR - https://osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/6t9qg_v3/
AB - While metacognition - our ability to evaluate our own cognitive processes - has been extensively studied by measuring trial-by-trial self-assessments of task performance (local confidence), real-world decisions often require a broader perspective, drawing on evaluations of performance over wider timespans (global confidence). Despite its pervasive influence on decision-making and mental health, it remains unknown whether global confidence is formed through similar or distinct processes across cognitive domains. Here we employ a novel gamified approach to compare how global confidence is formed in the domains of memory and perception. In memory, we found that both local accuracy and confidence contributed to global confidence, whereas in perception, global confidence was predicted by local confidence alone. By comparing the formation of global confidence across domains, our study provides new insights into the mechanisms underpinning self-evaluation, paving the way for the development of metacognitive interventions in education and psychiatry.
ER -