Evidence of within- and between-stock connectivity in Mediterranean fisheries challenges the stock unit paradigm
Abstract
Achieving sustainable management of marine resources and implementing biologically realistic assessment depend on accurate identification of stock structure. Most harvested marine species are currently assessed under the common and long-standing assumption of "stock unit" within designated spatiotemporally invariant polygons known as assessment units, despite evidence of passive and/or active dispersal across multiple scales. Our objective here is to investigate the connectivity and spatial structure of red mullet (Mullus barbatus) metapopulation system in the Northwestern Mediterranean Sea and compare the delineation of assessment units with biological units. To achieve this, we integrate simulated larval dispersal modelling with tissue stable isotope analysis, encompassing the entire life cycle. We observe misalignment between the present "closed" assessment units and the identified biologically informed units. The identified metapopulation system comprises northern and southern subpopulations with dissimilar demographic roles. This principally stems from the Northern Current mediated larval transport from high-density persistent spawning grounds and, secondarily, likely from the regional differences in the isotopic baseline associated with different productivity regimes. Such an interdisciplinary approach is of elevated importance for species with stark differences across their life history, such as red mullet. Moreover, larval connectivity diagnostics successfully capture the interannual variability of recruitment dynamics of this complex stock, evidencing the capacity of biophysical models to inform fisheries assessment and management. This study highlights the importance of implementing spatial stock assessment frameworks that rely on critical, yet still largely disregarded, ecological information.
Related
- Mapping bycatch risk hotspots for marine megafauna in the Mediterranean: contrasting artisanal and industrial fisheries
- Contribution of Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) towards ecosystem services and fisheries: An experts’ perspective from Mediterranean MPAs
- Optimising Connectivity in Deep‐Sea MPA Networks for Nephrops norvegicus Recovery in NW Mediterranean Sea
- Evidence mapping of the causes and effects of habitat change attributed to offshore wind development is important for determining impacts on fisheries species
- Advancing knowledge on biodiversity-driven ecological connectivity at sea and across the land–sea interface: challenges and future directions
BibTeX
@article{kerametsidis2026evidence,
title = {{Evidence of within- and between-stock connectivity in Mediterranean fisheries challenges the stock unit paradigm}},
author = {Georgios Kerametsidis and Manuel Hidalgo and Baptiste Mourre and Enrico Ser-Giacomi and Lucía López-López and Antonio Esteban and Encarnación García and Miguel Vivas and Angelique Jadaud and Gregoire Certain and Vincent Rossi},
journal = {Scientific Reports},
year = {2026},
month = nov,
doi = {10.1038/s41598-026-47826-7},
url = {https://hal.science/hal-05854057v1},
note = {CC BY},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Evidence of within- and between-stock connectivity in Mediterranean fisheries challenges the stock unit paradigm
AU - Georgios Kerametsidis
AU - Manuel Hidalgo
AU - Baptiste Mourre
AU - Enrico Ser-Giacomi
AU - Lucía López-López
AU - Antonio Esteban
AU - Encarnación García
AU - Miguel Vivas
AU - Angelique Jadaud
AU - Gregoire Certain
AU - Vincent Rossi
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/11/05
JO - Scientific Reports
DO - 10.1038/s41598-026-47826-7
UR - https://hal.science/hal-05854057v1
AB - Achieving sustainable management of marine resources and implementing biologically realistic assessment depend on accurate identification of stock structure. Most harvested marine species are currently assessed under the common and long-standing assumption of "stock unit" within designated spatiotemporally invariant polygons known as assessment units, despite evidence of passive and/or active dispersal across multiple scales. Our objective here is to investigate the connectivity and spatial structure of red mullet (Mullus barbatus) metapopulation system in the Northwestern Mediterranean Sea and compare the delineation of assessment units with biological units. To achieve this, we integrate simulated larval dispersal modelling with tissue stable isotope analysis, encompassing the entire life cycle. We observe misalignment between the present "closed" assessment units and the identified biologically informed units. The identified metapopulation system comprises northern and southern subpopulations with dissimilar demographic roles. This principally stems from the Northern Current mediated larval transport from high-density persistent spawning grounds and, secondarily, likely from the regional differences in the isotopic baseline associated with different productivity regimes. Such an interdisciplinary approach is of elevated importance for species with stark differences across their life history, such as red mullet. Moreover, larval connectivity diagnostics successfully capture the interannual variability of recruitment dynamics of this complex stock, evidencing the capacity of biophysical models to inform fisheries assessment and management. This study highlights the importance of implementing spatial stock assessment frameworks that rely on critical, yet still largely disregarded, ecological information.
SN - 2045-2322
ER -