The present does not reflect the past: geographic mismatches between fossil and modern records are widespread across the tree of life.
- 1Department of Earth Sciences, University of Oxford , Oxford, UK.
Abstract
The distribution of organisms across Earth provides insight into the origin and maintenance of biodiversity. Abundant fossil evidence suggests taxa have undergone substantial range changes over time. However, biogeographic theory and models often tend to assume that clades originated in the regions where we observe them today. Understanding the prevalence of geographically dynamic clades across the tree of life provides a way to evaluate these assumptions, thereby refining key evolutionary hypotheses. We provide a review of such range-shifting clades using a two-pronged approach. First, literature searches uncovered examples across most major multicellular groups (comprising 129 clades with mismatches between fossil and modern ranges). Concurrently, we used the well-sampled mammalian fossil record as a case study, finding that more than half of its terrestrial families (51%) had substantial (>1000 km) geographic mismatches. Geographically dynamic lineages are both common and widespread, but despite their ubiquity, fossil-modern mismatches have only recently been integrated into phylogenetic and biogeographic methods and no comprehensive overview of their advantages and challenges exists. We therefore review the current state of the field and discuss case studies where fossil evidence reshaped prevailing biogeographic theory. Biogeographers must take advantage of these rich fossil histories to better elucidate evolutionary theory across space and time.
Related
- Spike-wave discharges reflect widespread, but non-uniform, cortical hypersynchrony during immobility
- Some temporal and geographic records of Abatus species (Echinoidea, Schizasteridae) in Antarctic and Subantarctic environments.
- Do Harbour Porpoise Mortality Records Reflect Living Population Structure? A Matrix Population Model Diagnostic
- Assessing the Potential Distribution of Eriocheir sinensis Under Climate Change: Regional Contrasts and Spatial Mismatches in Terrestrial and Nearshore Suitability
- Increased activity without changes in coupling between somata and apical dendrites during visual mismatches
BibTeX
@article{shipley2026present,
title = {{The present does not reflect the past: geographic mismatches between fossil and modern records are widespread across the tree of life.}},
author = {Benjamin R Shipley and Erin E Saupe},
journal = {Proceedings. Biological sciences},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.1098/rspb.2026.1431},
url = {https://europepmc.org/article/MED/42901521},
note = {CC BY},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - The present does not reflect the past: geographic mismatches between fossil and modern records are widespread across the tree of life.
AU - Benjamin R Shipley
AU - Erin E Saupe
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/01
JO - Proceedings. Biological sciences
DO - 10.1098/rspb.2026.1431
UR - https://europepmc.org/article/MED/42901521
AB - The distribution of organisms across Earth provides insight into the origin and maintenance of biodiversity. Abundant fossil evidence suggests taxa have undergone substantial range changes over time. However, biogeographic theory and models often tend to assume that clades originated in the regions where we observe them today. Understanding the prevalence of geographically dynamic clades across the tree of life provides a way to evaluate these assumptions, thereby refining key evolutionary hypotheses. We provide a review of such range-shifting clades using a two-pronged approach. First, literature searches uncovered examples across most major multicellular groups (comprising 129 clades with mismatches between fossil and modern ranges). Concurrently, we used the well-sampled mammalian fossil record as a case study, finding that more than half of its terrestrial families (51%) had substantial (>1000 km) geographic mismatches. Geographically dynamic lineages are both common and widespread, but despite their ubiquity, fossil-modern mismatches have only recently been integrated into phylogenetic and biogeographic methods and no comprehensive overview of their advantages and challenges exists. We therefore review the current state of the field and discuss case studies where fossil evidence reshaped prevailing biogeographic theory. Biogeographers must take advantage of these rich fossil histories to better elucidate evolutionary theory across space and time.
SN - 0962-8452
SN - 1471-2954
ER -