Association between preferred and documented mode of birth and birth experiences in low- and middle-income countries: a multisite cross-sectional study
Abstract
Rationale and objectives: Unmet birth expectations can affect birth experiences and satisfaction with care (BES). In low-and middle-income countries (LMICs), rising caesarean section (CS) rates may widen mode of birth (MOB) preferences and clinical decisions gaps. We describe matches between MOB preferences and the MOB documented in medical records, and assess whether such matches were associated with BES. Methods: We pooled data from two cross-sectional surveys in 32 hospitals in Argentina, Burkina Faso, Thailand, and Viet Nam (QUALI-DEC project). Postpartum women retrospectively reported the MOB they had preferred during late pregnancy. We assessed separately whether women's preferred MOB matched the initiated and actual MOB documented in medical records. We measured BES using the QUALI-DEC Birth Experience and Satisfaction scale, and computed overall and dimension-specific BES scores. Associations between preferred-documented MOB matches and BES scores were estimated using multilevel multivariable linear regression, adjusted for confounders, clustering, and selection bias. Findings: Of 3228 women with a MOB preference, preferred-documented MOB match rates were high for both initiated (92.0%) and actual (78.0%) MOB. Women preferring vaginal birth (VB) more often had an initiated (98.0%) and actual (81.0%) VB; those preferring CS less often had a matching prelabour CS (33.0%) or actual CS (57.0%). Matches were modestly associated with higher overall and dimension-specific BES scores, regardless of preference for VB or CS. Conclusions: Findings suggest matches between women’s preferences and documented MOB may be relevant to understanding variation in BES. Additional research is needed to further clarify these associations in LMICs.
Related
- Preferred visual experiences provide intuitive descriptions of the functional properties of the cortical navigation network
- Association between early post-insertion arterial oxygen tension and documented acute upper-body deep or central venous thrombosis in critically ill adults: A retrospective MIMIC-IV cohort study
- The moderating role of impulsivity in the association between sexual abuse and substance use frequency across countries, gender identities, and sexual orientations
- Association between nirsevimab coverage and pediatric emergency department visits for bronchiolitis in 12 European countries: An interrupted time-series analysis
- Positive Selection Drives Preferred Segment Combinations during Influenza Virus Reassortment
BibTeX
@article{vololonarivelo2026association,
title = {{Association between preferred and documented mode of birth and birth experiences in low- and middle-income countries: a multisite cross-sectional study}},
author = {Barbara Elyan Edwige Vololonarivelo and Ana Pilar Betrán and Meghan A Bohren and Claudia Hanson and Pisake Lumbiganon and Charles Kaboré and Guillermo Carroli and Camille Etcheverry and Truc Phuong Nguyen and Cristina Lumia and Majda Hamrit and Celina Gialdini and Ramon Escuriet and Quoc Nhu Hung Mac and Alexandre Dumont},
journal = {Midwifery},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
doi = {10.1016/j.midw.2026.104991},
url = {https://u-paris.hal.science/hal-05774053v1},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Association between preferred and documented mode of birth and birth experiences in low- and middle-income countries: a multisite cross-sectional study
AU - Barbara Elyan Edwige Vololonarivelo
AU - Ana Pilar Betrán
AU - Meghan A Bohren
AU - Claudia Hanson
AU - Pisake Lumbiganon
AU - Charles Kaboré
AU - Guillermo Carroli
AU - Camille Etcheverry
AU - Truc Phuong Nguyen
AU - Cristina Lumia
AU - Majda Hamrit
AU - Celina Gialdini
AU - Ramon Escuriet
AU - Quoc Nhu Hung Mac
AU - Alexandre Dumont
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/09/18
JO - Midwifery
DO - 10.1016/j.midw.2026.104991
UR - https://u-paris.hal.science/hal-05774053v1
AB - Rationale and objectives: Unmet birth expectations can affect birth experiences and satisfaction with care (BES). In low-and middle-income countries (LMICs), rising caesarean section (CS) rates may widen mode of birth (MOB) preferences and clinical decisions gaps. We describe matches between MOB preferences and the MOB documented in medical records, and assess whether such matches were associated with BES. Methods: We pooled data from two cross-sectional surveys in 32 hospitals in Argentina, Burkina Faso, Thailand, and Viet Nam (QUALI-DEC project). Postpartum women retrospectively reported the MOB they had preferred during late pregnancy. We assessed separately whether women's preferred MOB matched the initiated and actual MOB documented in medical records. We measured BES using the QUALI-DEC Birth Experience and Satisfaction scale, and computed overall and dimension-specific BES scores. Associations between preferred-documented MOB matches and BES scores were estimated using multilevel multivariable linear regression, adjusted for confounders, clustering, and selection bias. Findings: Of 3228 women with a MOB preference, preferred-documented MOB match rates were high for both initiated (92.0%) and actual (78.0%) MOB. Women preferring vaginal birth (VB) more often had an initiated (98.0%) and actual (81.0%) VB; those preferring CS less often had a matching prelabour CS (33.0%) or actual CS (57.0%). Matches were modestly associated with higher overall and dimension-specific BES scores, regardless of preference for VB or CS. Conclusions: Findings suggest matches between women’s preferences and documented MOB may be relevant to understanding variation in BES. Additional research is needed to further clarify these associations in LMICs.
SN - 0266-6138
ER -