Bell scenarios encode classical non-causality
Abstract
Bell and contextuality scenarios are unified within the Acín-Fritz-Leverrier-Sainz hypergraph formalism, in which measurements are hyperedges. Multipartite measurements are obtained from product rules that combine independent contextuality scenarios into a single hypergraph. Several such rules exist: they are structurally distinct, yet yield the same classical, quantum, and boxworld correlations. Here, we show that this difference is not incidental, unveiling an unexpected connection. The measurements of composite Bell scenarios are exactly the process functions, the deterministic classical communication protocols that may be non-causal, i.e., lack a definite causal order without generating paradoxes. Validity of a hyperedge and logical consistency of a process function are thus one and the same condition. This allows us to characterize process functions by normalization and no-signaling alone, providing transformations that generate non-causal process functions from no-communication ones. The product rules, in turn, order process functions by causal structure, from no-communication to non-causality, which yields a graphical criterion for the latter: a process function is non-causal precisely when its hyperedge is generated by the disjunctive but not the maximal product. We thereby obtain the first joint hypergraph representation of (non-causal) process functions and (nonlocal-without-entanglement) measurements, recasting classical non-causality as a non-standard way of composing black boxes.
Related
- Information Causality Characterizes the Set of Quantum Correlations in the Simplest Bell Scenario
- Detectability of Post-Quantum Correlations in Symmetry-Restricted Bell Scenarios
- Bell's go theorem: regaining local causality with a new notion of realism
- QEncodeBench: Can Large Language Models Encode Classical Problems into Verified Quantum Oracles?
- Quantum communication and Bell nonlocality require infinite classical communication to simulate
BibTeX
@misc{leitherer2026bell,
title = {{Bell scenarios encode classical non-causality}},
author = {Andreas Leitherer and Kyrylo Simonov and Ravi Kunjwal and Antonio Acín and Kuntal Sengupta and Hippolyte Dourdent},
howpublished = {arXiv},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.48550/arxiv.2610.23367},
eprint = {2610.23367},
archivePrefix = {arXiv},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.23367},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - UNPB
TI - Bell scenarios encode classical non-causality
AU - Andreas Leitherer
AU - Kyrylo Simonov
AU - Ravi Kunjwal
AU - Antonio Acín
AU - Kuntal Sengupta
AU - Hippolyte Dourdent
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/16
PB - arXiv
DO - 10.48550/arxiv.2610.23367
UR - https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.23367
AB - Bell and contextuality scenarios are unified within the Acín-Fritz-Leverrier-Sainz hypergraph formalism, in which measurements are hyperedges. Multipartite measurements are obtained from product rules that combine independent contextuality scenarios into a single hypergraph. Several such rules exist: they are structurally distinct, yet yield the same classical, quantum, and boxworld correlations. Here, we show that this difference is not incidental, unveiling an unexpected connection. The measurements of composite Bell scenarios are exactly the process functions, the deterministic classical communication protocols that may be non-causal, i.e., lack a definite causal order without generating paradoxes. Validity of a hyperedge and logical consistency of a process function are thus one and the same condition. This allows us to characterize process functions by normalization and no-signaling alone, providing transformations that generate non-causal process functions from no-communication ones. The product rules, in turn, order process functions by causal structure, from no-communication to non-causality, which yields a graphical criterion for the latter: a process function is non-causal precisely when its hyperedge is generated by the disjunctive but not the maximal product. We thereby obtain the first joint hypergraph representation of (non-causal) process functions and (nonlocal-without-entanglement) measurements, recasting classical non-causality as a non-standard way of composing black boxes.
ER -