Large Scale Expansion of Organic Farming at Risk of Phosphorus Limitation in the Long Run
Abstract
Debates about the agronomic feasibility of feeding the world organically have often focused on potential nitrogen (N) limitations, overlooking the challenges raised by the availability of phosphorus (P) in soils. Here we address this missing piece by simulating, over a 100‐year time span, a 100% organic world, in which mineral fertilizers are banned. We show that, in the short term, soil available P would barely limit organic crop production due to (i) existing soil P stocks, (ii) a replenishment of the available P pool by more stable pools, and (iii) a strong N limitation that reduces crop yields and consequently plant P demand. Conversely, in the long term (~100 years), the simulated 60% drop in cropland soil available P would result in a −12% reduction in cropland production globally, ranging from −4% in Eastern Europe to −29% in Latin America. This P limitation would be greater in places with high yields and a high proportion of legumes in crop rotations, highlighting the need to address N‐P interactions simultaneously to design more sustainable food systems. The expansion of organic farming therefore runs the risk of slowly but surely depleting soil P unless measures are taken to recycle all P flows within the agri‐food system.
Related
- Global compilation of in situ particulate organic carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus concentrations in coastal and open ocean waters
- Beyond growth limitation: rethinking carbon dynamics at the alpine treeline. A commentary on ‘The role of elevation, tree height and crown position on the carbon balance of trees at the southern Andes treeline’
- Dry Farming in the Great Basin
- Engineering perspectives on salt-induced transport limitation in saline aquifers: implications for long-term CO2 storage security
- Land suitability analysis for taro (Colocasia esculenta) cultivation based on topo-edaphic variables in a smallholder farming system
BibTeX
@article{demay2026large,
title = {{Large Scale Expansion of Organic Farming at Risk of Phosphorus Limitation in the Long Run}},
author = {Josephine Demay and Bruno Ringeval and Pietro Barbieri and Sylvain Pellerin and Thomas Nesme},
journal = {Global Change Biology},
year = {2026},
month = aug,
doi = {10.1111/gcb.71067},
url = {https://hal.inrae.fr/hal-05787085v1},
note = {CC BY-NC 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Large Scale Expansion of Organic Farming at Risk of Phosphorus Limitation in the Long Run
AU - Josephine Demay
AU - Bruno Ringeval
AU - Pietro Barbieri
AU - Sylvain Pellerin
AU - Thomas Nesme
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/08/26
JO - Global Change Biology
DO - 10.1111/gcb.71067
UR - https://hal.inrae.fr/hal-05787085v1
AB - Debates about the agronomic feasibility of feeding the world organically have often focused on potential nitrogen (N) limitations, overlooking the challenges raised by the availability of phosphorus (P) in soils. Here we address this missing piece by simulating, over a 100‐year time span, a 100% organic world, in which mineral fertilizers are banned. We show that, in the short term, soil available P would barely limit organic crop production due to (i) existing soil P stocks, (ii) a replenishment of the available P pool by more stable pools, and (iii) a strong N limitation that reduces crop yields and consequently plant P demand. Conversely, in the long term (~100 years), the simulated 60% drop in cropland soil available P would result in a −12% reduction in cropland production globally, ranging from −4% in Eastern Europe to −29% in Latin America. This P limitation would be greater in places with high yields and a high proportion of legumes in crop rotations, highlighting the need to address N‐P interactions simultaneously to design more sustainable food systems. The expansion of organic farming therefore runs the risk of slowly but surely depleting soil P unless measures are taken to recycle all P flows within the agri‐food system.
SN - 1354-1013
SN - 1365-2486
ER -