Rethinking hydrothermal vents: a structural ecology perspective on the early emergence of metabolic roles
- 1Institute for Integrated Radiation and Nuclear Science, Kyoto University, 2 Asashiro-Nishi, Kumatori-cho, Sennan-gun, Osaka, 590-0494 Japan
Abstract
Hydrothermal vents are widely considered plausible settings for the origin of life, owing to their steep redox gradients and the availability of chemical energy. Their capacity to support organic synthesis, molecular retention, and breakdown varies with local conditions. Here, I propose a conceptual framework for assessing whether connected environments could support complementary prebiotic chemical functions. Hydrothermal systems may contribute to the breakdown and reuse of supplied organic compounds alongside their constructive roles, while ice–water interfaces may support concentration, selected synthetic reactions, and product retention when suitable reactants are available. Producer-like, consumer-like, and decomposer-like functions are used as nonexclusive analogies for chemical production, use of supplied organic compounds, and breakdown yielding potentially reusable products; they do not denote demonstrated abiotic metabolisms. The central hypothesis is that life’s beginnings may have depended partly on transitions between environments, rather than on processes within any single environment alone. This proposal can be assessed by comparing coupled and isolated reaction systems for product survival, reuse, and sustained reaction activity. The article presents no new experimental validation, and neither the proposed environmental connections nor their contribution to the emergence of heritable metabolism or the last universal common ancestor is established.
Related
- Intermediate stages in the origin of metabolism at a phosphorylating hydrothermal vent
- How nanoscale physics shapes ice formation in the Universe. Rethinking gas freeze-out on dust grains
- Rethinking Domain Specialization for Open-Ended Scientific Reasoning in Astronomy Language Models
- Rethinking Regolith Strength: Why Nonlinearity Matters on Small Bodies
- How nanoscale physics shapes ice formation in the Universe: Rethinking gas freeze-out on dust grains
BibTeX
@article{kato2026rethinking,
title = {{Rethinking hydrothermal vents: a structural ecology perspective on the early emergence of metabolic roles}},
author = {Shinya Kato},
journal = {Die Naturwissenschaften},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.1007/s00114-026-02189-x},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1007/s00114-026-02189-x},
note = {CC BY-NC-ND 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Rethinking hydrothermal vents: a structural ecology perspective on the early emergence of metabolic roles
AU - Shinya Kato
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/27
JO - Die Naturwissenschaften
DO - 10.1007/s00114-026-02189-x
UR - https://doi.org/10.1007/s00114-026-02189-x
AB - Hydrothermal vents are widely considered plausible settings for the origin of life, owing to their steep redox gradients and the availability of chemical energy. Their capacity to support organic synthesis, molecular retention, and breakdown varies with local conditions. Here, I propose a conceptual framework for assessing whether connected environments could support complementary prebiotic chemical functions. Hydrothermal systems may contribute to the breakdown and reuse of supplied organic compounds alongside their constructive roles, while ice–water interfaces may support concentration, selected synthetic reactions, and product retention when suitable reactants are available. Producer-like, consumer-like, and decomposer-like functions are used as nonexclusive analogies for chemical production, use of supplied organic compounds, and breakdown yielding potentially reusable products; they do not denote demonstrated abiotic metabolisms. The central hypothesis is that life’s beginnings may have depended partly on transitions between environments, rather than on processes within any single environment alone. This proposal can be assessed by comparing coupled and isolated reaction systems for product survival, reuse, and sustained reaction activity. The article presents no new experimental validation, and neither the proposed environmental connections nor their contribution to the emergence of heritable metabolism or the last universal common ancestor is established.
SN - 0028-1042
SN - 1432-1904
ER -