Trigger or driver? Tracing the role of climate variability since the Little Ice Age in the abandonment of mountain villages in the Eastern Pyrenees: evidence from historical documents
Abstract
In recent decades, rural depopulation has emerged as a widespread phenomenon across much of Europe, driven by shared underlying processes but shaped by region-specific dynamics. Understanding how climate variability interacts with socioeconomic dynamics to drive long-term settlement abandonment is critical in the context of current global change. High-mountain regions are particularly sensitive to environmental and social pressures, yet long-term empirical evidence remains limited. This study analyzes 307 abandoned or uninhabited villages out of 1,214 documented settlements in the Eastern Pyrenees (Catalan and Aranese sector) between 1275 and 2024, based on systematic examination of historical records. Abandonment drivers were classified into natural hazards (geological, climatic, and biological), anthropogenic factors (socioeconomic and geopolitical/historical), and unknown causes, allowing a long-term assessment of climate–society interactions across the Little Ice Age (LIA) and the Industrial Era (IE). Anthropogenic factors dominate overall, accounting for 78.2% of abandonment cases, whereas natural hazards represent 12.7%. Although natural hazards played a relatively greater role during the LIA, abandonment peaked during the IE, driven primarily by socioeconomic transformations such as rural exodus, declining accessibility, and economic restructuring. Climate rarely acted as a direct driver but contributed to approximately 15% of cases, often interacting with other stressors. Periods of increased abandonment frequently followed phases of climatic deterioration, suggesting a lagged and indirect influence. These results indicate that climate variability functioned mainly as a vulnerability multiplier rather than as an independent cause of settlement decline. Overall, the present findings challenge deterministic interpretations linking climate directly to depopulation. Instead, they highlight that settlement persistence depended primarily on adaptive capacity and socioeconomic context. This long-term perspective provides a transferable framework for understanding how climate–society interactions shape settlement dynamics and emphasizes that the risk under contemporary climate change also lies in its interaction with existing socioeconomic vulnerabilities.
Related
- Multiple portraits of dry snow avalanche slopes near villages in Nunavik, Canada
- An environmental type-recessiveness framework for the spatial coupling of environmental heterogeneity and ICH recessiveness in Guizhou’s ethnic minority villages, China
- Why Do Farmers Leave Land Idle? Unpacking the Role of Farmland Fragmentation and Mechanization Constraints in Farmland Abandonment Behavior
- BORDER OPTICS : Satellite Verification of India's Vibrant Villages Programme: A Compositing-Window Robustness Assessment of Border-Village Development
- Characteristics and consequences of H2O undersaturation and low melt fertility in mountain belt interiors
BibTeX
@misc{bermejo2026trigger,
title = {{Trigger or driver? Tracing the role of climate variability since the Little Ice Age in the abandonment of mountain villages in the Eastern Pyrenees: evidence from historical documents}},
author = {Mercè Cisneros Bermejo and Dr Agustí Esteban-Amat and Jordi Ibáñez-Insa and Josep Barriendos and Mariano Barriendos and Cristina Simó and Claudi Aventín-Boya and Javier Sigró and Òscar Jané},
howpublished = {EarthArXiv},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.31223/x54b84},
url = {https://eartharxiv.org/repository/view/14135/},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - UNPB
TI - Trigger or driver? Tracing the role of climate variability since the Little Ice Age in the abandonment of mountain villages in the Eastern Pyrenees: evidence from historical documents
AU - Mercè Cisneros Bermejo
AU - Dr Agustí Esteban-Amat
AU - Jordi Ibáñez-Insa
AU - Josep Barriendos
AU - Mariano Barriendos
AU - Cristina Simó
AU - Claudi Aventín-Boya
AU - Javier Sigró
AU - Òscar Jané
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/01
PB - EarthArXiv
DO - 10.31223/x54b84
UR - https://eartharxiv.org/repository/view/14135/
AB - In recent decades, rural depopulation has emerged as a widespread phenomenon across much of Europe, driven by shared underlying processes but shaped by region-specific dynamics. Understanding how climate variability interacts with socioeconomic dynamics to drive long-term settlement abandonment is critical in the context of current global change. High-mountain regions are particularly sensitive to environmental and social pressures, yet long-term empirical evidence remains limited. This study analyzes 307 abandoned or uninhabited villages out of 1,214 documented settlements in the Eastern Pyrenees (Catalan and Aranese sector) between 1275 and 2024, based on systematic examination of historical records. Abandonment drivers were classified into natural hazards (geological, climatic, and biological), anthropogenic factors (socioeconomic and geopolitical/historical), and unknown causes, allowing a long-term assessment of climate–society interactions across the Little Ice Age (LIA) and the Industrial Era (IE). Anthropogenic factors dominate overall, accounting for 78.2% of abandonment cases, whereas natural hazards represent 12.7%. Although natural hazards played a relatively greater role during the LIA, abandonment peaked during the IE, driven primarily by socioeconomic transformations such as rural exodus, declining accessibility, and economic restructuring. Climate rarely acted as a direct driver but contributed to approximately 15% of cases, often interacting with other stressors. Periods of increased abandonment frequently followed phases of climatic deterioration, suggesting a lagged and indirect influence. These results indicate that climate variability functioned mainly as a vulnerability multiplier rather than as an independent cause of settlement decline. Overall, the present findings challenge deterministic interpretations linking climate directly to depopulation. Instead, they highlight that settlement persistence depended primarily on adaptive capacity and socioeconomic context. This long-term perspective provides a transferable framework for understanding how climate–society interactions shape settlement dynamics and emphasizes that the risk under contemporary climate change also lies in its interaction with existing socioeconomic vulnerabilities.
ER -