Tree island area in oil palm agroforests directly and indirectly drives evaporative fraction
- 1University of Göttingen (Göttingen, Germany)
Abstract
Evapotranspiration (ET) – the combined water flux from soil and vegetation to the atmosphere – is a key component of water cycling and climate regulation, and strongly affected by land-use changes. The evaporative fraction (EF), representing the proportion of available energy allocated to ET, is often preferred over ET as a target variable in studies involving repeated measurements under varying weather conditions. In Sumatra's lowlands in Indonesia, (evapo)transpiration of dominant land-use types including oil palm monocultures is well studied; however, there is a lack of studies assessing ET (or EF) across diverse mosaic landscapes and types of land-use such as oil palm agroforests. Across 52 experimental plots – forest restoration patches known as “tree islands” – in an oil palm landscape (EFForTS-BEE), we tested whether the experimental treatments “planted tree diversity” and `tree island area' influence ET and EF as derived from UAV (uncrewed aerial vehicle)-based thermography and subsequent energy balance modeling. A random partition linear model showed that planted tree diversity (1, 2, 3, or 6 species) did not affect plot-level ET or EF, whereas tree island area (25, 100, 400, or 1600 m ² ) had a positive effect, with EF increasing by 17 % from the smallest to the largest tree islands. A structural equation model revealed that the effect of tree island area on EF was mediated by both direct and indirect pathways. Specifically, a strong direct effect of island area on EF (Std.Beta = 0.44, p <0.001) was complemented by an indirect pathway through increased observed woody plant diversity and stand structural complexity. Stand structural complexity had a positive effect on EF (Std.Beta = 0.20, p <0.05), while neither the vegetation index GNDVI nor tree height variability had significant effects. The decrease in EF with increasing distance from the edge within larger tree islands suggests that edge-related spatial variation may be related to, but does not fully explain, the positive area effect. Our findings suggest that larger tree islands enhance ET and EF through structural and biodiversity-related mechanisms. This underscores the importance of tree islands in human-modified landscapes, not only as biodiversity refugia but also as functional elements that support climate regulation.
Versions
Related
- Integrating local and landscape management promotes biodiversity, multifunctionality and yields in tropical agroforests
- Cellulose Fiber Crystallizer for Continuous Evaporative Lithium Enrichment from Low-Quality Brines
- Spatializing Air Conditioner and Evaporative Cooler Ownership, Use, and Inequality across 400+ Districts Pan-India: Unpacking Social, Environmental, and Urbanization Correlates
- Ocean surface currents directly imaged from space
- Accumulation of stranded plastic objects and other artefacts at Inaccessible Island, central South Atlantic Ocean
BibTeX
@article{wintz2026tree,
title = {{Tree island area in oil palm agroforests directly and indirectly drives evaporative fraction}},
author = {Thorge Wintz and Alexander Röll and Gustavo Brant Paterno and Florian Ellsäßer and Delphine Clara Zemp and Hendrayanto and Bambang Irawan and Alexander Knohl and Holger Kreft and Dirk Hölscher},
journal = {Biogeosciences},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.5194/bg-23-7643-2026},
url = {https://bg.copernicus.org/articles/23/7643/2026/},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Tree island area in oil palm agroforests directly and indirectly drives evaporative fraction
AU - Thorge Wintz
AU - Alexander Röll
AU - Gustavo Brant Paterno
AU - Florian Ellsäßer
AU - Delphine Clara Zemp
AU - Hendrayanto
AU - Bambang Irawan
AU - Alexander Knohl
AU - Holger Kreft
AU - Dirk Hölscher
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/30
JO - Biogeosciences
DO - 10.5194/bg-23-7643-2026
UR - https://bg.copernicus.org/articles/23/7643/2026/
AB - Evapotranspiration (ET) – the combined water flux from soil and vegetation to the atmosphere – is a key component of water cycling and climate regulation, and strongly affected by land-use changes. The evaporative fraction (EF), representing the proportion of available energy allocated to ET, is often preferred over ET as a target variable in studies involving repeated measurements under varying weather conditions. In Sumatra's lowlands in Indonesia, (evapo)transpiration of dominant land-use types including oil palm monocultures is well studied; however, there is a lack of studies assessing ET (or EF) across diverse mosaic landscapes and types of land-use such as oil palm agroforests. Across 52 experimental plots – forest restoration patches known as “tree islands” – in an oil palm landscape (EFForTS-BEE), we tested whether the experimental treatments “planted tree diversity” and `tree island area' influence ET and EF as derived from UAV (uncrewed aerial vehicle)-based thermography and subsequent energy balance modeling. A random partition linear model showed that planted tree diversity (1, 2, 3, or 6 species) did not affect plot-level ET or EF, whereas tree island area (25, 100, 400, or 1600 m ² ) had a positive effect, with EF increasing by 17 % from the smallest to the largest tree islands. A structural equation model revealed that the effect of tree island area on EF was mediated by both direct and indirect pathways. Specifically, a strong direct effect of island area on EF (Std.Beta = 0.44, p <0.001) was complemented by an indirect pathway through increased observed woody plant diversity and stand structural complexity. Stand structural complexity had a positive effect on EF (Std.Beta = 0.20, p <0.05), while neither the vegetation index GNDVI nor tree height variability had significant effects. The decrease in EF with increasing distance from the edge within larger tree islands suggests that edge-related spatial variation may be related to, but does not fully explain, the positive area effect. Our findings suggest that larger tree islands enhance ET and EF through structural and biodiversity-related mechanisms. This underscores the importance of tree islands in human-modified landscapes, not only as biodiversity refugia but also as functional elements that support climate regulation.
SN - 1726-4189
ER -