Applications of artificial intelligence in traditional Chinese medicine tongue diagnosis: a bibliometric review of research trends and hotspots, 2015-2026.
- 1Department of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Guangzhou Cadre and Talent Health Management Center, Guangzhou, China.
- 2College of Nursing, Changsha Medical University, Changsha, China.
- 3Imaging Department, Clinical Research Center for Reproduction and Genetics in Hunan Province, Reproductive & Genetic Hospital of CITIC-Xiangya, Changsha, China.
Abstract
Objectives
This study aimed to characterize the development landscape of artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted tongue diagnosis in Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) by comparing publication trends, collaboration patterns, research hotspots, and emerging topics between CNKI-indexed and WoSCC-indexed literature.Methods
Literature published between January 2015 and August 2026 was retrieved from the Web of Science Core Collection (WoSCC) and China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI). Publication trends were summarized descriptively, and CiteSpace and VOSviewer were used for collaboration-network, keyword co-occurrence, clustering, timeline, burst-detection, and journal citation analyses. CNKI-indexed and WoSCC-indexed records were analysed separately because of differences in database coverage, indexing characteristics, metadata structures, and publication practices.Results
A total of 482 studies were included, comprising 295 WoSCC-indexed and 187 CNKI-indexed records. Publication output showed an overall upward trend in both datasets over the study period. The CNKI keyword clustering network showed high clustering quality (modularity Q = 0.7929; weighted mean silhouette S = 0.9413), as did the WoSCC network (Q = 0.8000; S = 0.9239). In CNKI, the strongest keyword bursts included "deep learning" (strength = 2.95), "image segmentation" (2.69), and "transfer learning" (2.61); in WoSCC, prominent bursts included "artificial intelligence" (2.13), "image colour analysis" (2.10), and "machine learning" (1.86). CNKI-indexed literature showed prominent themes involving tongue-image objectification, segmentation, and TCM-oriented diagnostic concepts, whereas WoSCC-indexed literature showed more differentiated themes involving AI architectures, tongue-feature analysis, computational modelling, and disease-related applications. Highly cited publications in both datasets further reflected the importance of tongue-image extraction and segmentation and the subsequent expansion toward disease-oriented modelling. Across both datasets, the temporal patterns suggested a shift in research attention from conventional image processing and feature extraction toward machine learning, deep learning, and more integrated AI-based approaches.Conclusions
The two datasets showed complementary but database-specific thematic structures in AI-assisted tongue diagnosis. Although the literature indicates a shift toward more advanced and disease-oriented AI applications, these bibliometric patterns do not establish the scientific or medical validity, diagnostic accuracy, or clinical readiness of AI-assisted tongue analysis. Further standardization, multicentre external validation, and clinically interpretable and reproducible research are needed before broader clinical application.
Related
- A Bibliometric Analysis of Research on Nursing Diagnosis and Decision Support Systems with Artificial Intelligence (2009-2023)
- Diagnostic accuracy of tongue diagnosis for stroke syndrome differentiation in traditional Chinese medicine: a systematic review, meta-analysis, and narrative synthesis of artificial intelligence-assisted models.
- Latent Profiles of Attitudes Toward Artificial Intelligence Applications Among Traditional Chinese Medicine Nurses and Associated Factors: A Multicenter Cross‐Sectional Study
- Mapping the evolution of artificial intelligence applications in bone metastasis: a bibliometric and visualization analysis
- Artificial Intelligence-Enabled Medical Diagnosis in the Internet of Medical Things: An End-to-End Survey of Connected Sensing, Distributed Intelligence, Clinical Applications, and Validation.
BibTeX
@article{li2026applications,
title = {{Applications of artificial intelligence in traditional Chinese medicine tongue diagnosis: a bibliometric review of research trends and hotspots, 2015-2026.}},
author = {Yilin Li and Yang Yang and Shaoqin Lin and Hengxu Wang and Liyuan Yan and Mingxiang Zheng and Lei Xiang and Xiangjiang Tang},
journal = {Frontiers in physiology},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.3389/fphys.2026.1895902},
url = {https://europepmc.org/article/MED/42898973},
note = {CC BY},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Applications of artificial intelligence in traditional Chinese medicine tongue diagnosis: a bibliometric review of research trends and hotspots, 2015-2026.
AU - Yilin Li
AU - Yang Yang
AU - Shaoqin Lin
AU - Hengxu Wang
AU - Liyuan Yan
AU - Mingxiang Zheng
AU - Lei Xiang
AU - Xiangjiang Tang
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/05
JO - Frontiers in physiology
DO - 10.3389/fphys.2026.1895902
UR - https://europepmc.org/article/MED/42898973
AB - Objectives This study aimed to characterize the development landscape of artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted tongue diagnosis in Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) by comparing publication trends, collaboration patterns, research hotspots, and emerging topics between CNKI-indexed and WoSCC-indexed literature.Methods Literature published between January 2015 and August 2026 was retrieved from the Web of Science Core Collection (WoSCC) and China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI). Publication trends were summarized descriptively, and CiteSpace and VOSviewer were used for collaboration-network, keyword co-occurrence, clustering, timeline, burst-detection, and journal citation analyses. CNKI-indexed and WoSCC-indexed records were analysed separately because of differences in database coverage, indexing characteristics, metadata structures, and publication practices.Results A total of 482 studies were included, comprising 295 WoSCC-indexed and 187 CNKI-indexed records. Publication output showed an overall upward trend in both datasets over the study period. The CNKI keyword clustering network showed high clustering quality (modularity Q = 0.7929; weighted mean silhouette S = 0.9413), as did the WoSCC network (Q = 0.8000; S = 0.9239). In CNKI, the strongest keyword bursts included "deep learning" (strength = 2.95), "image segmentation" (2.69), and "transfer learning" (2.61); in WoSCC, prominent bursts included "artificial intelligence" (2.13), "image colour analysis" (2.10), and "machine learning" (1.86). CNKI-indexed literature showed prominent themes involving tongue-image objectification, segmentation, and TCM-oriented diagnostic concepts, whereas WoSCC-indexed literature showed more differentiated themes involving AI architectures, tongue-feature analysis, computational modelling, and disease-related applications. Highly cited publications in both datasets further reflected the importance of tongue-image extraction and segmentation and the subsequent expansion toward disease-oriented modelling. Across both datasets, the temporal patterns suggested a shift in research attention from conventional image processing and feature extraction toward machine learning, deep learning, and more integrated AI-based approaches.Conclusions The two datasets showed complementary but database-specific thematic structures in AI-assisted tongue diagnosis. Although the literature indicates a shift toward more advanced and disease-oriented AI applications, these bibliometric patterns do not establish the scientific or medical validity, diagnostic accuracy, or clinical readiness of AI-assisted tongue analysis. Further standardization, multicentre external validation, and clinically interpretable and reproducible research are needed before broader clinical application.
SN - 1664-042X
ER -