Analysis of the adaptation of Place-based Interventions (PBIs) addressing health inequalities in deprived areas through implementation science frameworks: a scoping review
Abstract
Background: Global health inequalities are increasing in deprived areas. Place-based interventions (PBIs) are designed to address these differences; however, systematic evidence regarding their adaptation remains limited. This scoping review examines the adaptation of PBIs using Implementation Science (IS) frameworks, identifies critical gaps in the literature, and offers actionable recommendations for future research.
Methods: Arksey and O’Malley’s framework guided the review process. Six databases, nine IS websites, and grey literature sources were searched for studies reporting PBI adaptations using IS frameworks or theories. Adaptations were classified using the Framework for Reporting Adaptations and Modifications (FRAME), and outcomes were mapped to Proctor’s taxonomy.
Results: Out of 6,902 records, nine studies met the inclusion criteria, all originating from high-income countries. PBIs were adapted to align with local resources. Most adaptations addressed staff roles, training, delivery, and infrastructure, while fewer involved group-based or culturally tailored formats. Researchers primarily employed the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research ( CFIR) and realist frameworks to evaluate implementation, rather than to assess the effects of adaptation on services or client outcomes. Although studies identified barriers and enablers, they provided limited detail on the impacts of adaptation. Reporting predominantly focused on acceptability and fidelity, with limited evidence regarding sustainability, cost, and reach. Key enablers included cross-sector collaboration, community engagement, adaptability, and leadership support.
Conclusion: Although adaptation is often promoted to improve acceptability and contextual fit, community participation is frequently limited to consultation rather than substantive decision-making. This raises health equity concerns, as limited community influence may lead to adaptations that fail to reflect the needs and priorities of disadvantaged populations, potentially reinforcing existing health inequalities. Future research should examine how adaptation processes influence equity and whether they effectively reduce health inequalities among marginalized groups.
Related
- Advocacy and policy leadership training for primary care: a global environmental scan of competency frameworks, interventions, and strategic priorities
- Addressing gender bias in sexual and reproductive health care: A scoping review of training tools and interventions
- From evidence to impact: purposeful use of implementation science theories, models, and frameworks in genomics and precision health
- Beyond symptom change: engagement equity and implementation of WeChat-based trauma interventions
- Digital, Mobile and Artificial Intelligence‐Supported Interventions for Pressure Injury Prevention and Management: A Systematic Review of Clinical, Workflow and Implementation Outcomes
BibTeX
@article{nour2026analysis,
title = {{Analysis of the adaptation of Place-based Interventions (PBIs) addressing health inequalities in deprived areas through implementation science frameworks: a scoping review}},
author = {Nehal Nour and Dervla Kelly and Evangelin Samarj and Anne Dee and Geoffrey Curran and Patrick O’Donnell},
journal = {BMC Public Health},
year = {2026},
month = nov,
doi = {10.1186/s12889-026-30358-0},
url = {https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12889-026-30358-0},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Analysis of the adaptation of Place-based Interventions (PBIs) addressing health inequalities in deprived areas through implementation science frameworks: a scoping review
AU - Nehal Nour
AU - Dervla Kelly
AU - Evangelin Samarj
AU - Anne Dee
AU - Geoffrey Curran
AU - Patrick O’Donnell
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/11/16
JO - BMC Public Health
DO - 10.1186/s12889-026-30358-0
UR - https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12889-026-30358-0
AB - Background: Global health inequalities are increasing in deprived areas. Place-based interventions (PBIs) are designed to address these differences; however, systematic evidence regarding their adaptation remains limited. This scoping review examines the adaptation of PBIs using Implementation Science (IS) frameworks, identifies critical gaps in the literature, and offers actionable recommendations for future research. Methods: Arksey and O’Malley’s framework guided the review process. Six databases, nine IS websites, and grey literature sources were searched for studies reporting PBI adaptations using IS frameworks or theories. Adaptations were classified using the Framework for Reporting Adaptations and Modifications (FRAME), and outcomes were mapped to Proctor’s taxonomy. Results: Out of 6,902 records, nine studies met the inclusion criteria, all originating from high-income countries. PBIs were adapted to align with local resources. Most adaptations addressed staff roles, training, delivery, and infrastructure, while fewer involved group-based or culturally tailored formats. Researchers primarily employed the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research ( CFIR) and realist frameworks to evaluate implementation, rather than to assess the effects of adaptation on services or client outcomes. Although studies identified barriers and enablers, they provided limited detail on the impacts of adaptation. Reporting predominantly focused on acceptability and fidelity, with limited evidence regarding sustainability, cost, and reach. Key enablers included cross-sector collaboration, community engagement, adaptability, and leadership support. Conclusion: Although adaptation is often promoted to improve acceptability and contextual fit, community participation is frequently limited to consultation rather than substantive decision-making. This raises health equity concerns, as limited community influence may lead to adaptations that fail to reflect the needs and priorities of disadvantaged populations, potentially reinforcing existing health inequalities. Future research should examine how adaptation processes influence equity and whether they effectively reduce health inequalities among marginalized groups.
SN - 1471-2458
ER -