Does Topology-Dependent Chemistry Influence the Interstellar PAH Inventory? Insights from the Absence of Cyanotriphenylenes
Abstract
Although a set of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) has recently been identified in the cold dark cloud TMC-1, several common PAH motifs remain absent, leaving the origin of this apparent structural selectivity unresolved. Triphenylene (\ce{C18H12}) provides a stringent test of whether relative thermodynamic stability alone can account for the emerging PAH inventory because it is the smallest fully benzenoid PAH predicted by Clar's rule, is exceptionally stable, and is a key subunit of larger detected aromatic frameworks such as coronene and fullerene-related species. To probe whether such thermodynamically favored carbon skeletons are selected under cold interstellar conditions, we synthesized cyanotriphenylenes and measured their first 6.5--16~GHz microwave rotational spectra as polar tracers for the non-polar parent. An astronomical search based on these spectroscopic parameters yielded no detection, suggesting a possible ``missing triphenylene'' anomaly: despite its exceptional thermodynamic stability, this fully benzenoid PAH may be relatively depleted in TMC-1. To rationalize this behavior, we introduce a ring-node graphic representation that classifies PAH skeletons by topology; within this framework, triphenylene, whose compactness is otherwise ambiguous, is classified as non-compact. This representation reveals a tentative clustering of the currently detected and undetected PAHs according to topology, suggesting that the current PAH inventory cannot be rationalized solely on the basis of thermodynamic stability and may instead reflect differences in formation and destruction kinetics. The observed selectivity may arise from two complementary effects: sequential growth decay along bottom-up growth pathways and rapid consumption of bay-region intermediates by reactive unsaturated small species.
Related
- Sulfur ice chemistry: Photolysis and radiolysis of OCS and H_2S in interstellar ice analogs
- Slow-electron-triggered chemistry in interstellar methanol-water ices
- Hydrogenation of Uracil in Solid Para-Hydrogen: Infrared Spectra of Monohydrogenated Radicals (5H‑C4H5N2O2, 6H‑C4H5N2O2, and 4OH-C4H5N2O2) and Their Implications for RNA-Related Chemistry in the Interstellar Medium
- Non-equilibrium chemistry and radiation hydrodynamics in metal-poor and metal-rich interstellar gas
- From local chemistry to galactic evolution: unlocking the power of interstellar isotopes with ALMA2040
BibTeX
@misc{ren2026does,
title = {{Does Topology-Dependent Chemistry Influence the Interstellar PAH Inventory? Insights from the Absence of Cyanotriphenylenes}},
author = {Huanyu Ren and Gabi Wenzel and Thomas H. Speak and Miya Duffy and Annapoorani Hariharan and Martin S. Holdren and D. Archie Stewart and Christopher N. Shingledecker and Reace H. J. Willis and Ilsa R. Cooke and Brett A. McGuire},
howpublished = {arXiv},
year = {2026},
month = nov,
doi = {10.48550/arxiv.2611.05070},
eprint = {2611.05070},
archivePrefix = {arXiv},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.05070},
}
RIS
TY - UNPB
TI - Does Topology-Dependent Chemistry Influence the Interstellar PAH Inventory? Insights from the Absence of Cyanotriphenylenes
AU - Huanyu Ren
AU - Gabi Wenzel
AU - Thomas H. Speak
AU - Miya Duffy
AU - Annapoorani Hariharan
AU - Martin S. Holdren
AU - D. Archie Stewart
AU - Christopher N. Shingledecker
AU - Reace H. J. Willis
AU - Ilsa R. Cooke
AU - Brett A. McGuire
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/11/03
PB - arXiv
DO - 10.48550/arxiv.2611.05070
UR - https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.05070
AB - Although a set of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) has recently been identified in the cold dark cloud TMC-1, several common PAH motifs remain absent, leaving the origin of this apparent structural selectivity unresolved. Triphenylene (\ce{C18H12}) provides a stringent test of whether relative thermodynamic stability alone can account for the emerging PAH inventory because it is the smallest fully benzenoid PAH predicted by Clar's rule, is exceptionally stable, and is a key subunit of larger detected aromatic frameworks such as coronene and fullerene-related species. To probe whether such thermodynamically favored carbon skeletons are selected under cold interstellar conditions, we synthesized cyanotriphenylenes and measured their first 6.5--16~GHz microwave rotational spectra as polar tracers for the non-polar parent. An astronomical search based on these spectroscopic parameters yielded no detection, suggesting a possible ``missing triphenylene'' anomaly: despite its exceptional thermodynamic stability, this fully benzenoid PAH may be relatively depleted in TMC-1. To rationalize this behavior, we introduce a ring-node graphic representation that classifies PAH skeletons by topology; within this framework, triphenylene, whose compactness is otherwise ambiguous, is classified as non-compact. This representation reveals a tentative clustering of the currently detected and undetected PAHs according to topology, suggesting that the current PAH inventory cannot be rationalized solely on the basis of thermodynamic stability and may instead reflect differences in formation and destruction kinetics. The observed selectivity may arise from two complementary effects: sequential growth decay along bottom-up growth pathways and rapid consumption of bay-region intermediates by reactive unsaturated small species.
ER -