A pencil of quadratic forms in nine variables with no member of Witt index four
Abstract
We exhibit an explicit pair (A,B) of integral symmetric 9×9 matrices, defining a nonsingular pair of quadratic forms over ℚ, such that no member of the rational pencil λqA+μqB has Witt index $4$ over ℚ. This refutes a conjecture from \cite{Que16a}, which predicted that every nonsingular pair in n variables generates a pencil containing a form of Witt index ⌈ (n−1)/2⌉. The obstruction is purely $2$-adic and affects the whole pencil at once: every member has Witt index exactly $3$ over ℚ2. The proof is finite and elementary: a parity argument on det(λA+μB), a congruence lemma reducing ℙ1(ℚ2) to the twelve classes of ℙ1(ℤ/8), and a verification at each class, in which the anisotropy verdict is certified in two independent ways. All scripts are provided in the GitHub repository.
Related
- Counting solutions to quadratic forms in eight prime variables of off-diagonal rank $3$
- On the abundance of rigid meromorphic cocycles for quadratic forms in four variables
- Translation invariant quadratic forms in $8$ variables and dense sets of primes
- A single LU~factorization approach to model reduction for linear system families with a quadratic matrix pencil
- Improved bounds in Birch's theorem for forms in many variables
BibTeX
@misc{quertier2026pencil,
title = {{A pencil of quadratic forms in nine variables with no member of Witt index four}},
author = {Tony Quertier},
howpublished = {arXiv},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
doi = {10.48550/arxiv.2609.07692},
eprint = {2609.07692},
archivePrefix = {arXiv},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.07692},
}
RIS
TY - UNPB
TI - A pencil of quadratic forms in nine variables with no member of Witt index four
AU - Tony Quertier
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/09/07
PB - arXiv
DO - 10.48550/arxiv.2609.07692
UR - https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.07692
AB - We exhibit an explicit pair (A,B) of integral symmetric 9×9 matrices, defining a nonsingular pair of quadratic forms over ℚ, such that no member of the rational pencil λq_A+μq_B has Witt index $4$ over ℚ. This refutes a conjecture from \cite{Que16a}, which predicted that every nonsingular pair in n variables generates a pencil containing a form of Witt index ⌈ (n−1)/2⌉. The obstruction is purely $2$-adic and affects the whole pencil at once: every member has Witt index exactly $3$ over ℚ_2. The proof is finite and elementary: a parity argument on det(λA+μB), a congruence lemma reducing ℙ^1(ℚ_2) to the twelve classes of ℙ^1(ℤ/8), and a verification at each class, in which the anisotropy verdict is certified in two independent ways. All scripts are provided in the GitHub repository.
ER -