Understanding Barriers to Surgical Care: A Qualitative Study of Black Individuals With Hand Dysfunction
5 affiliations
- 1University of Toledo College of Medicine and Life Sciences Toledo OH USA
- 2Center for Healthcare Outcomes and Policy University of Michigan Ann Arbor MI USA
- 3Division of Plastic Surgery The University of California Los Angeles CA USA
- 4Section of Plastic Surgery, Department of Surgery University of Michigan Ann Arbor MI USA
- 5Department of Surgery University of Michigan Ann Arbor MI USA
Abstract
Objective: To identify barriers influencing treatment decision‐making among Black individuals with carpal tunnel syndrome and to explore mechanisms contributing to disparities in hand surgery utilisation.
Summary Background Data: Racial disparities exist in a variety of surgical subspecialties, including hand surgery. Little information on why these disparities exist or how to improve disparities from the patient's perspective is known.
Methods: We conducted a study utilising virtual semi‐structured interviews, focusing on participants’ interactions with healthcare providers, the impact of hand dysfunction, and participants’ experiences with racism and discrimination. Using an interpretive description approach, we captured major themes in the coded data.
Results: The sample included 28 Black individuals with carpal tunnel syndrome. We identified three key themes: (1) Racism predisposes Black participants to inequitable care: participants experienced intergenerational drag, microaggressions, discrimination, and mistrust related to historical injustices. Participants engaged in code‐switching to navigate biases and have their symptoms validated. (2) Social and systemic factors enable access to care: participants experienced economic instability, limited paid leave, unreliable transportation, inequitable workplace policies, and lack of social support. (3) Inadequate assessment of needs and access to care among Black participants: Participants struggled to navigate the referral process and obtain timely diagnostic testing. Many participants also described how providers misinterpreted their symptoms, which strained relationships with providers.
Conclusions: Racism and discrimination contribute to Black individuals’ reluctance to undergo hand surgery. Improving disparities in surgery requires systemic and interpersonal solutions that optimise resource allocation, improve the surgical referral process, mitigate bias in healthcare interactions, and strengthen patient support networks. Understanding the drivers of racial disparities from patients’ perspectives is necessary to develop actionable, patient‐centred solutions.
Patient or Public Contribution: Prior to study initiation, three structured community engagement sessions were conducted to collaborate with Black community members to co‐develop and iteratively shape our research question and study design. Our community research collaborators assessed study relevance, refined key study objectives, and informed interview guide domains.
Related
- Understanding engagement with a deposit return scheme for reusable cups: A qualitative study on barriers and enablers of cup use and return through the COM-B Model
- Barriers and Factors Associated With Disclosure of Chlamydia trachomatis Infection Among Sexually Active Individuals in Buea, Cameroon: A Cross‐Sectional Study
- Understanding ChatGPT adoption among medical students: an integrated theoretical model of psychological barriers and individual factors
- The lived experiences of sexual and gender minority individuals in Guyana: a qualitative investigation into well-being
- Educational expectations and needs of individuals scheduled for breast surgery within the Primary Nursing Model: a qualitative study
BibTeX
@article{thompson2026understanding,
title = {{Understanding Barriers to Surgical Care: A Qualitative Study of Black Individuals With Hand Dysfunction}},
author = {Noelle T. Thompson and Natalie B. Baxter and Ayana Cole‐Price and Mary E. Byrnes and Rachel C. Hooper},
journal = {Health Expectations : An International Journal of Public Participation in Health Care and Health Policy},
year = {2026},
month = nov,
doi = {10.1111/hex.70958},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1111/hex.70958},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Understanding Barriers to Surgical Care: A Qualitative Study of Black Individuals With Hand Dysfunction
AU - Noelle T. Thompson
AU - Natalie B. Baxter
AU - Ayana Cole‐Price
AU - Mary E. Byrnes
AU - Rachel C. Hooper
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/11/04
JO - Health Expectations : An International Journal of Public Participation in Health Care and Health Policy
DO - 10.1111/hex.70958
UR - https://doi.org/10.1111/hex.70958
AB - Objective: To identify barriers influencing treatment decision‐making among Black individuals with carpal tunnel syndrome and to explore mechanisms contributing to disparities in hand surgery utilisation. Summary Background Data: Racial disparities exist in a variety of surgical subspecialties, including hand surgery. Little information on why these disparities exist or how to improve disparities from the patient's perspective is known. Methods: We conducted a study utilising virtual semi‐structured interviews, focusing on participants’ interactions with healthcare providers, the impact of hand dysfunction, and participants’ experiences with racism and discrimination. Using an interpretive description approach, we captured major themes in the coded data. Results: The sample included 28 Black individuals with carpal tunnel syndrome. We identified three key themes: (1) Racism predisposes Black participants to inequitable care: participants experienced intergenerational drag, microaggressions, discrimination, and mistrust related to historical injustices. Participants engaged in code‐switching to navigate biases and have their symptoms validated. (2) Social and systemic factors enable access to care: participants experienced economic instability, limited paid leave, unreliable transportation, inequitable workplace policies, and lack of social support. (3) Inadequate assessment of needs and access to care among Black participants: Participants struggled to navigate the referral process and obtain timely diagnostic testing. Many participants also described how providers misinterpreted their symptoms, which strained relationships with providers. Conclusions: Racism and discrimination contribute to Black individuals’ reluctance to undergo hand surgery. Improving disparities in surgery requires systemic and interpersonal solutions that optimise resource allocation, improve the surgical referral process, mitigate bias in healthcare interactions, and strengthen patient support networks. Understanding the drivers of racial disparities from patients’ perspectives is necessary to develop actionable, patient‐centred solutions. Patient or Public Contribution: Prior to study initiation, three structured community engagement sessions were conducted to collaborate with Black community members to co‐develop and iteratively shape our research question and study design. Our community research collaborators assessed study relevance, refined key study objectives, and informed interview guide domains.
SN - 1369-6513
SN - 1369-7625
ER -