Gauge versus (hidden) physical symmetries of FLRW cosmologies
Abstract
In generally covariant theories, evolution in coordinate time is a gauge transformation, so that a symmetry made manifest in a gauge-fixed description need not be a symmetry of the physical dynamics. At the same time, deparametrisation removes gauge redundancies but may hide physical symmetries, in particular those that depend on the chosen physical clock. We investigate the relation between gauge and hidden physical symmetries in flat FLRW geometry coupled to an arbitrary number n of free massless scalar fields. We show that conformal Killing vectors of the minisuperspace metric generate conserved charges that are Dirac observables and hence gauge-invariant. Their Poisson algebra realises the maximal conformal algebra conf(n,1)≃so(n+1,2), extending previous single-field results to arbitrary n. We then revisit the Eisenhart--Duval lift in a family of gauges and show that the resulting symmetry algebra is gauge dependent. Only in the harmonic gauge does the algebra enlarge to the Schrödinger algebra, which is thus not a physical symmetry. Finally, we show that deparametrisation maps the lifted charges to gauge-invariant Dirac observables, which always realise a subalgebra of conf(n,1), recovering it in full in the harmonic gauge. Our results provide a systematic framework for disentangling gauge from physical symmetries in minisuperspace models, recovering charges to which reduced phase-space descriptions are structurally blind, and extending naturally to models with potentials.
Versions
Related
- Five-flavor udscb¯ molecular pentaquarks from heavy-quark and local hidden gauge symmetries
- Nilpotent Symmetries and Conserved Charges: BRST-Quantized Version of the 4D Abelian 2-Form Gauge Theory
- Hidden symmetries and the universality of Hawking radiation
- Gauge It or Break It: Lectures on Global Symmetries and the Cobordism Conjecture
- Ubiquitous topological materials protected by hidden partial symmetries
BibTeX
@misc{calcinari2026gauge,
title = {{Gauge versus (hidden) physical symmetries of FLRW cosmologies}},
author = {Andrea Calcinari and Adrià Delhom and Federico Greco and Daniele Oriti and Néstor Rivero},
howpublished = {arXiv},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
doi = {10.48550/arxiv.2607.27351},
eprint = {2607.27351},
archivePrefix = {arXiv},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.27351},
}
RIS
TY - UNPB
TI - Gauge versus (hidden) physical symmetries of FLRW cosmologies
AU - Andrea Calcinari
AU - Adrià Delhom
AU - Federico Greco
AU - Daniele Oriti
AU - Néstor Rivero
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/09/20
PB - arXiv
DO - 10.48550/arxiv.2607.27351
UR - https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.27351
AB - In generally covariant theories, evolution in coordinate time is a gauge transformation, so that a symmetry made manifest in a gauge-fixed description need not be a symmetry of the physical dynamics. At the same time, deparametrisation removes gauge redundancies but may hide physical symmetries, in particular those that depend on the chosen physical clock. We investigate the relation between gauge and hidden physical symmetries in flat FLRW geometry coupled to an arbitrary number n of free massless scalar fields. We show that conformal Killing vectors of the minisuperspace metric generate conserved charges that are Dirac observables and hence gauge-invariant. Their Poisson algebra realises the maximal conformal algebra conf(n,1)≃so(n+1,2), extending previous single-field results to arbitrary n. We then revisit the Eisenhart--Duval lift in a family of gauges and show that the resulting symmetry algebra is gauge dependent. Only in the harmonic gauge does the algebra enlarge to the Schrödinger algebra, which is thus not a physical symmetry. Finally, we show that deparametrisation maps the lifted charges to gauge-invariant Dirac observables, which always realise a subalgebra of conf(n,1), recovering it in full in the harmonic gauge. Our results provide a systematic framework for disentangling gauge from physical symmetries in minisuperspace models, recovering charges to which reduced phase-space descriptions are structurally blind, and extending naturally to models with potentials.
ER -