A randomized study on migration of the Spectron EF and the Charnley flanged 40 cemented femoral stems: secondary analysis of a randomized controlled trial using radiostereometric analysis (RSA) with 10 years’ follow-up
8 affiliations
- 1Department of Clinical Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, University of Bergen, Bergen
- 2The Norwegian Arthroplasty Register, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Haukeland University Hospital, Bergen
- 3Coastal Hospital in Hagavik, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Haukeland University Hospital, Bergen
- 4Department of Occupational Medicine, Haukeland University Hospital, Bergen
- 5Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, St. Olavs Hospital, Trondheim
- 6Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Haukeland University Hospital, Bergen
- 7Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Lovisenberg Diakonal Hospital, Oslo
- 8Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Biomatlab, Haukeland University Hospital, Bergen, Norway
Abstract
Background and purpose: Our primary aim was to compare the 10-year migration of the proximally roughened Spectron EF stem with the Charnley flanged 40 stems in cemented THA. Secondary aims were to assess the influence of polyethylene type on Spectron EF migration, and clinical outcomes.
Methods: In this randomized trial (NCT00698672), 150 patients (70% women; mean age 70 years) underwent cemented THA with either a Charnley stem (n = 30) or a Spectron EF stem (n = 120, 4 groups with different articulating surfaces). The articulations utilized conventional polyethylene (CPE) or highly crosslinked polyethylene (XLPE) cup liners combined with either cobalt-chromium (CoCr) or Oxinium (OxZr) femoral heads. RSA was performed postoperatively and up to 10 years. Migration was analyzed using linear mixed-effects models. Clinical outcome was assessed with the Harris Hip Score (HHS).
Results: After 10 years, 48 patients (14 Charnley, 34 Spectron EF) had evaluable RSA data. Both stems showed posterior translation, subsidence, and retroversion. Retroversion was greater for the Charnley stem than the Spectron EF stem at 3.2° (95% confidence interval [CI] 2.7–3.8) and 1.5° (CI 1.2–1.8), respectively, with a mean difference of 1.7° (CI 1.1– 2.4). The Spectron EF stem had more subsidence at 0.72 mm (CI 0.56–0.88) vs 0.32 mm (CI 0.06–0.57) for the Charnley stem, with a difference of 0.41 mm (CI 0.11–0.71). Spectron EF stems articulating with XLPE had 0.44 mm (CI 0.12–0.76) more subsidence than stems articulating with CPE. HHS improved from 41 (SD 15) to 86 (SD 19) for the Charnley stem and 45 (SD 13) to 86 (SD 15) for the Spectron EF stem with no statistically significant difference between the groups.
Conclusion: After 10 years, the Spectron EF stem showed less retroversion, but more subsidence than the Charnley stem, with otherwise similar migration and clinical outcomes. XLPE articulating stems had more subsidence than CPE with the Spectron EF stem.
Related
- Comparison of CT-based migration analysis against radiostereometric analysis for assessing two-year migration in an uncemented medial pivot tibial knee implant : clinical implications from a prospective safety study
- Stable 2-year migration on radiostereometric analysis and improved gait speed and function after bicruciate-retaining TKA: a prospective cohort of 25 patients
- Assessing an educational strategy to improve community health provider-led provision of cervical cancer screening services in western Kenya: A secondary analysis of the Elimisha-HPV cluster-randomized controlled trial
- Blood Biomarkers of Alzheimer's Disease Neuropathology, Cognition, and Response to a Multidomain Lifestyle Intervention: Secondary analysis of the FINGER Randomized Controlled Dementia Risk Reduction Trial
- Participant Characteristics Associated With Loneliness Reduction During a Digital Social Robot Intervention Among Older Adults Living Alone in Japan: Secondary Analysis of a Randomized Controlled Trial
BibTeX
@article{johannessen2026randomized,
title = {{A randomized study on migration of the Spectron EF and the Charnley flanged 40 cemented femoral stems: secondary analysis of a randomized controlled trial using radiostereometric analysis (RSA) with 10 years’ follow-up}},
author = {Håkon Greve JOHANNESSEN and Geir HALLAN and Ove FURNES and Anne Marie FENSTAD and Stein Håkon LYGRE and Kristin HAUGAN and Thomas KADAR and Mona BADAWY and Kari INDREKVAM and Arild AAMODT and Paul Johan HØL},
journal = {Acta Orthopaedica},
year = {2026},
month = nov,
doi = {10.2340/17453674.2026.46836},
url = {https://doi.org/10.2340/17453674.2026.46836},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - A randomized study on migration of the Spectron EF and the Charnley flanged 40 cemented femoral stems: secondary analysis of a randomized controlled trial using radiostereometric analysis (RSA) with 10 years’ follow-up
AU - Håkon Greve JOHANNESSEN
AU - Geir HALLAN
AU - Ove FURNES
AU - Anne Marie FENSTAD
AU - Stein Håkon LYGRE
AU - Kristin HAUGAN
AU - Thomas KADAR
AU - Mona BADAWY
AU - Kari INDREKVAM
AU - Arild AAMODT
AU - Paul Johan HØL
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/11/12
JO - Acta Orthopaedica
DO - 10.2340/17453674.2026.46836
UR - https://doi.org/10.2340/17453674.2026.46836
AB - Background and purpose: Our primary aim was to compare the 10-year migration of the proximally roughened Spectron EF stem with the Charnley flanged 40 stems in cemented THA. Secondary aims were to assess the influence of polyethylene type on Spectron EF migration, and clinical outcomes. Methods: In this randomized trial (NCT00698672), 150 patients (70% women; mean age 70 years) underwent cemented THA with either a Charnley stem (n = 30) or a Spectron EF stem (n = 120, 4 groups with different articulating surfaces). The articulations utilized conventional polyethylene (CPE) or highly crosslinked polyethylene (XLPE) cup liners combined with either cobalt-chromium (CoCr) or Oxinium (OxZr) femoral heads. RSA was performed postoperatively and up to 10 years. Migration was analyzed using linear mixed-effects models. Clinical outcome was assessed with the Harris Hip Score (HHS). Results: After 10 years, 48 patients (14 Charnley, 34 Spectron EF) had evaluable RSA data. Both stems showed posterior translation, subsidence, and retroversion. Retroversion was greater for the Charnley stem than the Spectron EF stem at 3.2° (95% confidence interval [CI] 2.7–3.8) and 1.5° (CI 1.2–1.8), respectively, with a mean difference of 1.7° (CI 1.1– 2.4). The Spectron EF stem had more subsidence at 0.72 mm (CI 0.56–0.88) vs 0.32 mm (CI 0.06–0.57) for the Charnley stem, with a difference of 0.41 mm (CI 0.11–0.71). Spectron EF stems articulating with XLPE had 0.44 mm (CI 0.12–0.76) more subsidence than stems articulating with CPE. HHS improved from 41 (SD 15) to 86 (SD 19) for the Charnley stem and 45 (SD 13) to 86 (SD 15) for the Spectron EF stem with no statistically significant difference between the groups. Conclusion: After 10 years, the Spectron EF stem showed less retroversion, but more subsidence than the Charnley stem, with otherwise similar migration and clinical outcomes. XLPE articulating stems had more subsidence than CPE with the Spectron EF stem.
SN - 1745-3674
SN - 1745-3682
ER -