Why 2D Models Fail to Capture Flow Properties in 3D Heterogeneous Media: A Connectivity Perspective
Abstract
We analyze how the equivalent hydraulic conductivity, Keq, varies with the coarsening scale λ/I in 2D and 3D heterogeneous media. Their local hydraulic conductivity, k(bf r), follows a lognormal distribution in all cases, while spatial connectivity of k(bf r) ranges from high (HCS), through intermediate or multi-Gaussian (ICS) and low (LCS), to unstructured (NS). Using a stochastic approach, we characterize the full distribution P[log(Keq)], and its moments: mean ⟨ Keq⟩, log-variance σlog(Keq)2, and log-skewness γlog(Keq), as a function of λ/I. Significant contrasts appear between 2D and 3D, which we interpret in terms of two key factors associated with spatial dimensionality. We observe that, compared with ICS, LCS and HCS exhibit two distinct features: existing analytical expressions for coarse-graining of k(bf r) in multi-Gaussian media do not apply, while P[log(Keq)] deviates from Gaussian at all scales λ/I. Critical path analysis is then used to quantify the connectivity of our samples, and show that Keq exhibits a power-law dependence on it. Our results reveal that connectivity can lead to substantial differences between 2D and 3D macroscopic flow properties, even for the same geostatistical parameters, highlighting the severe limitations of using 2D models to represent 3D flows.
Related
- Minimizing capture time with many small traps in heterogeneous media
- GREEN-PRECONDITIONED DYNAMIC GRAPH NEURAL OPERATOR FOR ELECTROMAGNETIC FIELD PREDICTION IN HETEROGENEOUS MEDIA
- Stochastic dose fluctuations in boron neutron capture therapy with heterogeneous boron distributions
- A new perspective in linear Cauchy Elasticity: variational minimum principles for statics, dynamics, and heterogeneous materials
- Energy spectrums of slowed neutrons in heterogeneous uranium-carbon and thorium-carbon fission media
BibTeX
@misc{picighelli2026models,
title = {{Why 2D Models Fail to Capture Flow Properties in 3D Heterogeneous Media: A Connectivity Perspective}},
author = {Cristian Picighelli and Ivan Colecchio and Marcelo Piva and Alejandro D. Otero and Alejandro Boschan},
howpublished = {arXiv},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
doi = {10.48550/arxiv.2609.14609},
eprint = {2609.14609},
archivePrefix = {arXiv},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.14609},
note = {CC BY-NC-ND 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - UNPB
TI - Why 2D Models Fail to Capture Flow Properties in 3D Heterogeneous Media: A Connectivity Perspective
AU - Cristian Picighelli
AU - Ivan Colecchio
AU - Marcelo Piva
AU - Alejandro D. Otero
AU - Alejandro Boschan
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/09/13
PB - arXiv
DO - 10.48550/arxiv.2609.14609
UR - https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.14609
AB - We analyze how the equivalent hydraulic conductivity, K_eq, varies with the coarsening scale λ/I in 2D and 3D heterogeneous media. Their local hydraulic conductivity, k(bf r), follows a lognormal distribution in all cases, while spatial connectivity of k(bf r) ranges from high (HCS), through intermediate or multi-Gaussian (ICS) and low (LCS), to unstructured (NS). Using a stochastic approach, we characterize the full distribution P[log(K_eq)], and its moments: mean ⟨ K_eq⟩, log-variance σ_log(K_eq)^2, and log-skewness γ_log(K_eq), as a function of λ/I. Significant contrasts appear between 2D and 3D, which we interpret in terms of two key factors associated with spatial dimensionality. We observe that, compared with ICS, LCS and HCS exhibit two distinct features: existing analytical expressions for coarse-graining of k(bf r) in multi-Gaussian media do not apply, while P[log(K_eq)] deviates from Gaussian at all scales λ/I. Critical path analysis is then used to quantify the connectivity of our samples, and show that K_eq exhibits a power-law dependence on it. Our results reveal that connectivity can lead to substantial differences between 2D and 3D macroscopic flow properties, even for the same geostatistical parameters, highlighting the severe limitations of using 2D models to represent 3D flows.
ER -