Incomplete references leave bulk deconvolution targets non-identifiable, but identification has a computable precision price
- 1Department of Ophthalmology, Peking Union Medical College Hospital, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences and Peking Union Medical College, Beijing 100730, China
Abstract
Background. Reference-based deconvolution estimates cell-type proportions from bulk profiles. Incomplete references compromise these estimates, yet many remedies return point estimates. We separate the operator provenance that reproduces an estimate from the information and precision that identify its target. Results. Two operator histories at one reduced reference give different estimators: 28.2% of 196,420 sample-deletion pairs differed by >0.1 total variation; locking every learned component made paths identical. Across nine cohorts, operator history reversed 160 of 952 association signs, 31 with a significant path, and changed significance for 126. Observationally equivalent completions can fill the open simplex and reverse retained-type rankings. Under a joint zero-exposure condition, shared structure leaves inherited bounds unchanged; one to six uncalibrated views also gave identical bounds. A profile library contracted estimator-output envelopes by 98.93% yet covered the full-reference effect for 42.77%, with 19 wrong-sign certificates; conditional sharp bounds stayed at [-1, 1]. Treating RNA yields as exact collapsed intervals to points covering none of seven flow-measured targets: contraction without coverage is false certainty. Calibrated cross-modal anchors contract width to 0.51 at six types but certify no valid sign. Exact RNA yields identify cell fractions from RNA contributions; a decisive sign in blood requires {+/-}2.6% proxy accuracy with near-total contraction of donor-heterogeneity and dynamic-range envelopes. Conclusions. Incomplete-reference deconvolution is an identification problem, not only an estimation problem. Remedies must be scored on shrinkage, coverage, certification and false certification against held-out targets. fitdrop implements this scoring and a precision frontier for planning decisive measurements.
Related
- Report the tolerance, not the count: exact phylogenetic distance deconvolution with incomplete references
- Identifiable inverse optimal transport for single-cell state transitions
- DISCERN: Identifiable Disease Evidence for Generalizable Medical Multimodal Learning
- The Metabolic Organ Clock: A Computable Framework Linking Cell-Lineage Architecture to Emergent Organ Bioenergetics
- A computable probability landscape for T cell receptor repertoire sampling and comparison
BibTeX
@misc{jiang2026incomplete,
title = {{Incomplete references leave bulk deconvolution targets non-identifiable, but identification has a computable precision price}},
author = {H. Jiang and F. Gao and P. Liu and Y. Wu and Y. Jie and Y. Li and Y. Jiang},
howpublished = {bioRxiv},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
doi = {10.64898/2026.09.10.750775},
url = {https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.64898/2026.09.10.750775v1},
note = {CC BY},
}
RIS
TY - UNPB
TI - Incomplete references leave bulk deconvolution targets non-identifiable, but identification has a computable precision price
AU - H. Jiang
AU - F. Gao
AU - P. Liu
AU - Y. Wu
AU - Y. Jie
AU - Y. Li
AU - Y. Jiang
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/09/10
PB - bioRxiv
DO - 10.64898/2026.09.10.750775
UR - https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.64898/2026.09.10.750775v1
AB - Background. Reference-based deconvolution estimates cell-type proportions from bulk profiles. Incomplete references compromise these estimates, yet many remedies return point estimates. We separate the operator provenance that reproduces an estimate from the information and precision that identify its target. Results. Two operator histories at one reduced reference give different estimators: 28.2% of 196,420 sample-deletion pairs differed by >0.1 total variation; locking every learned component made paths identical. Across nine cohorts, operator history reversed 160 of 952 association signs, 31 with a significant path, and changed significance for 126. Observationally equivalent completions can fill the open simplex and reverse retained-type rankings. Under a joint zero-exposure condition, shared structure leaves inherited bounds unchanged; one to six uncalibrated views also gave identical bounds. A profile library contracted estimator-output envelopes by 98.93% yet covered the full-reference effect for 42.77%, with 19 wrong-sign certificates; conditional sharp bounds stayed at [-1, 1]. Treating RNA yields as exact collapsed intervals to points covering none of seven flow-measured targets: contraction without coverage is false certainty. Calibrated cross-modal anchors contract width to 0.51 at six types but certify no valid sign. Exact RNA yields identify cell fractions from RNA contributions; a decisive sign in blood requires {+/-}2.6% proxy accuracy with near-total contraction of donor-heterogeneity and dynamic-range envelopes. Conclusions. Incomplete-reference deconvolution is an identification problem, not only an estimation problem. Remedies must be scored on shrinkage, coverage, certification and false certification against held-out targets. fitdrop implements this scoring and a precision frontier for planning decisive measurements.
ER -