Discrepancy between soil safety and herbal risk: high cadmium enrichment in roots and leaves of Plantago asiatica and associated health implications
Abstract
Plantago asiatica ( P. asiatica ) plays an important role in traditional Chinese medicine treatments and ecological environment assessments. This study focused on the heavy metals discrepancy between soil safety and health risk from different parts of P. asiatica . The contents of 10 heavy metals in the roots, stems, leaves, seeds and corresponding soils were determined using ICP-MS. A health risk assessment method for heavy metal elements was established and simulated by Monte Carlo. The assessment integrated the Bioconcentration Factor (BCF), Hazard Index (HI) and Total Carcinogenic Risk (TCR) models. Results revealed significant variations in heavy metal concentrations and exceedance rates among different plant parts. Roots and leaves exhibited the highest exceedance rates (100% and 57.69%, respectively), while the growth soils remained below the risk screening values for agricultural land. This was primarily attributed to their strong Cd enrichment capacity (BCF: 10.18 in roots, 6.73 in leaves). However, low translocation factors (TF < 1) were found in stems, leaves and seeds, suggesting P. asiatica as a potential candidate for phytostabilization research. Furthermore, risk assessment from the proposed medicinal material safety threshold indicated that heavy metal levels in all four parts posed potential non-carcinogenic health risks for both adults and children under the conservative assumption that all measured As was inorganic As. This contrasted with the food safety framework, under which only roots exceeded the threshold. Moreover, a potential carcinogenic effect was identified in roots for adults under the conservative assumption that all measured As was inorganic As. Therefore, significant discrepancy existed in heavy metal contamination and associated health risks across different parts of P. asiatica . In particular, As in roots and leaves were identified as the primary drivers of potential non-carcinogenic health risks, warranting prioritized attention in quality control and risk management. It was recommended to avoid or reduce using high-risk parts (especially roots) in medicinal applications.
Related
- Morphological and Size-Dependent Enrichment of Endotoxins in Coastal Spray Aerosols: Implications for Regional Respiratory Health Risks
- Distribution and evolution of manganese minerals in polymetallic nodules from the Clarion-Clipperton Fracture Zone: implications for nickel and copper enrichment
- Sustained crustal helium enrichment associated with postseismic viscoelastic relaxation following the 2025 Myanmar earthquake
- Fluoride enrichment, hydrogeochemical processes, and health risks from groundwater ingestion in the Zabzugu District, Ghana
- Enrichment of urban waste compost samples allows the isolation of highly efficient phosphate solubilizing bacteria
BibTeX
@article{qiu2026discrepancy,
title = {{Discrepancy between soil safety and herbal risk: high cadmium enrichment in roots and leaves of Plantago asiatica and associated health implications}},
author = {Suyan Qiu and Yifan Dong and Qiushuang Ai and Xiren Yu and Jingtian Liang and Li Zhang and Mengjun Ye and Huming Shao and Dawen Zhang},
journal = {Scientific Reports},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.1038/s41598-026-73602-8},
url = {https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-026-73602-8},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Discrepancy between soil safety and herbal risk: high cadmium enrichment in roots and leaves of Plantago asiatica and associated health implications
AU - Suyan Qiu
AU - Yifan Dong
AU - Qiushuang Ai
AU - Xiren Yu
AU - Jingtian Liang
AU - Li Zhang
AU - Mengjun Ye
AU - Huming Shao
AU - Dawen Zhang
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/01
JO - Scientific Reports
DO - 10.1038/s41598-026-73602-8
UR - https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-026-73602-8
AB - Plantago asiatica ( P. asiatica ) plays an important role in traditional Chinese medicine treatments and ecological environment assessments. This study focused on the heavy metals discrepancy between soil safety and health risk from different parts of P. asiatica . The contents of 10 heavy metals in the roots, stems, leaves, seeds and corresponding soils were determined using ICP-MS. A health risk assessment method for heavy metal elements was established and simulated by Monte Carlo. The assessment integrated the Bioconcentration Factor (BCF), Hazard Index (HI) and Total Carcinogenic Risk (TCR) models. Results revealed significant variations in heavy metal concentrations and exceedance rates among different plant parts. Roots and leaves exhibited the highest exceedance rates (100% and 57.69%, respectively), while the growth soils remained below the risk screening values for agricultural land. This was primarily attributed to their strong Cd enrichment capacity (BCF: 10.18 in roots, 6.73 in leaves). However, low translocation factors (TF < 1) were found in stems, leaves and seeds, suggesting P. asiatica as a potential candidate for phytostabilization research. Furthermore, risk assessment from the proposed medicinal material safety threshold indicated that heavy metal levels in all four parts posed potential non-carcinogenic health risks for both adults and children under the conservative assumption that all measured As was inorganic As. This contrasted with the food safety framework, under which only roots exceeded the threshold. Moreover, a potential carcinogenic effect was identified in roots for adults under the conservative assumption that all measured As was inorganic As. Therefore, significant discrepancy existed in heavy metal contamination and associated health risks across different parts of P. asiatica . In particular, As in roots and leaves were identified as the primary drivers of potential non-carcinogenic health risks, warranting prioritized attention in quality control and risk management. It was recommended to avoid or reduce using high-risk parts (especially roots) in medicinal applications.
SN - 2045-2322
ER -