Tube thoracostomy through an existing stab wound after refusal of conventional chest tube placement: a case report
- 1Department of Surgery, Pediatric Surgery Unit, Shaafi Hospital, Mogadishu, Somalia
- 2Faculty of Medicine and Surgery, Banadir University, Mogadishu, Somalia
Abstract
Introduction and importance:: Tube thoracostomy is the standard treatment for traumatic hemothorax requiring pleural drainage and is usually performed through the safe triangle. Rarely, management becomes challenging when a patient refuses the conventional insertion site. We report an unusual case of tube thoracostomy performed through an existing stab wound after the patient refused a separate chest tube incision.
Case presentation:: An 18-year-old, previously healthy male presented 6 hours after a right posterior lower chest stab injury. Chest radiography showed a moderate right-sided hemothorax. Tube thoracostomy was indicated because of reduced air entry and pleural fluid collection. The patient and his father declined the conventional insertion site after a discussion of risks and available options. After wound reassessment, confirmation of pleural communication, and informed consent, a 28-Fr chest tube was inserted through the existing stab wound under digital guidance. Approximately 300 mL of blood was drained immediately, with clinical improvement and no complications. The patient remained stable. Computed tomography imaging, which had initially been declined, was performed before discharge and demonstrated an AAST grade III posterior right hepatic laceration without active bleeding. The liver injury was managed non-operatively.
Clinical discussion:: The safe triangle remains the standard approach for tube thoracostomy. This case highlights the importance of careful assessment, patient autonomy, informed consent, and close observation when an unusual clinical situation requires individualized management.
Conclusion:: Tube thoracostomy through an existing stab wound should not replace the conventional technique. This single case does not establish the safety, efficacy, or reproducibility of this approach. However, in exceptional circumstances, it may be considered with caution, while maintaining patient safety and adhering to established surgical principles.
Related
- Intracardiac Placement of Needle Thoracostomy Catheter by Paramedics Due to Anatomic Variation: A Case Report
- Comparison of ‘quilting sutures’ with ‘conventional sutures and drain placement’ after mastectomy: protocol for the BE-Quilt – a multicentre, pragmatic randomised controlled trial
- Simulated Placement and Rounds (SPaR): Improving Self-Reported Preparedness for Foundation Training through Ward-Round-Based Simulation
- Prioritising Research through Engagement with older Adult Care Homes and potential for mapping to existing data sources: the PREACH study
- Editorial: Beyond conventional biomarkers: unlocking immunotherapy response through novel biomarkers or combinatorial approaches
BibTeX
@article{sed2026tube,
title = {{Tube thoracostomy through an existing stab wound after refusal of conventional chest tube placement: a case report}},
author = {Zubair Mohamed Dahir Sed and Badrudin A. Warsame},
journal = {International Journal of Surgery Case Reports},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.1097/rc9.0000000000001168},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1097/rc9.0000000000001168},
note = {CC BY-NC-ND 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Tube thoracostomy through an existing stab wound after refusal of conventional chest tube placement: a case report
AU - Zubair Mohamed Dahir Sed
AU - Badrudin A. Warsame
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/22
JO - International Journal of Surgery Case Reports
DO - 10.1097/rc9.0000000000001168
UR - https://doi.org/10.1097/rc9.0000000000001168
AB - Introduction and importance:: Tube thoracostomy is the standard treatment for traumatic hemothorax requiring pleural drainage and is usually performed through the safe triangle. Rarely, management becomes challenging when a patient refuses the conventional insertion site. We report an unusual case of tube thoracostomy performed through an existing stab wound after the patient refused a separate chest tube incision. Case presentation:: An 18-year-old, previously healthy male presented 6 hours after a right posterior lower chest stab injury. Chest radiography showed a moderate right-sided hemothorax. Tube thoracostomy was indicated because of reduced air entry and pleural fluid collection. The patient and his father declined the conventional insertion site after a discussion of risks and available options. After wound reassessment, confirmation of pleural communication, and informed consent, a 28-Fr chest tube was inserted through the existing stab wound under digital guidance. Approximately 300 mL of blood was drained immediately, with clinical improvement and no complications. The patient remained stable. Computed tomography imaging, which had initially been declined, was performed before discharge and demonstrated an AAST grade III posterior right hepatic laceration without active bleeding. The liver injury was managed non-operatively. Clinical discussion:: The safe triangle remains the standard approach for tube thoracostomy. This case highlights the importance of careful assessment, patient autonomy, informed consent, and close observation when an unusual clinical situation requires individualized management. Conclusion:: Tube thoracostomy through an existing stab wound should not replace the conventional technique. This single case does not establish the safety, efficacy, or reproducibility of this approach. However, in exceptional circumstances, it may be considered with caution, while maintaining patient safety and adhering to established surgical principles.
SN - 2210-2612
ER -