Intersectional Inequalities in Mental Health Need and Youth Justice Contact among Pupils enrolled in Alternative Provision
- 1Institute for Global Health, University College London, UK
Abstract
Background. Unmet mental health and education needs increase the risk of youth justice contact. Understanding inequalities in alternative provision (AP) and how these relate to school recorded mental health needs or police criminalisation may identify opportunities to intervene. Methods. We analysed population-level linked school and police administrative data for 3.7m pupils (born 1997-2003) who attended state schools in England. We examined differences by racial-ethnic group and gender in rates and timing of AP enrolment and recording patterns of mental health-related provision and youth justice contacts among pupils with AP enrolment. Results. Our findings indicate heightened mental health need and vulnerability to criminalisation among pupils recorded with AP enrolment. Enrolment was highest among Irish Traveller and Romani pupils, followed by Black Caribbean and Mixed White-Black Caribbean pupils. Boys were enrolled more than girls, but some girls had higher rates than boys from other groups. Over 50% boys from Black Caribbean and Mixed White-Black Caribbean backgrounds with AP enrolment had a youth justice contact, the majority of whom had recorded mental health needs. Conclusion. Heightened need and intersectional inequalities among pupils enrolled in AP highlight the importance of a co-ordinated public health approach to understanding and responding to children's needs.
Related
- Mental Health-related School Provision and Hospital Contacts among Pupils enrolled in Alternative Provision
- Social inequalities and the risk of multimorbidity in Mexican adults: an intersectional approach
- A lifecourse perspective on sociodemographic intersectional inequalities in physical and mental health outcomes
- How much the burden of diabetes and hypertension is attributable to social inequalities? an intersectional analysis in Brazil
- Intersectional inequalities in youth mental health measurement and outcomes: population-representative evidence from the UK Millennium Cohort Study
BibTeX
@misc{chobhthaigh2026intersectional,
title = {{Intersectional Inequalities in Mental Health Need and Youth Justice Contact among Pupils enrolled in Alternative Provision}},
author = {S. Ni Chobhthaigh and C. Cox and T. Greenway-Bailey and J. Musanu and M. Green and A. Buhari and M. Mawi and C. Neave and R. A. Burgess and M. A. Jay and D. Devakumar},
howpublished = {medRxiv},
year = {2026},
month = nov,
doi = {10.64898/2026.11.08.26367542},
url = {https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.64898/2026.11.08.26367542v1},
note = {CC BY},
}
RIS
TY - UNPB
TI - Intersectional Inequalities in Mental Health Need and Youth Justice Contact among Pupils enrolled in Alternative Provision
AU - S. Ni Chobhthaigh
AU - C. Cox
AU - T. Greenway-Bailey
AU - J. Musanu
AU - M. Green
AU - A. Buhari
AU - M. Mawi
AU - C. Neave
AU - R. A. Burgess
AU - M. A. Jay
AU - D. Devakumar
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/11/08
PB - medRxiv
DO - 10.64898/2026.11.08.26367542
UR - https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.64898/2026.11.08.26367542v1
AB - Background. Unmet mental health and education needs increase the risk of youth justice contact. Understanding inequalities in alternative provision (AP) and how these relate to school recorded mental health needs or police criminalisation may identify opportunities to intervene. Methods. We analysed population-level linked school and police administrative data for 3.7m pupils (born 1997-2003) who attended state schools in England. We examined differences by racial-ethnic group and gender in rates and timing of AP enrolment and recording patterns of mental health-related provision and youth justice contacts among pupils with AP enrolment. Results. Our findings indicate heightened mental health need and vulnerability to criminalisation among pupils recorded with AP enrolment. Enrolment was highest among Irish Traveller and Romani pupils, followed by Black Caribbean and Mixed White-Black Caribbean pupils. Boys were enrolled more than girls, but some girls had higher rates than boys from other groups. Over 50% boys from Black Caribbean and Mixed White-Black Caribbean backgrounds with AP enrolment had a youth justice contact, the majority of whom had recorded mental health needs. Conclusion. Heightened need and intersectional inequalities among pupils enrolled in AP highlight the importance of a co-ordinated public health approach to understanding and responding to children's needs.
ER -