Intellectual property rights and the global exchange of molecular plant technologies
6 affiliations
- 1School of International Law, Southwest University of Political Science and Law, Chongqing, China
- 2Sarhad University of Science and IT, Peshawar, Pakistan
- 3International Arbitrator at Chongqing Arbitration Commission CQAC, China
- 4Global Research Fellow at ASTA Research Centre, Madagascar
- 5Sarhad Institute of Legal Studies, Sarhad University of Science and IT, Peshawar, Pakistan
- 6Department of International and Applied Economics, Széchenyi István University, Győr, Hungary
Abstract
The global intellectual property regime for plants is structurally misaligned with the molecular tools on which climate-resilient agriculture now depends. As gene editing, synthetic biology, and Digital Sequence Information (DSI) become central to breeding drought-, heat-, and salinity-tolerant crops, these same technologies are increasingly enclosed within dense patent thickets, trade rules that go beyond the minimum standards of the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS), commonly called TRIPS-plus rules, and costly regulatory requirements. Using doctrinal legal analysis, a patent-landscape review, and product-level case studies, we show how this architecture generates a “Market Power Effect,” whereby a small group of firms can set prices, stack royalties, and control access to enabling technologies, effectively sidelining public breeders, small laboratories, and climate-vulnerable states. We develop the concept of “legal resilience” to capture the idea that molecular resilience in biotech crops is meaningless without legal structures that allow rapid, equitable diffusion of adaptive traits. Empirically, we link rising CRISPR-related patents, escalating licensing and compliance costs, and corporate concentration to stagnant yield growth, persistent human undernourishment, and an emerging form of digital biopiracy that existing access and benefit-sharing instruments cannot contain. We also examine the position of large middle-income innovators, China in particular, which do not fit the conventional North–South division and whose domestic policy choices are pushing toward stronger rather than weaker protection. On this basis, we propose a polycentric reform package: a climate-utility model tier for incremental local adaptations; a multilateral DSI benefit-sharing fund financed by small levies on commercial seed sales; compulsory humanitarian patent pools for abiotic stress-resistance technologies; regional molecular hubs that pair laboratories with pro-bono freedom-to-operate support; and sustained support for the existing network of genebanks and community seed systems as a practical counterweight to the hazard of genetic uniformity. Our central claim is that genetic resilience must be treated as an essential facility for human food security, not merely as a tradable private asset.
Related
- Tri-Modality Representation Learning for Molecular Property Prediction
- A human rights-based approach to biodiversity monitoring
- Predictors of COVID-19 vaccination status among youth in eThekwini, South Africa: results from the AYAZAZI RIGHTS study
- Microduplication of the ARID1A gene causes intellectual disability with recognizable syndromic features
- The Role of the Immunoglobulin Superfamily of Cell Adhesion Molecules in Intellectual Disability
BibTeX
@article{haider2026intellectual,
title = {{Intellectual property rights and the global exchange of molecular plant technologies}},
author = {Aftab Haider and Asif Khan and András Szeberényi},
journal = {GM Crops \& Food},
year = {2026},
month = nov,
doi = {10.1080/21645698.2026.2740254},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1080/21645698.2026.2740254},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Intellectual property rights and the global exchange of molecular plant technologies
AU - Aftab Haider
AU - Asif Khan
AU - András Szeberényi
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/11/10
JO - GM Crops & Food
DO - 10.1080/21645698.2026.2740254
UR - https://doi.org/10.1080/21645698.2026.2740254
AB - The global intellectual property regime for plants is structurally misaligned with the molecular tools on which climate-resilient agriculture now depends. As gene editing, synthetic biology, and Digital Sequence Information (DSI) become central to breeding drought-, heat-, and salinity-tolerant crops, these same technologies are increasingly enclosed within dense patent thickets, trade rules that go beyond the minimum standards of the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS), commonly called TRIPS-plus rules, and costly regulatory requirements. Using doctrinal legal analysis, a patent-landscape review, and product-level case studies, we show how this architecture generates a “Market Power Effect,” whereby a small group of firms can set prices, stack royalties, and control access to enabling technologies, effectively sidelining public breeders, small laboratories, and climate-vulnerable states. We develop the concept of “legal resilience” to capture the idea that molecular resilience in biotech crops is meaningless without legal structures that allow rapid, equitable diffusion of adaptive traits. Empirically, we link rising CRISPR-related patents, escalating licensing and compliance costs, and corporate concentration to stagnant yield growth, persistent human undernourishment, and an emerging form of digital biopiracy that existing access and benefit-sharing instruments cannot contain. We also examine the position of large middle-income innovators, China in particular, which do not fit the conventional North–South division and whose domestic policy choices are pushing toward stronger rather than weaker protection. On this basis, we propose a polycentric reform package: a climate-utility model tier for incremental local adaptations; a multilateral DSI benefit-sharing fund financed by small levies on commercial seed sales; compulsory humanitarian patent pools for abiotic stress-resistance technologies; regional molecular hubs that pair laboratories with pro-bono freedom-to-operate support; and sustained support for the existing network of genebanks and community seed systems as a practical counterweight to the hazard of genetic uniformity. Our central claim is that genetic resilience must be treated as an essential facility for human food security, not merely as a tradable private asset.
SN - 2164-5698
SN - 2164-5701
ER -