The ETHICA-4P in intercultural mental health care for migrants: perspectives from the United Kingdom and Chile
5 affiliations
- 1The School of Health in Social Science, The University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
- 2Global Health Academy, The University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
- 3Escuela de Psicología, Facultad de Ciencias Sociales, Universidad Santo Tomás, Viña del Mar, Chile
- 4Escuela de Trabajo Social, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Valparaíso, Valparaiso, Chile
- 5Facultad de Bioética, Universidad Anáhuac, México
Abstract
Background: Mental health services in destination countries for migration are increasingly required to support service users from diverse cultural backgrounds. Although migrants may experience elevated mental health challenges, existing approaches are often insufficient to meet their needs. There is a need for tools that support practitioners in delivering competent and ethical intercultural care and navigating complex ethical decision-making.
Objective: To beta-test the ETHICA-4P ethical decision-making toolkit and evaluate its potential to support clinicians in addressing ethical challenges arising in intercultural practice.
Methods: Feedback was collected from stakeholders and practitioners in two destination countries for migration, Chile and the United Kingdom, through focus groups and anonymous surveys. Data were analysed using Reflexive Thematic Analysis to compare participants’ perspectives and suggestions regarding the use and further development of the toolkit.
Results: Three themes were identified: ‘Shared ethical dilemmas’, ‘Prioritising different levels of analysis according to place-based needs’, and ‘Practical guide, or tool for reflection?’. Participants reported similar ethical challenges and shared perspectives on the potential use of ETHICA-4P in practice. However, they differed in how intercultural care needs were conceptualised and addressed according to context, with some emphasising systems-level responses and others clinician-level approaches. These differences generated distinct suggestions for improving the toolkit.
Conclusions: The findings provide guidance for the continued development of ETHICA-4P and highlight the importance of flexibility in supporting ethical intercultural practice across diverse service and national contexts.
Related
- Intercultural pathways to indigenous mental health: the integration of ayahuasca in community care in the Yaqui intercultural medicine clinic in Sonora, Mexico
- A Scoping Review of Person-Centered Mental Health Care for Migrants and Refugees in Humanitarian Settings
- Correlates of mental health and the cascade of care among in-transit migrants in two border cities in Mexico
- Developing a survey tool to assess gendered violence and mental health burden in migrants living in precarity
- Mental health needs of migrants and strategies to address them: a qualitative, participatory study applying a socio-ecological framework in Barcelona, Spain
BibTeX
@article{calia2026ethica4p,
title = {{The ETHICA-4P in intercultural mental health care for migrants: perspectives from the United Kingdom and Chile}},
author = {Clara Calia and Benny Martin and Liz Grant and Cristobal Guerra and Edgardo Toro and Magda Liliana Rincón and Alice Gritti and Corinne Reid},
journal = {Global Health Action},
year = {2026},
month = nov,
doi = {10.1080/16549716.2026.2758969},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1080/16549716.2026.2758969},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - The ETHICA-4P in intercultural mental health care for migrants: perspectives from the United Kingdom and Chile
AU - Clara Calia
AU - Benny Martin
AU - Liz Grant
AU - Cristobal Guerra
AU - Edgardo Toro
AU - Magda Liliana Rincón
AU - Alice Gritti
AU - Corinne Reid
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/11/04
JO - Global Health Action
DO - 10.1080/16549716.2026.2758969
UR - https://doi.org/10.1080/16549716.2026.2758969
AB - Background: Mental health services in destination countries for migration are increasingly required to support service users from diverse cultural backgrounds. Although migrants may experience elevated mental health challenges, existing approaches are often insufficient to meet their needs. There is a need for tools that support practitioners in delivering competent and ethical intercultural care and navigating complex ethical decision-making. Objective: To beta-test the ETHICA-4P ethical decision-making toolkit and evaluate its potential to support clinicians in addressing ethical challenges arising in intercultural practice. Methods: Feedback was collected from stakeholders and practitioners in two destination countries for migration, Chile and the United Kingdom, through focus groups and anonymous surveys. Data were analysed using Reflexive Thematic Analysis to compare participants’ perspectives and suggestions regarding the use and further development of the toolkit. Results: Three themes were identified: ‘Shared ethical dilemmas’, ‘Prioritising different levels of analysis according to place-based needs’, and ‘Practical guide, or tool for reflection?’. Participants reported similar ethical challenges and shared perspectives on the potential use of ETHICA-4P in practice. However, they differed in how intercultural care needs were conceptualised and addressed according to context, with some emphasising systems-level responses and others clinician-level approaches. These differences generated distinct suggestions for improving the toolkit. Conclusions: The findings provide guidance for the continued development of ETHICA-4P and highlight the importance of flexibility in supporting ethical intercultural practice across diverse service and national contexts.
SN - 1654-9716
SN - 1654-9880
ER -