Skip to content
DraconiticResearch
Search Sources API
226,742 studies31 sourcesUpdated 44 min ago
Peer-reviewedCC BYPatient Preference and Adherence

Aligning Care with Patient Treatment Beliefs: A Secondary Analysis of a Randomized Controlled Trial Examining the Role of Fear Avoidance Beliefs in Neck Pain

4 affiliations
  1. 1Ambulatory Services | Hilliard Community Center Physical Therapy
  2. 2Doctor of Science in Physical Therapy
  3. 3Department of Rehabilitation Science
  4. 4Division of Physical Therapy

Abstract

Kenneth W Kirby,1,2 Joseph M Lorenzetti,2 Joshua A Kidd,2 Jodi L Young,2 Joshua A Cleland,3 Ronald J Schenk4 1Rehabilitation Services, Musculoskeletal Rehabilitation, The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, Columbus, OH, USA; 2Department of Physical Therapy, Doctor of Science in Physical Therapy Program, Bellin College, Green Bay, WI, USA; 3Department of Rehabilitation Science, Doctor of Physical Therapy Program, Tufts University School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA; 4Department of Rehabilitation Science, Division of Physical Therapy, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC, USACorrespondence: Kenneth W Kirby, Rehabilitation Services, Musculoskeletal Rehabilitation, The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center Hilliard Community Center, Physical Therapy 3995 Cosgray Rd, Suite 1000, Hilliard, OH, 43026, USA, Email [email protected]: Patient beliefs regarding the anticipated benefit of specific treatments may influence rehabilitation outcomes; however, the relationship between treatment beliefs, treatment-belief concordance, and fear-avoidance outcomes remains unclear.Purpose: To determine whether baseline treatment-belief concordance moderated the relationship between treatment group and short-term fear-avoidance outcomes and whether baseline treatment beliefs were associated with short- and long-term fear-avoidance outcomes in individuals with neck pain.Design: Secondary analysis of a randomized controlled trial.Methods: Patients with neck pain (N = 106) were classified according to baseline active or passive treatment-belief profiles and randomly assigned to receive either exercise alone or manual therapy combined with exercise. Fear-avoidance beliefs related to physical activity (FABQ-PA) and work (FABQ-W) were assessed at baseline, visit 3, and 6 months. Analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) models examined whether treatment-belief concordance moderated the relationship between treatment group and fear-avoidance outcomes at visit 3 and whether baseline active and passive treatment belief scores were associated with fear-avoidance outcomes at visit 3 and 6 months. Models were adjusted for baseline fear-avoidance beliefs, baseline pain intensity (NPRS), symptom duration, and treatment group where appropriate.Results: Of 106 participants, 64 (60.4%) reported an active treatment-belief profile, whereas 42 (39.6%) reported a passive treatment-belief profile. Treatment-belief concordance was not associated with FABQ-PA or FABQ-W outcomes at visit 3 (all p > 0.05). Baseline active and passive treatment-belief scores were not associated with FABQ-PA or FABQ-W outcomes at either visit 3 or 6 months (all p > 0.05).Conclusions: In individuals with neck pain, treatment-belief concordance was not associated with short-term fear-avoidance outcomes, and baseline treatment-belief scores were not associated with short- or long-term fear-avoidance outcomes. These findings suggest that matching treatment to patients’ initial beliefs regarding active vs passive care may not influence subsequent fear-avoidance outcomes.Plain Language Summary: Neck pain can lead some people to avoid physical activity or work because they fear these activities will worsen their pain. Researchers call these concerns fear-avoidance beliefs. We wanted to understand whether patients’ beliefs about which treatments would help them most, such as active approaches (exercise) or passive approaches (hands-on treatments), influenced changes in fear-avoidance over time.We analyzed data from 106 adults with neck pain who participated in a clinical trial and received either an exercise program alone or manual therapy combined with exercise. Before treatment, participants reported whether they believed active or passive treatments would be most beneficial. We then examined whether receiving a treatment that matched those beliefs affected fear-avoidance outcomes and whether baseline treatment beliefs predicted future fear-avoidance.We found that receiving a treatment that matched patients’ treatment beliefs was not associated with fear-avoidance outcomes in the short term. We also found that patients’ baseline treatment beliefs were not associated with fear-avoidance outcomes in either the short term or at six months. These findings suggest that addressing fear-related thoughts and behaviors may be more important for improving fear-avoidance outcomes than matching treatment to a patient’s initial beliefs about active vs passive care.Keywords: patient beliefs, fear-avoidance beliefs, FABQ, neck pain, manual therapy, rehabilitation

Related

  1. High-intensity interval versus moderate-intensity continuous freestyle swimming in obese college students: A randomized controlled study protocol examining glycolipid and vascular endothelial responses
    Mei Yang, Jingjing Wang, Xiaoyun Su +2
    PLOS OnePeer-reviewedCC BYFull textEnzymology & metabolismNeurosciencePLOSEurope PMCPMC
  2. Examining the Gastrointestinal Effects of Solnul®, a Prebiotic Resistant Potato Starch: A Replication Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Clinical Trial in Healthy Adults
    Jason R. Bush, Izuchukwu Iwuamadi, Edward C. Deehan
    NutrientsPeer-reviewedCC BY 4.0NutritionCrossref
  3. Assessing an educational strategy to improve community health provider-led provision of cervical cancer screening services in western Kenya: A secondary analysis of the Elimisha-HPV cluster-randomized controlled trial
    Purity Chepkoech, Stephanie B. Jordan, Breandan Makhulo +5
    Global Health & MedicinePeer-reviewedLicence not statedFull textEpidemiology & public healthPMC
  4. Blood Biomarkers of Alzheimer's Disease Neuropathology, Cognition, and Response to a Multidomain Lifestyle Intervention: Secondary analysis of the FINGER Randomized Controlled Dementia Risk Reduction Trial
    A. Rosenberg, A. Solomon, A. Matton +13
    medRxivPreprintAll rights reservedFull textNeurologymedRxiv
  5. Participant Characteristics Associated With Loneliness Reduction During a Digital Social Robot Intervention Among Older Adults Living Alone in Japan: Secondary Analysis of a Randomized Controlled Trial
    Hiroshi Murayama, Mai Takase
    Journal of Medical Internet ResearchPeer-reviewedCC BYFull textEpidemiology & public healthDOAJ
BibTeX
@article{kirby2026aligning,
  title = {{Aligning Care with Patient Treatment Beliefs: A Secondary Analysis of a Randomized Controlled Trial Examining the Role of Fear Avoidance Beliefs in Neck Pain}},
  author = {Kirby KW and Lorenzetti JM and Kidd JA and Young JL and Cleland JA and Schenk RJ},
  journal = {Patient Preference and Adherence},
  year = {2026},
  month = nov,
  url = {https://www.dovepress.com/aligning-care-with-patient-treatment-beliefs-a-secondary-analysis-of-a-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-PPA},
  note = {CC BY},
}
RIS
TY  - JOUR
TI  - Aligning Care with Patient Treatment Beliefs: A Secondary Analysis of a Randomized Controlled Trial Examining the Role of Fear Avoidance Beliefs in Neck Pain
AU  - Kirby KW
AU  - Lorenzetti JM
AU  - Kidd JA
AU  - Young JL
AU  - Cleland JA
AU  - Schenk RJ
PY  - 2026
DA  - 2026/11/15
JO  - Patient Preference and Adherence
UR  - https://www.dovepress.com/aligning-care-with-patient-treatment-beliefs-a-secondary-analysis-of-a-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-PPA
AB  - Kenneth W Kirby,1,2 Joseph M Lorenzetti,2 Joshua A Kidd,2 Jodi L Young,2 Joshua A Cleland,3 Ronald J Schenk4 1Rehabilitation Services, Musculoskeletal Rehabilitation, The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, Columbus, OH, USA; 2Department of Physical Therapy, Doctor of Science in Physical Therapy Program, Bellin College, Green Bay, WI, USA; 3Department of Rehabilitation Science, Doctor of Physical Therapy Program, Tufts University School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA; 4Department of Rehabilitation Science, Division of Physical Therapy, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC, USACorrespondence: Kenneth W Kirby, Rehabilitation Services, Musculoskeletal Rehabilitation, The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center Hilliard Community Center, Physical Therapy 3995 Cosgray Rd, Suite 1000, Hilliard, OH, 43026, USA, Email [email protected]: Patient beliefs regarding the anticipated benefit of specific treatments may influence rehabilitation outcomes; however, the relationship between treatment beliefs, treatment-belief concordance, and fear-avoidance outcomes remains unclear.Purpose: To determine whether baseline treatment-belief concordance moderated the relationship between treatment group and short-term fear-avoidance outcomes and whether baseline treatment beliefs were associated with short- and long-term fear-avoidance outcomes in individuals with neck pain.Design: Secondary analysis of a randomized controlled trial.Methods: Patients with neck pain (N = 106) were classified according to baseline active or passive treatment-belief profiles and randomly assigned to receive either exercise alone or manual therapy combined with exercise. Fear-avoidance beliefs related to physical activity (FABQ-PA) and work (FABQ-W) were assessed at baseline, visit 3, and 6 months. Analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) models examined whether treatment-belief concordance moderated the relationship between treatment group and fear-avoidance outcomes at visit 3 and whether baseline active and passive treatment belief scores were associated with fear-avoidance outcomes at visit 3 and 6 months. Models were adjusted for baseline fear-avoidance beliefs, baseline pain intensity (NPRS), symptom duration, and treatment group where appropriate.Results: Of 106 participants, 64 (60.4%) reported an active treatment-belief profile, whereas 42 (39.6%) reported a passive treatment-belief profile. Treatment-belief concordance was not associated with FABQ-PA or FABQ-W outcomes at visit 3 (all p > 0.05). Baseline active and passive treatment-belief scores were not associated with FABQ-PA or FABQ-W outcomes at either visit 3 or 6 months (all p > 0.05).Conclusions: In individuals with neck pain, treatment-belief concordance was not associated with short-term fear-avoidance outcomes, and baseline treatment-belief scores were not associated with short- or long-term fear-avoidance outcomes. These findings suggest that matching treatment to patients’ initial beliefs regarding active vs passive care may not influence subsequent fear-avoidance outcomes.Plain Language Summary: Neck pain can lead some people to avoid physical activity or work because they fear these activities will worsen their pain. Researchers call these concerns fear-avoidance beliefs. We wanted to understand whether patients’ beliefs about which treatments would help them most, such as active approaches (exercise) or passive approaches (hands-on treatments), influenced changes in fear-avoidance over time.We analyzed data from 106 adults with neck pain who participated in a clinical trial and received either an exercise program alone or manual therapy combined with exercise. Before treatment, participants reported whether they believed active or passive treatments would be most beneficial. We then examined whether receiving a treatment that matched those beliefs affected fear-avoidance outcomes and whether baseline treatment beliefs predicted future fear-avoidance.We found that receiving a treatment that matched patients’ treatment beliefs was not associated with fear-avoidance outcomes in the short term. We also found that patients’ baseline treatment beliefs were not associated with fear-avoidance outcomes in either the short term or at six months. These findings suggest that addressing fear-related thoughts and behaviors may be more important for improving fear-avoidance outcomes than matching treatment to a patient’s initial beliefs about active vs passive care.Keywords: patient beliefs, fear-avoidance beliefs, FABQ, neck pain, manual therapy, rehabilitation
SN  - 1177-889X
ER  -