From burial to barrier: how burial history controls the hydraulic conductivity in argillaceous formations
- 1RWTH Aachen University (Aachen, Germany)
Abstract
Deep geological repositories for high-level radioactive waste (HLW) rely to a large extent on the long-term sealing integrity of host rocks to limit fluid flow and radionuclide migration. Low hydraulic conductivity (K<10-10 m s ⁻¹ ; StandAG, 2017) is a key factor for effective long-term barrier performance. Among other properties, argillaceous formations are promising candidates due to their effective aquitard characteristics. However, predicting their bulk hydraulic behaviour across temporal and spatial scales remains difficult, as it reflects the combined effects of intrinsic material properties and post-depositional evolution. This study compiles 782 hydraulic conductivity measurements from six European argillaceous formations, including laboratory and field scales. By integrating petrophysical, mineralogical, and reconstructed burial history data, we identify systematic links between burial evolution and hydraulic behaviour. Results show that maximum burial depth and associated stress and temperature conditions emerge as a primary and consistent control on matrix-scale hydraulic conductivity, which is largely retained after uplift. In contrast, bulk hydraulic behaviour at the rock-mass scale reflects interactions between maximum burial depth and present-day depth, as controlled by processes such as decompaction, fracturing, and self-sealing processes. Three evolutionary trends emerge from the compiled data: (1) Shallowly buried (<400 m), poorly indurated formations show limited hydraulic variability and scale independence; (2) Moderately buried (∼850–2000 m), over-consolidated (stiff clay) formations retain low matrix hydraulic conductivity after uplift, but exhibit gradually (partly significantly) enhanced hydraulic conductivity at depths <100 m due to the evolution of a pronounced decompaction zone. When devoted to less pronounced uplift and at greater present-day depths (>250 m) matrix and bulk hydraulic conductivities converge and predominantly range within a natural variability between 10 ⁻¹⁴ to 10 ⁻¹² m s ⁻¹ , indicating effective self-sealing processes; (3) deeply buried formations (>2000 m) become increasingly indurated and brittle, with reduced self-sealing capacity due to the loss of swellable clay mineral phases and fracture-dominated bulk hydraulic behaviour. Matrix and rock-mass hydraulic conductivities may diverge by several orders of magnitude. These trends provide predictive insights into the long-term barrier performance of argillaceous host rocks in HLW repositories.
Versions
Related
- Geologically-inspired and mutation-aware driven well log density reconstruction method for complex heterogeneous formations
- A Technical Feasibility Assessment Using Reservoir Simulation for CO2 Storage in Sarmatian Formations of the Getic Platform, Romania
- The circulation and water mass (trans)formations in the Arctic Mediterranean Sea and their implications for the deep ocean circulation: a narrative
- Elevated environmental humidity modulates aquaporin expression and impacts leaf hydraulic efficiency in silver birch (Betula pendula)
- Development of a Combined Detection and Relocation Workflow (TM2DD) to Characterize Escalating Hydraulic Fracturing Induced Seismicity in the Karnes Trough Fault Zone of the Eagle Ford Shale Play, Texas
BibTeX
@article{burchartz2026from,
title = {{From burial to barrier: how burial history controls the hydraulic conductivity in argillaceous formations}},
author = {Raphael Burchartz and Brian Mutuma Mbui and Peter Achtziger-Zupančič and Garri Gaus and Timo Seemann and Lisa Winhausen and Yvonne Spychala and Mohammadreza Jalali and Ralf Littke and Florian Amann},
journal = {Solid Earth},
year = {2026},
month = nov,
doi = {10.5194/se-17-1239-2026},
url = {https://se.copernicus.org/articles/17/1239/2026/},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - From burial to barrier: how burial history controls the hydraulic conductivity in argillaceous formations
AU - Raphael Burchartz
AU - Brian Mutuma Mbui
AU - Peter Achtziger-Zupančič
AU - Garri Gaus
AU - Timo Seemann
AU - Lisa Winhausen
AU - Yvonne Spychala
AU - Mohammadreza Jalali
AU - Ralf Littke
AU - Florian Amann
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/11/03
JO - Solid Earth
DO - 10.5194/se-17-1239-2026
UR - https://se.copernicus.org/articles/17/1239/2026/
AB - Deep geological repositories for high-level radioactive waste (HLW) rely to a large extent on the long-term sealing integrity of host rocks to limit fluid flow and radionuclide migration. Low hydraulic conductivity (K<10-10 m s ⁻¹ ; StandAG, 2017) is a key factor for effective long-term barrier performance. Among other properties, argillaceous formations are promising candidates due to their effective aquitard characteristics. However, predicting their bulk hydraulic behaviour across temporal and spatial scales remains difficult, as it reflects the combined effects of intrinsic material properties and post-depositional evolution. This study compiles 782 hydraulic conductivity measurements from six European argillaceous formations, including laboratory and field scales. By integrating petrophysical, mineralogical, and reconstructed burial history data, we identify systematic links between burial evolution and hydraulic behaviour. Results show that maximum burial depth and associated stress and temperature conditions emerge as a primary and consistent control on matrix-scale hydraulic conductivity, which is largely retained after uplift. In contrast, bulk hydraulic behaviour at the rock-mass scale reflects interactions between maximum burial depth and present-day depth, as controlled by processes such as decompaction, fracturing, and self-sealing processes. Three evolutionary trends emerge from the compiled data: (1) Shallowly buried (<400 m), poorly indurated formations show limited hydraulic variability and scale independence; (2) Moderately buried (∼850–2000 m), over-consolidated (stiff clay) formations retain low matrix hydraulic conductivity after uplift, but exhibit gradually (partly significantly) enhanced hydraulic conductivity at depths <100 m due to the evolution of a pronounced decompaction zone. When devoted to less pronounced uplift and at greater present-day depths (>250 m) matrix and bulk hydraulic conductivities converge and predominantly range within a natural variability between 10 ⁻¹⁴ to 10 ⁻¹² m s ⁻¹ , indicating effective self-sealing processes; (3) deeply buried formations (>2000 m) become increasingly indurated and brittle, with reduced self-sealing capacity due to the loss of swellable clay mineral phases and fracture-dominated bulk hydraulic behaviour. Matrix and rock-mass hydraulic conductivities may diverge by several orders of magnitude. These trends provide predictive insights into the long-term barrier performance of argillaceous host rocks in HLW repositories.
SN - 1869-9529
ER -