Military Contamination and Regimes of Scientific Recognition: A Conceptual Framework
- 1NEVG
Abstract
This article develops a conceptual framework for analyzing military contamination as a long-term, distributed, and often under-recognized process. Rather than focusing on the moral classification of individual scientists, it examines the institutional and cognitive organization of scientific knowledge in contexts where state, military, and industrial activities produce environmental harm. The article introduces the concept of a regime of scientific recognition: a historically situated configuration of evidentiary rules, institutional dependencies, disciplinary practices, and forms of responsibility that determines what counts as contamination, how fragmented evidence is interpreted, and what consequences follow from uncertainty. Three ideal-typical regimes are distinguished: accompanying science, which enables, regulates, or normalizes military and state objectives; warning science, which treats incomplete but converging evidence as sufficient grounds for precaution; and critical reconstruction, which investigates both environmental harm and the conditions that delayed or obscured its recognition. The article argues that military contamination requires analysis not only through environmental science, toxicology, medicine, and geography, but also through the sociology of scientific knowledge, the history of expertise, political ecology, and theories of institutional responsibility. The proposed framework shifts attention from isolated pollutants to the organization of knowledge that makes long-term contamination visible or invisible within scientific and political communities alike.
Related
- Fertilizer and soil health for sustained crop production in sub-Saharan Africa: Theory and conceptual framework
- A conceptual framework for life cycle sustainability assessment of mobility systems
- Societal readiness for just energy transitions: toward an integrated conceptual framework
- The conceptual scope of landscape services: A framework for assessing services related to the environment at the landscape scale
- LitCurate: A Configuration-Driven AI-Assisted Framework for Scientific Database Construction with an Application to Lower-Mantle Equation-of-State Data
BibTeX
@article{nikolaenko2026military,
title = {{Military Contamination and Regimes of Scientific Recognition: A Conceptual Framework}},
author = {Dmitry Nikolaenko},
journal = {Pollution and Diseases},
year = {2026},
month = jun,
doi = {10.66659/bb4q9n88},
url = {https://doi.org/10.66659/bb4q9n88},
note = {CC BY},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Military Contamination and Regimes of Scientific Recognition: A Conceptual Framework
AU - Dmitry Nikolaenko
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/06/04
JO - Pollution and Diseases
DO - 10.66659/bb4q9n88
UR - https://doi.org/10.66659/bb4q9n88
AB - This article develops a conceptual framework for analyzing military contamination as a long-term, distributed, and often under-recognized process. Rather than focusing on the moral classification of individual scientists, it examines the institutional and cognitive organization of scientific knowledge in contexts where state, military, and industrial activities produce environmental harm. The article introduces the concept of a regime of scientific recognition: a historically situated configuration of evidentiary rules, institutional dependencies, disciplinary practices, and forms of responsibility that determines what counts as contamination, how fragmented evidence is interpreted, and what consequences follow from uncertainty. Three ideal-typical regimes are distinguished: accompanying science, which enables, regulates, or normalizes military and state objectives; warning science, which treats incomplete but converging evidence as sufficient grounds for precaution; and critical reconstruction, which investigates both environmental harm and the conditions that delayed or obscured its recognition. The article argues that military contamination requires analysis not only through environmental science, toxicology, medicine, and geography, but also through the sociology of scientific knowledge, the history of expertise, political ecology, and theories of institutional responsibility. The proposed framework shifts attention from isolated pollutants to the organization of knowledge that makes long-term contamination visible or invisible within scientific and political communities alike.
SN - 3029-9039
ER -