Lock-ins and bounded strategies: a systems-based theory of change for organic vegetable farming in Flanders
Abstract
Organic farming is central to the sustainability goals of the European Union, yet it remains marginal in intensively farmed regions such as Flanders. Taking up the notion of systemic lock-in, we examine why organic vegetable farming struggles to expand in this region and why a strategy developed in a participatory systems mapping workshop converged on a bounded set of actions perceived as feasible by participants. Findings reveal how multiple mechanisms jointly hamper the sector’s expansion and its distinctiveness from conventional agriculture. These include competition for scarce land and seasonal labour, retailer driven pricing and standard specifications, exposure to imports and macro-economic shocks, and a knowledge–policy bias towards sustainable intensification solutions. To overcome these struggles, participants prioritised coordination measures within existing mandates and institutional relationships, including raising consumer awareness, seeking commitments across the value chain to secure sales channels and a steady local supply, dedicated advisory services and public procurement. By overlaying the participatorily developed Theory of Change onto ex post refined system maps, we make the scope and limits of the designed interventions analytically visible. Ex post analysis indicates that these measures leave the engine behind the on-going agro-industrialization in the region intact and leave the organic vegetable sector vulnerable to wider shocks and trends. The boundedness of the resulting portfolio reflects the effects of participation and goal framing, the institutional context and changing political-economic conditions. We conclude with analytical implications for participatory strategy design and discuss implications for building transformative agroecological politics and policy.
Related
- Yield determinants in rice under organic and conventional production systems: Implications for selection strategies
- Nutritional strategies using synbiotics and organic acids to enhance piglet post-weaning growth and gut health.
- Organic‐microbial strategies for iron and zinc biofortification in orange‐fleshed sweet potato [Ipomoea batatas (L.) Lam.]
- Toward a global chemogeography of dissolved organic matter: a molecular trait dataset across Earth systems
- Ecologically based agriculture benefits earthworms in Argentina’s large-scale systems: farm-level strategies matter
BibTeX
@article{tessier2026lockins,
title = {{Lock-ins and bounded strategies: a systems-based theory of change for organic vegetable farming in Flanders}},
author = {Louis Tessier and Marija Roglic and Domenico Dentoni},
journal = {Agriculture and Human Values},
year = {2026},
month = may,
doi = {10.1007/s10460-026-10910-9},
url = {https://hal.science/hal-05840381v1},
note = {CC BY-NC-ND},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Lock-ins and bounded strategies: a systems-based theory of change for organic vegetable farming in Flanders
AU - Louis Tessier
AU - Marija Roglic
AU - Domenico Dentoni
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/05/13
JO - Agriculture and Human Values
DO - 10.1007/s10460-026-10910-9
UR - https://hal.science/hal-05840381v1
AB - Organic farming is central to the sustainability goals of the European Union, yet it remains marginal in intensively farmed regions such as Flanders. Taking up the notion of systemic lock-in, we examine why organic vegetable farming struggles to expand in this region and why a strategy developed in a participatory systems mapping workshop converged on a bounded set of actions perceived as feasible by participants. Findings reveal how multiple mechanisms jointly hamper the sector’s expansion and its distinctiveness from conventional agriculture. These include competition for scarce land and seasonal labour, retailer driven pricing and standard specifications, exposure to imports and macro-economic shocks, and a knowledge–policy bias towards sustainable intensification solutions. To overcome these struggles, participants prioritised coordination measures within existing mandates and institutional relationships, including raising consumer awareness, seeking commitments across the value chain to secure sales channels and a steady local supply, dedicated advisory services and public procurement. By overlaying the participatorily developed Theory of Change onto ex post refined system maps, we make the scope and limits of the designed interventions analytically visible. Ex post analysis indicates that these measures leave the engine behind the on-going agro-industrialization in the region intact and leave the organic vegetable sector vulnerable to wider shocks and trends. The boundedness of the resulting portfolio reflects the effects of participation and goal framing, the institutional context and changing political-economic conditions. We conclude with analytical implications for participatory strategy design and discuss implications for building transformative agroecological politics and policy.
SN - 0889-048X
SN - 1572-8366
ER -