Including ratio traits in multiple trait selection
- 1School of Environmental and Rural Science, University of New England, Armidale, NSW 2351 Australia
Abstract
Background: Animal breeding programs aim to improve productivity while reducing input costs and resource use. As sustainability has become a central concern, feed intake and enteric methane emissions now feature more prominently in breeding objectives, supported by increasing availability of individual-animal measurements for those traits. An important question is how to incorporate these traits most effectively in selection indices that aim at improving both resource efficiency and environmental outcomes. A seemingly appealing strategy is to augment existing selection indices with a ratio trait such as production per unit of feed intake or methane emitted per unit of product, as direct indicators of efficiency. This paper will investigate selection indices that include a ratio trait. Selection index theory was used to compare single trait selection for a ratio trait with selection based on a linear index comprising the component traits, as well as with selection including both the ratio trait and one of its components. Genetic parameters for ratio traits were approximated from those of the component traits. When incorporating a ratio trait into the breeding objective, the economic weights of the component traits were correspondingly adjusted.
Results: When ratio traits are used as a single trait selection criterion, the response to selection is driven largely by the coefficient of genetic variation of each component trait. However, an index including a ratio trait as well as one of the component traits is equivalent to a linear index with the two component traits. A breeding objective including both a ratio trait and a component trait requires an adjustment of economic values of the component traits.
Conclusion: Ratio traits such as feed efficiency and methane intensity can be used in selection indices as they give equivalent selection responses as indices that include the component traits (e.g. feed intake and methane production) alongside production traits, provided that at least one of the component traits—either the numerator or denominator—is also included in the index and economic weights are adjusted accordingly.
Related
- Multi-Trait GWAS Analyses of Blood Pressure Traits Provide Limited Gains in Locus Discovery or Polygenic Risk Score Performance Compared to Single-Trait GWAS.
- Genome-wide cross-trait analysis to compare genetic architecture between Parkinson's disease and kidney-related traits.
- Trade-offs among selection regimes shape trait evolution and resilience in three-guild networks
- Multi-Trait Phenotypic and SSR-Based Genetic Diversity Assessment of Individual Plants for Parental Selection in Turf-Type Tall Fescue
- Genetic variation and trait selection in ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum Lam.) across dry and rainy seasons in Peru
BibTeX
@article{werf2026including,
title = {{Including ratio traits in multiple trait selection}},
author = {Julius H. J. van der Werf},
journal = {Genetics, Selection, Evolution : GSE},
year = {2026},
month = nov,
doi = {10.1186/s12711-026-01111-3},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1186/s12711-026-01111-3},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Including ratio traits in multiple trait selection
AU - Julius H. J. van der Werf
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/11/11
JO - Genetics, Selection, Evolution : GSE
DO - 10.1186/s12711-026-01111-3
UR - https://doi.org/10.1186/s12711-026-01111-3
AB - Background: Animal breeding programs aim to improve productivity while reducing input costs and resource use. As sustainability has become a central concern, feed intake and enteric methane emissions now feature more prominently in breeding objectives, supported by increasing availability of individual-animal measurements for those traits. An important question is how to incorporate these traits most effectively in selection indices that aim at improving both resource efficiency and environmental outcomes. A seemingly appealing strategy is to augment existing selection indices with a ratio trait such as production per unit of feed intake or methane emitted per unit of product, as direct indicators of efficiency. This paper will investigate selection indices that include a ratio trait. Selection index theory was used to compare single trait selection for a ratio trait with selection based on a linear index comprising the component traits, as well as with selection including both the ratio trait and one of its components. Genetic parameters for ratio traits were approximated from those of the component traits. When incorporating a ratio trait into the breeding objective, the economic weights of the component traits were correspondingly adjusted. Results: When ratio traits are used as a single trait selection criterion, the response to selection is driven largely by the coefficient of genetic variation of each component trait. However, an index including a ratio trait as well as one of the component traits is equivalent to a linear index with the two component traits. A breeding objective including both a ratio trait and a component trait requires an adjustment of economic values of the component traits. Conclusion: Ratio traits such as feed efficiency and methane intensity can be used in selection indices as they give equivalent selection responses as indices that include the component traits (e.g. feed intake and methane production) alongside production traits, provided that at least one of the component traits—either the numerator or denominator—is also included in the index and economic weights are adjusted accordingly.
SN - 0999-193X
SN - 1297-9686
ER -