The queer Hero versus the Fool bias of the queer trait: An archetypometric analysis of the collective portrayal of queerness in fictional stories
Abstract
Visibility in media is pivotal for identity development and for broadening societal views of gender and sexuality. Queer representation has increased in recent years, yet damaging stereotypes and tropes persist. Here, we focus on queer portrayal and its perception by audiences in fictional stories (television, film, and literature) by studying characters by their quantified archetypes which are operationalizations of common conceptions such as Hero, Diva, and Outcast. We use the archetypometrics and Fandom's LGBTQIA+ datasets to study samples of fictional characters along the trait differential spanning straight to queer. We find, quantify, and explain a seeming paradox. The characters with the highest queer score present positive primary archetypes and are typically Heroes rather than Fools, Angels rather than Demons, and Adventurers rather than Traditionalists. But evaluation across many stories for the straight-queer trait itself reveals a strong collective-writing bias towards Fool (away from Hero) and no meaningful loading for the other two dimensions. Our analysis offers a population-scale view of the complexities of queer portrayal, while also pointing to risks in blindly training on many-authored story corpora.
Related
- Adaptive negativity estimation via collective measurements
- Collective charge excitations in the kagome lattice driven by Holstein phonons and magnetic fields
- Microscopic description of the fission process including intrinsic excitations. Part II: 240Pu excited and asymmetric fission paths within the Schrodinger Collective
- Microscopic description of the fission process including intrinsic excitations. Part I: 240Pu adiabatic and asymmetric fission path within the Schrodinger Collective Intrinsic Model
- Microscopic description of the fission process including intrinsic excitations. Part III: 240Pu fission dynamics along 1D asymmetric paths within the Schrodinger Collective Intrinsic Model
BibTeX
@misc{fehr2026queer,
title = {{The queer Hero versus the Fool bias of the queer trait: An archetypometric analysis of the collective portrayal of queerness in fictional stories}},
author = {Ashley M. A. Fehr and Calla Glavin Beauregard and Julia Witte Zimmerman and Danny Benett and Timothy R. Tangherlini and Christopher M. Danforth and Peter Sheridan Dodds},
howpublished = {arXiv},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
doi = {10.48550/arxiv.2607.08859},
eprint = {2607.08859},
archivePrefix = {arXiv},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.08859},
}
RIS
TY - UNPB
TI - The queer Hero versus the Fool bias of the queer trait: An archetypometric analysis of the collective portrayal of queerness in fictional stories
AU - Ashley M. A. Fehr
AU - Calla Glavin Beauregard
AU - Julia Witte Zimmerman
AU - Danny Benett
AU - Timothy R. Tangherlini
AU - Christopher M. Danforth
AU - Peter Sheridan Dodds
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/09/24
PB - arXiv
DO - 10.48550/arxiv.2607.08859
UR - https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.08859
AB - Visibility in media is pivotal for identity development and for broadening societal views of gender and sexuality. Queer representation has increased in recent years, yet damaging stereotypes and tropes persist. Here, we focus on queer portrayal and its perception by audiences in fictional stories (television, film, and literature) by studying characters by their quantified archetypes which are operationalizations of common conceptions such as Hero, Diva, and Outcast. We use the archetypometrics and Fandom's LGBTQIA+ datasets to study samples of fictional characters along the trait differential spanning straight to queer. We find, quantify, and explain a seeming paradox. The characters with the highest queer score present positive primary archetypes and are typically Heroes rather than Fools, Angels rather than Demons, and Adventurers rather than Traditionalists. But evaluation across many stories for the straight-queer trait itself reveals a strong collective-writing bias towards Fool (away from Hero) and no meaningful loading for the other two dimensions. Our analysis offers a population-scale view of the complexities of queer portrayal, while also pointing to risks in blindly training on many-authored story corpora.
ER -