Mild generalised hypermobility (Beighton score ≥2) is the most accurate preoperative indicator of intraoperatively-confirmed microinstability in 622 primary hip arthroscopies.
6 affiliations
- 1Orthosports North Harbour Ltd., Millennium Centre Auckland New Zealand.
- 2School of Nursing, Waipapa Taumata Rau/University of Auckland Auckland New Zealand.
- 3Te Whatu Ora/Health New Zealand Auckland New Zealand.
- 4Faculty of Medical and Health Sciences, Waipapa Taumata Rau/University of Auckland Auckland New Zealand.
- 5Auckland Radiology Group Auckland New Zealand.
- 6Apex Sports Clinic Singapore Singapore.
Abstract
Purpose
To identify the preoperative diagnostic accuracy of routine hip arthroscopy clinical assessments for intraoperatively confirmed microinstability.Methods
Image indices, clinical assessments and operation details from 622 consecutive primary hip arthroscopies undertaken by a single surgeon between January 2018 and December 2020 were extracted from the surgeon's database. Microinstability diagnosis was retrospectively confirmed by the presence of any of four intraoperative criteria: increased ease of distraction of the hip, isolated straight anterior labral tear, inside-out chondral lesion or a lateral Seldes 2 or 3 labral tear in the absence of cam or pincer morphology. Optimal thresholds for numerical measures were determined using receiver operating characteristic curve (ROC) analyses by minimising the distance from the point of perfect sensitivity and specificity. Diagnostic parameters, calculated from contingency tables, were evaluated for individual and combinations of demographic, examination and imaging indices, including age, self-reported gender, risk-sport participation, positive log roll/hip dial test, Beighton score, hip range-of-motion, lateral centre-edge angle (LCEA), Tonnis angle, crossover sign and ischial sign.Results
A total of 622 hips (533 patients) aged 35.5 ± 11.8 years, 56%:44% female:male ratio were identified. Female patients were 2.08 times more likely than male to have microinstability (sensitivity 0.93, specificity 0.55). A Beighton score ≥2 was the best overall indicator of microinstability (sensitivity 0.85, specificity 0.82, positive likelihood ratio 4.73, negative likelihood ratio 0.18). Presence of female gender, with either LCEA < 35° or Beighton score ≥2, increased sensitivity to 0.93, at the expense of specificity (0.69) and no combination of indices surpassed Beighton score alone in the Youden index (sensitivity + specificity - 1).Conclusion
Among the individual and combined presurgical indicators evaluated, Beighton score ≥2 was the most accurate test for intraoperatively-confirmed microinstability in primary hip arthroscopy patients. Mild generalised laxity, particularly in female patients with a slightly shallow acetabulum (LCEA < 35°), should raise suspicion of microinstability to minimise missed diagnoses.Level of evidence
Level III, diagnostic study.
Related
- Rationale for giving antiepileptics intraoperatively in patients undergoing surgery for supratentorial brain tumors.
- Uterus Didelphys Bicollis Diagnosed Intraoperatively in a Primigravida After Long-Standing Primary Infertility: A Case Report.
- Association Between Joint Hypermobility and Pelvic Organ Prolapse: A Hospital‐Based Cross‐Sectional Study
- Early Clinical Outcomes Following Patient-Specific Visual Feedback Using Intraoperatively Recorded Knee Motion After Total Knee Arthroplasty
- Beyond Primary Epilepsy: Fahr's Syndrome Secondary to Congenital Parathyroid Agenesis Presenting With Generalised Seizures in a Young Adult
BibTeX
@article{bacon2026mild,
title = {{Mild generalised hypermobility (Beighton score ≥2) is the most accurate preoperative indicator of intraoperatively-confirmed microinstability in 622 primary hip arthroscopies.}},
author = {Catherine J Bacon and Rowan P Auchterlonie and Rebecca M Woodward and Gen Lin Foo and Man Lu and Renuka M Vesey and Matthew J Brick},
journal = {Journal of experimental orthopaedics},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.1002/jeo2.70955},
url = {https://europepmc.org/article/MED/42910389},
note = {CC BY},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Mild generalised hypermobility (Beighton score ≥2) is the most accurate preoperative indicator of intraoperatively-confirmed microinstability in 622 primary hip arthroscopies.
AU - Catherine J Bacon
AU - Rowan P Auchterlonie
AU - Rebecca M Woodward
AU - Gen Lin Foo
AU - Man Lu
AU - Renuka M Vesey
AU - Matthew J Brick
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/21
JO - Journal of experimental orthopaedics
DO - 10.1002/jeo2.70955
UR - https://europepmc.org/article/MED/42910389
AB - Purpose To identify the preoperative diagnostic accuracy of routine hip arthroscopy clinical assessments for intraoperatively confirmed microinstability.Methods Image indices, clinical assessments and operation details from 622 consecutive primary hip arthroscopies undertaken by a single surgeon between January 2018 and December 2020 were extracted from the surgeon's database. Microinstability diagnosis was retrospectively confirmed by the presence of any of four intraoperative criteria: increased ease of distraction of the hip, isolated straight anterior labral tear, inside-out chondral lesion or a lateral Seldes 2 or 3 labral tear in the absence of cam or pincer morphology. Optimal thresholds for numerical measures were determined using receiver operating characteristic curve (ROC) analyses by minimising the distance from the point of perfect sensitivity and specificity. Diagnostic parameters, calculated from contingency tables, were evaluated for individual and combinations of demographic, examination and imaging indices, including age, self-reported gender, risk-sport participation, positive log roll/hip dial test, Beighton score, hip range-of-motion, lateral centre-edge angle (LCEA), Tonnis angle, crossover sign and ischial sign.Results A total of 622 hips (533 patients) aged 35.5 ± 11.8 years, 56%:44% female:male ratio were identified. Female patients were 2.08 times more likely than male to have microinstability (sensitivity 0.93, specificity 0.55). A Beighton score ≥2 was the best overall indicator of microinstability (sensitivity 0.85, specificity 0.82, positive likelihood ratio 4.73, negative likelihood ratio 0.18). Presence of female gender, with either LCEA < 35° or Beighton score ≥2, increased sensitivity to 0.93, at the expense of specificity (0.69) and no combination of indices surpassed Beighton score alone in the Youden index (sensitivity + specificity - 1).Conclusion Among the individual and combined presurgical indicators evaluated, Beighton score ≥2 was the most accurate test for intraoperatively-confirmed microinstability in primary hip arthroscopy patients. Mild generalised laxity, particularly in female patients with a slightly shallow acetabulum (LCEA < 35°), should raise suspicion of microinstability to minimise missed diagnoses.Level of evidence Level III, diagnostic study.
SN - 2197-1153
ER -