Sustainable Polymers as System-Dependent Technologies: A Critical Engineering Assessment of LCA Evidence, Circular Compatibility, and Scalability Constraints
- 1Department of Industrial Engineering and Management, Faculty of Engineering, Lucian Blaga University of Sibiu, 550024 Sibiu, Romania
- 2S.C. Fusion România S.R:L, Ștefan cel Mare Street, no. 152-154, 550321 Sibiu, Romania
- 3Faculty of Economics, “Constantin Brâncuși” University of Targu Jiu, 210185 Târgu Jiu, Romania
Abstract
The transition toward sustainable polymer systems is frequently framed as a material substitution challenge. However, the environmental performance of bio-based, biodegradable, and recyclable polymers is not an intrinsic property of feedstock origin but a system-dependent outcome shaped by energy inputs, infrastructure compatibility, economic feasibility, and governance alignment. This review provides a critical engineering assessment of sustainable polymer technologies based on systematic evidence screening (n = 193), bibliometric analysis, life cycle assessment (LCA) synthesis, techno-economic indicators, end-of-life scenario interpretation, and a multi-criteria evidence synthesis based on source-linked quantitative indicators and categorical evidence. To avoid treating these components as parallel but disconnected analyses, the synthesis explicitly links bibliometric clusters with LCA, TEA, and infrastructure evidence categories through an evidence-gap mapping matrix and confidence grading scheme. The findings indicate that bio-based polymers, such as PLA, PHA, and PBS, may achieve reduced greenhouse gas emissions under optimized production conditions; however, these advantages are highly sensitive to electricity carbon intensity, land-use assumptions, and end-of-life infrastructure. Quantitative LCA evidence indicates that polylactic acid (PLA) may achieve greenhouse gas emission reductions in the range of approximately 25–55% compared to conventional PET under low-carbon energy scenarios (1.3–3.0 vs. 2.0–3.5 kg CO2e/kg), while polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHA) show reductions of 10–40%, depending on fermentation efficiency and feedstock selection. However, these benefits can diminish or reverse under fossil-intensive energy mixes or when land-use change impacts are included, reinforcing the system-dependent nature of sustainability performance. Recyclability within established material streams frequently provides more stable long-term performance than biodegradable alternatives deployed without controlled composting systems. Evidence-strength analysis reveals moderate confidence in carbon footprint comparisons, weak-to-moderate confidence in techno-economic scalability claims, and conditional confidence in infrastructure-dependent outcomes. The results demonstrate that sustainable polymers are system-dependent technologies rather than inherently sustainable materials. Future engineering research must prioritize integrated LCA–TEA modeling, infrastructure-aligned material design, scenario-based end-of-life assessment, and harmonized sustainability reporting standards to enable scalable and verifiable circular polymer systems.
Related
- Molecular Design and Interface Engineering of Self-Assembled Monolayers for Inverted Perovskite Solar Cells: A Data-Driven Review of Efficiency, Stability and Scalability
- Winery By-Products as Sustainable Functional Resources: An Overview of Composition, Green Extraction Technologies, and Industrial Valorization
- Towards Sustainable Regenerated Cellulose Fibres: A Review of Conventional Spinning Technologies and Advancing Ionic Liquid-DMSO Solvent Systems.
- Polymer-based heterojunction photocatalysts for environmental remediation and solar fuels: a review on interface engineering, stability, and sustainable design
- Clean hydrogen from water: emerging technologies for a sustainable energy future
BibTeX
@article{lazar2026sustainable,
title = {{Sustainable Polymers as System-Dependent Technologies: A Critical Engineering Assessment of LCA Evidence, Circular Compatibility, and Scalability Constraints}},
author = {Sergiu Lazăr and Dan Dobrotă and Ionela Magdalena Rotaru and Gabriela Dobrotă},
journal = {Polymers},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.3390/polym18202467},
url = {https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4360/18/20/2467},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Sustainable Polymers as System-Dependent Technologies: A Critical Engineering Assessment of LCA Evidence, Circular Compatibility, and Scalability Constraints
AU - Sergiu Lazăr
AU - Dan Dobrotă
AU - Ionela Magdalena Rotaru
AU - Gabriela Dobrotă
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/01
JO - Polymers
DO - 10.3390/polym18202467
UR - https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4360/18/20/2467
AB - The transition toward sustainable polymer systems is frequently framed as a material substitution challenge. However, the environmental performance of bio-based, biodegradable, and recyclable polymers is not an intrinsic property of feedstock origin but a system-dependent outcome shaped by energy inputs, infrastructure compatibility, economic feasibility, and governance alignment. This review provides a critical engineering assessment of sustainable polymer technologies based on systematic evidence screening (n = 193), bibliometric analysis, life cycle assessment (LCA) synthesis, techno-economic indicators, end-of-life scenario interpretation, and a multi-criteria evidence synthesis based on source-linked quantitative indicators and categorical evidence. To avoid treating these components as parallel but disconnected analyses, the synthesis explicitly links bibliometric clusters with LCA, TEA, and infrastructure evidence categories through an evidence-gap mapping matrix and confidence grading scheme. The findings indicate that bio-based polymers, such as PLA, PHA, and PBS, may achieve reduced greenhouse gas emissions under optimized production conditions; however, these advantages are highly sensitive to electricity carbon intensity, land-use assumptions, and end-of-life infrastructure. Quantitative LCA evidence indicates that polylactic acid (PLA) may achieve greenhouse gas emission reductions in the range of approximately 25–55% compared to conventional PET under low-carbon energy scenarios (1.3–3.0 vs. 2.0–3.5 kg CO2e/kg), while polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHA) show reductions of 10–40%, depending on fermentation efficiency and feedstock selection. However, these benefits can diminish or reverse under fossil-intensive energy mixes or when land-use change impacts are included, reinforcing the system-dependent nature of sustainability performance. Recyclability within established material streams frequently provides more stable long-term performance than biodegradable alternatives deployed without controlled composting systems. Evidence-strength analysis reveals moderate confidence in carbon footprint comparisons, weak-to-moderate confidence in techno-economic scalability claims, and conditional confidence in infrastructure-dependent outcomes. The results demonstrate that sustainable polymers are system-dependent technologies rather than inherently sustainable materials. Future engineering research must prioritize integrated LCA–TEA modeling, infrastructure-aligned material design, scenario-based end-of-life assessment, and harmonized sustainability reporting standards to enable scalable and verifiable circular polymer systems.
SN - 2073-4360
ER -