Mean-Centering Alters Pathway-Based Transcriptomic Comparisons of Feline and Mouse Kidney Disease
- 1Laboratory of Laboratory Animal Science and Medicine, School of Veterinary Medicine, Kitasato University, Towada 034-8628, Aomori, Japan
Abstract
Transcriptomic similarity is used to characterize disease models, but a comparison can change when the same responses are summarized differently. We examined mean-centering before pathway averaging in 16 disease states from one feline chronic kidney disease cohort and two mouse kidney injury models, using 2016 genes detected in both species’ proteomes and 422 overlapping pathways. Among 87 state pairs without shared control samples, uncentered pathway means separated same-species from cross-species pairs with an area under the curve of 0.868; removing each state’s mean across genes first reduced this to 0.511. The uncentered value was higher in 98.6% of animal-level resamples, and the difference held across nine offset and filter settings, all four gene spaces and the 83-pair subset without shared animals. Under within-state ranking or quantile normalization, which equalize each state’s overall level by construction, the contrast fell to 0.010 and 0.001. Reference-axis projections can rank states differently from cosine because they retain amplitude, and benchmark gaps were poorly calibrated. These results identify a consequential preprocessing choice rather than a preferred species or a validated measure of disease fidelity. Because all feline states came from one cohort and all mouse states from two datasets, species was confounded with dataset throughout, and the separation reported here may reflect dataset-specific technical variation rather than species biology.
Related
- Lycium barbarum Polysaccharide Fraction Ameliorates Palmitate-Induced Insulin Signaling Impairment in HepG2 Cells: Transcriptomic Evidence for the Potential Association with the DAG-PtdOH Metabolic Axis and the AMPK/ULK1 Autophagy Pathway
- Acute FGF23 Neutralization Alters Phosphate Handling and Bone Marrow Molecular Responses in Sickle Cell Disease Mice
- Self-centering steady-state flows emerge in confined actomyosin networks
- Integrated bulk and single-cell transcriptomic analyses with experimental validation identify PLOD1 as a diagnostic biomarker and TGF-β1-responsive profibrotic mediator in dupuytren’s disease
- Protocol for integrative transcriptomic/metabolomic analysis: A case study on factors influencing the oyster-POMS disease
BibTeX
@article{watanabe2026meancentering,
title = {{Mean-Centering Alters Pathway-Based Transcriptomic Comparisons of Feline and Mouse Kidney Disease}},
author = {Masaki Watanabe and Takeru Sasaki and Ryuya Nakagawa and Nobuya Sasaki},
journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.3390/ijms27209115},
url = {https://www.mdpi.com/1422-0067/27/20/9115},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Mean-Centering Alters Pathway-Based Transcriptomic Comparisons of Feline and Mouse Kidney Disease
AU - Masaki Watanabe
AU - Takeru Sasaki
AU - Ryuya Nakagawa
AU - Nobuya Sasaki
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/14
JO - International Journal of Molecular Sciences
DO - 10.3390/ijms27209115
UR - https://www.mdpi.com/1422-0067/27/20/9115
AB - Transcriptomic similarity is used to characterize disease models, but a comparison can change when the same responses are summarized differently. We examined mean-centering before pathway averaging in 16 disease states from one feline chronic kidney disease cohort and two mouse kidney injury models, using 2016 genes detected in both species’ proteomes and 422 overlapping pathways. Among 87 state pairs without shared control samples, uncentered pathway means separated same-species from cross-species pairs with an area under the curve of 0.868; removing each state’s mean across genes first reduced this to 0.511. The uncentered value was higher in 98.6% of animal-level resamples, and the difference held across nine offset and filter settings, all four gene spaces and the 83-pair subset without shared animals. Under within-state ranking or quantile normalization, which equalize each state’s overall level by construction, the contrast fell to 0.010 and 0.001. Reference-axis projections can rank states differently from cosine because they retain amplitude, and benchmark gaps were poorly calibrated. These results identify a consequential preprocessing choice rather than a preferred species or a validated measure of disease fidelity. Because all feline states came from one cohort and all mouse states from two datasets, species was confounded with dataset throughout, and the separation reported here may reflect dataset-specific technical variation rather than species biology.
SN - 1422-0067
ER -