Extracellular flux analyses indicate low ATP yield and require refinement for accurate determination of maximal oxygen consumption rate
Abstract
The Agilent Seahorse XF Analyzer has become a central tool for investigating cellular oxidative metabolism. Most studies employ the Seahorse XF Cell Mito Stress Test, which measures the oxygen consumption rate (OCR) under sequential pharmacological modulation of mitochondrial respiration. This assay partitions basal OCR into its functional components and estimates maximal OCR through uncoupler-driven stimulation of respiration, with the resulting value interpreted as the spare respiratory capacity. However, maximal OCR is obtained only after complete inhibition of ATP synthesis by oxidative phosphorylation, and its reliable determination requires appropriate uncoupler titration. Studies have underscored the limitations of this approach. To evaluate its reliability, we examined 97 recent publications reporting 530 Cell Mito Stress Tests. Strikingly, 17% of assays yielded a maximal OCR lower than the basal OCR, raising concerns about the accuracy of the method. To improve maximal OCR determination, we introduce the Cell Stimulation Test, which -analogous to maximal VO₂ assessments in patients -stimulates respiration directly from the basal state across a broad (1-8x) range of uncoupler concentrations. Using the same Seahorse plate, we compared results from both assays. Combined application of the Cell Mito Stress Test and the Cell Stimulation Test enhances the accuracy of maximal OCR assessment and eliminates the need for prior optimization of uncoupler concentration. Our survey further indicates that oxygen consumption not coupled to ATP synthesis constitutes a substantial fraction of basal cellular OCR (median ≈50%), with an unexpectedly large contribution from OCR typically classified as non-mitochondrial. We briefly discuss the implications and limitations of this observation.
Related
- Long-term sugar consumption alters extracellular dopamine and acetylcholine levels in the nucleus accumbens shell
- DNA Methylation Patterns Between Serous Uterine and Ovarian Carcinomas Indicate Shared Markers with Fallopian Tube Epithelium and Distinctions Consistent with Histopathology
- Lepidopteran Caterpillars in Ambers from Lebanon, Myanmar, Mexico, and the Dominican Republic Indicate Diversification of Defensive Structures and Increasing Abundance over Time
- Stochastic models indicate rapid smallpox spread and mass mortality of Indigenous Australians after colonial exposure
- Hippocampal theta sweeps indicate goal direction during navigation
BibTeX
@article{ransy2026extracellular,
title = {{Extracellular flux analyses indicate low ATP yield and require refinement for accurate determination of maximal oxygen consumption rate}},
author = {Celine Ransy and Mathieu Boissan and Noureddine Hammad and Abdelouhab Bouaboud and Tarik Issad and Maud de Dieuleveult and Benoit Miotto and Manuela Ye and Eric Pasmant and Frédéric Bouillaud},
journal = {Scientific Reports},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.1038/s41598-026-46479-w},
url = {https://hal.science/hal-05844381v1},
note = {CC BY-NC-SA 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Extracellular flux analyses indicate low ATP yield and require refinement for accurate determination of maximal oxygen consumption rate
AU - Celine Ransy
AU - Mathieu Boissan
AU - Noureddine Hammad
AU - Abdelouhab Bouaboud
AU - Tarik Issad
AU - Maud de Dieuleveult
AU - Benoit Miotto
AU - Manuela Ye
AU - Eric Pasmant
AU - Frédéric Bouillaud
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/29
JO - Scientific Reports
DO - 10.1038/s41598-026-46479-w
UR - https://hal.science/hal-05844381v1
AB - The Agilent Seahorse XF Analyzer has become a central tool for investigating cellular oxidative metabolism. Most studies employ the Seahorse XF Cell Mito Stress Test, which measures the oxygen consumption rate (OCR) under sequential pharmacological modulation of mitochondrial respiration. This assay partitions basal OCR into its functional components and estimates maximal OCR through uncoupler-driven stimulation of respiration, with the resulting value interpreted as the spare respiratory capacity. However, maximal OCR is obtained only after complete inhibition of ATP synthesis by oxidative phosphorylation, and its reliable determination requires appropriate uncoupler titration. Studies have underscored the limitations of this approach. To evaluate its reliability, we examined 97 recent publications reporting 530 Cell Mito Stress Tests. Strikingly, 17% of assays yielded a maximal OCR lower than the basal OCR, raising concerns about the accuracy of the method. To improve maximal OCR determination, we introduce the Cell Stimulation Test, which -analogous to maximal VO₂ assessments in patients -stimulates respiration directly from the basal state across a broad (1-8x) range of uncoupler concentrations. Using the same Seahorse plate, we compared results from both assays. Combined application of the Cell Mito Stress Test and the Cell Stimulation Test enhances the accuracy of maximal OCR assessment and eliminates the need for prior optimization of uncoupler concentration. Our survey further indicates that oxygen consumption not coupled to ATP synthesis constitutes a substantial fraction of basal cellular OCR (median ≈50%), with an unexpectedly large contribution from OCR typically classified as non-mitochondrial. We briefly discuss the implications and limitations of this observation.
SN - 2045-2322
ER -