Fostering engagement with accreditation: capitalizing on leaders’ professional values
- 1Department of Emergency Medicine, Queen’s Health Sciences, 76 Stuart St, Kingston, ON K7L 2V7 Canada
Abstract
Fostering educational leaders’ engagement with accreditation is important for the development of a Continuous Quality Improvement (CQI) culture in education programs, sustaining the quality of the education provided. Key to faculty engagement with academic demands is congruence between professional values and academic demands. To promote leaders’ engagement with accreditation, accreditation practices need to align with leaders’ values. There is currently no information on leaders’ professional values and on accreditation practices they perceive as most engaging. This study fills this gap and illustrates congruence between leaders’ professional values and accreditation practices. Appreciative inquiry, a strength-based evaluation approach focusing on what is going well in an organisation, was used to elicit perceptions from leaders of seven medical education programs (1 undergraduate, UGME, and 6 postgraduate, PGME) at one academic centre about the components of accreditation and of their professional role they find as most engaging and valuable. Two independent coders analyzed the content of interviews and focus group discussions using open, emergent coding, to identify themes and their associations. Twenty-eight (48%) of 59 invited leaders participated, 8 from UGME program (29% of total participants, 47% of UGME invitees), 20 from all 6 targeted PGME programs (71% of all participants, 48% of PGME invitees). Leaders value their role for the inherent intellectual stimulation, their contribution to learners’ growth, their effecting of meaningful changes, and the collaboration with learners and colleagues. Accreditation practices congruent with these values include comprehensive program reviews, faculty collaboration, and provision of external feedback and validation. The value of accreditation resides mainly in the preparation of documents and the visit, rather than in specific accreditation standards. Accreditation practices not congruent with leaders’ values and leading to their disengagement were also identified. Accreditation practices congruent with leaders’ professional values should be emphasized in accreditation practices to promote engagement and foster programmatic CQI, whereas non-congruent practices should be revisited for their added value. These results corroborate findings from previous literature on academic faculty engagement. Our findings will hopefully guide the development of new accreditation organisations and inform reforms of existing accreditation systems to foster leaders' meaningful engagement with accreditation and programmatic CQI.
Supplementary Information: The online version contains supplementary material available at https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-026-09938-6.
Related
- Fostering professional vision in clinical ward rounds through digital simulation-based learning with eye-movement modelling examples and personalised feedback: study protocol for four experimental studies
- Professional engagement and implementation appraisal in China’s national nutrition week: a nationwide cross-sectional study
- Strengthening Collective Professional Engagement around COPD: An Action Research in Primary Care
- Chest Pain Center Accreditation and Outcomes in Patients With Acute Chest Pain: A Single-Center Registry.
- Developing national meta-accreditation standards for medical education accreditation bodies in Iran: a mixed-methods standards development and consensus study.
BibTeX
@article{blouin2026fostering,
title = {{Fostering engagement with accreditation: capitalizing on leaders’ professional values}},
author = {Danielle Blouin},
journal = {BMC Medical Education},
year = {2026},
month = aug,
doi = {10.1186/s12909-026-09938-6},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-026-09938-6},
note = {CC BY-NC-ND 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Fostering engagement with accreditation: capitalizing on leaders’ professional values
AU - Danielle Blouin
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/08/08
JO - BMC Medical Education
DO - 10.1186/s12909-026-09938-6
UR - https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-026-09938-6
AB - Fostering educational leaders’ engagement with accreditation is important for the development of a Continuous Quality Improvement (CQI) culture in education programs, sustaining the quality of the education provided. Key to faculty engagement with academic demands is congruence between professional values and academic demands. To promote leaders’ engagement with accreditation, accreditation practices need to align with leaders’ values. There is currently no information on leaders’ professional values and on accreditation practices they perceive as most engaging. This study fills this gap and illustrates congruence between leaders’ professional values and accreditation practices. Appreciative inquiry, a strength-based evaluation approach focusing on what is going well in an organisation, was used to elicit perceptions from leaders of seven medical education programs (1 undergraduate, UGME, and 6 postgraduate, PGME) at one academic centre about the components of accreditation and of their professional role they find as most engaging and valuable. Two independent coders analyzed the content of interviews and focus group discussions using open, emergent coding, to identify themes and their associations. Twenty-eight (48%) of 59 invited leaders participated, 8 from UGME program (29% of total participants, 47% of UGME invitees), 20 from all 6 targeted PGME programs (71% of all participants, 48% of PGME invitees). Leaders value their role for the inherent intellectual stimulation, their contribution to learners’ growth, their effecting of meaningful changes, and the collaboration with learners and colleagues. Accreditation practices congruent with these values include comprehensive program reviews, faculty collaboration, and provision of external feedback and validation. The value of accreditation resides mainly in the preparation of documents and the visit, rather than in specific accreditation standards. Accreditation practices not congruent with leaders’ values and leading to their disengagement were also identified. Accreditation practices congruent with leaders’ professional values should be emphasized in accreditation practices to promote engagement and foster programmatic CQI, whereas non-congruent practices should be revisited for their added value. These results corroborate findings from previous literature on academic faculty engagement. Our findings will hopefully guide the development of new accreditation organisations and inform reforms of existing accreditation systems to foster leaders' meaningful engagement with accreditation and programmatic CQI. Supplementary Information: The online version contains supplementary material available at https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-026-09938-6.
SN - 1472-6920
ER -