Competition Between Task Accuracy and Habitual Locomotor Behavior Underlies the Speed-Accuracy Trade-Off in Walking
- 1University of Southern California
Abstract
The speed-accuracy trade-off is a hallmark feature of motor behavior, yet its underlying causes in cyclic, whole-body movements such as walking remain to be understood. In discrete, point-to-point movements, reduced accuracy at higher speeds is typically attributed to signal-dependent motor noise and an inability to use online error correction. Walking, however, may be governed by additional objectives, such as minimizing metabolic energy expenditure. To distinguish between these mechanisms, we tested young adults in a precision-walking task requiring them to match target step lengths across a range of treadmill speeds. Accuracy declined systematically as walking speed increased, demonstrating a locomotor speed-accuracy trade-off. Contrary to prevailing theory, removing online visual feedback of foot position did not affect this decline, indicating little contribution from visually guided error correction. Moreover, step-length variability, a task-specific measure of signal-dependent motor noise, decreased rather than increased with speed. Instead, faster walking produced progressively larger biases toward participants' habitual step lengths measured in the absence of targets. Because habitual step lengths are known to closely approximate energetically optimal values, these findings suggest energetic optimization, rather than motor noise or limitations associated with the use of online feedback, as the primary driver of the speed-accuracy trade-off during walking.
Related
- Divergence of cortical force-generating mechanisms underlies differences in spindle behavior between C. elegans and C. inopinata
- Cooperative IDR-folded domain interplay governs HP1α phase separation and underlies biphasic regulation by pathogenic poly-PR
- Differential chromatin enrichment of histone H3K27me3 underlies variable cell responses to estrogen and endocrine treatment
- Disrupted RGS coupling underlies a clinically distinct subset of GNAO1-related disorder
- Fluctuating hydrodynamic forces increase fish locomotor variability in turbulence
BibTeX
@misc{lachica2026competition,
title = {{Competition Between Task Accuracy and Habitual Locomotor Behavior Underlies the Speed-Accuracy Trade-Off in Walking}},
author = {I. J. Lachica and N. Schweighofer and J. M. Finley},
howpublished = {bioRxiv},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.64898/2026.10.21.760535},
url = {https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.64898/2026.10.21.760535v1},
note = {CC BY-NC-ND},
}
RIS
TY - UNPB
TI - Competition Between Task Accuracy and Habitual Locomotor Behavior Underlies the Speed-Accuracy Trade-Off in Walking
AU - I. J. Lachica
AU - N. Schweighofer
AU - J. M. Finley
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/21
PB - bioRxiv
DO - 10.64898/2026.10.21.760535
UR - https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.64898/2026.10.21.760535v1
AB - The speed-accuracy trade-off is a hallmark feature of motor behavior, yet its underlying causes in cyclic, whole-body movements such as walking remain to be understood. In discrete, point-to-point movements, reduced accuracy at higher speeds is typically attributed to signal-dependent motor noise and an inability to use online error correction. Walking, however, may be governed by additional objectives, such as minimizing metabolic energy expenditure. To distinguish between these mechanisms, we tested young adults in a precision-walking task requiring them to match target step lengths across a range of treadmill speeds. Accuracy declined systematically as walking speed increased, demonstrating a locomotor speed-accuracy trade-off. Contrary to prevailing theory, removing online visual feedback of foot position did not affect this decline, indicating little contribution from visually guided error correction. Moreover, step-length variability, a task-specific measure of signal-dependent motor noise, decreased rather than increased with speed. Instead, faster walking produced progressively larger biases toward participants' habitual step lengths measured in the absence of targets. Because habitual step lengths are known to closely approximate energetically optimal values, these findings suggest energetic optimization, rather than motor noise or limitations associated with the use of online feedback, as the primary driver of the speed-accuracy trade-off during walking.
ER -