Criminalizing genomic discrimination: protecting human dignity under UAE and French law.
- 1College of Law, United Arab Emirates University, Al Ain, United Arab Emirates.
- 2Department of Genetics and Genomics, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, United Arab Emirates University, Al Ain, United Arab Emirates.
Abstract
Introduction
The rapid advancement of genomics and biotechnology has introduced complex legal and ethical challenges, foremost among them genomic discrimination: the use of individuals' genetic traits, family medical history, or inferred genetic status to make adverse decisions in employment, insurance, access to services, or other legally significant contexts. Such practices undermine human dignity, equality, privacy, and trust in institutions.Methods
Using descriptive-analytical and comparative methods, we analyze the adequacy and effectiveness of criminal-law protections against genomic discrimination in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and France. We examine the scope of protected genetic information, the constitutive elements of the offense, applicable sanctions, attempted discrimination, aggravating circumstances, and emerging risks arising from familial and forensic uses of genetic data.Results
Both jurisdictions prohibit discrimination based on genetic characteristics, but important gaps remain regarding attempted offenses, aggravating circumstances, inferred genetic information, and the expanding use of familial and genealogical genetic data. In the UAE, the Human Genome Law expressly prohibits and criminalizes genomic discrimination, while French law prohibits discrimination based on genetic characteristics through its Civil and Penal Codes.Discussion
We recommend clearer criminal provisions addressing attempts, proportionate and cumulative sanctions where appropriate, explicit aggravating circumstances, and safeguards against discriminatory uses of inferred, familial, forensic, and genealogical genetic information. These reforms would strengthen protection of human dignity.
Related
- Human dignity and its associations with self efficacy and treatment adherence in adults with type 2 diabetes in Iran
- PINK1 agonist MTK458 attenuates cerebral edema by protecting blood-brain barrier integrity in intracerebral hemorrhage mice
- Protecting reproductive rights in an era of declining fertility: charting a path for the SRHR community
- Protecting workers from Algorithmic Management: a theoretical framework for four key protection factors
- Advancing Blue‐Light Photoactivatable TAM Kinase Inhibitors for Cancer Treatment: Challenges in Using π ‐Extended Coumarins as Photocleavable Protecting Groups
BibTeX
@article{gourari2026criminalizing,
title = {{Criminalizing genomic discrimination: protecting human dignity under UAE and French law.}},
author = {Fatiha Gourari and Mohammad Amin Alkrisheh and Abouelwafa Ibrahim and Nadia Akawi and Enas Mohammed AlQodsi},
journal = {Frontiers in medicine},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.3389/fmed.2026.1944734},
url = {https://europepmc.org/article/MED/42909072},
note = {CC BY},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Criminalizing genomic discrimination: protecting human dignity under UAE and French law.
AU - Fatiha Gourari
AU - Mohammad Amin Alkrisheh
AU - Abouelwafa Ibrahim
AU - Nadia Akawi
AU - Enas Mohammed AlQodsi
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/07
JO - Frontiers in medicine
DO - 10.3389/fmed.2026.1944734
UR - https://europepmc.org/article/MED/42909072
AB - Introduction The rapid advancement of genomics and biotechnology has introduced complex legal and ethical challenges, foremost among them genomic discrimination: the use of individuals' genetic traits, family medical history, or inferred genetic status to make adverse decisions in employment, insurance, access to services, or other legally significant contexts. Such practices undermine human dignity, equality, privacy, and trust in institutions.Methods Using descriptive-analytical and comparative methods, we analyze the adequacy and effectiveness of criminal-law protections against genomic discrimination in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and France. We examine the scope of protected genetic information, the constitutive elements of the offense, applicable sanctions, attempted discrimination, aggravating circumstances, and emerging risks arising from familial and forensic uses of genetic data.Results Both jurisdictions prohibit discrimination based on genetic characteristics, but important gaps remain regarding attempted offenses, aggravating circumstances, inferred genetic information, and the expanding use of familial and genealogical genetic data. In the UAE, the Human Genome Law expressly prohibits and criminalizes genomic discrimination, while French law prohibits discrimination based on genetic characteristics through its Civil and Penal Codes.Discussion We recommend clearer criminal provisions addressing attempts, proportionate and cumulative sanctions where appropriate, explicit aggravating circumstances, and safeguards against discriminatory uses of inferred, familial, forensic, and genealogical genetic information. These reforms would strengthen protection of human dignity.
SN - 2296-858X
ER -