Vegetative Barrier Acts as a ‘Trapper’ Rather than a ‘Filter’ for Potentially Toxic Element Contaminated Wind-Erodible Particles at the Vicinity of an Industrial Brownfield: Evaluation of a Nature-Based Solution
Abstract
Brownfields can represent sources of multiple contaminants and may present health risks through airborne particle dispersion and incidental soil ingestion for surrounding populations. Remediation with nature-based solutions to mitigate legacy industrial pollution is therefore a relevant step to consider and requires further evaluation. Vegetative barriers offer potential mitigation strategies, yet their effectiveness in diffuse, multi-source pollution contexts remains underexplored. This study evaluated a spontaneous perennial vegetative barrier contiguous to a former lead smelter in Marseille, France, situated within a historically industrial multisource contamination context. As public access to the site is formally prohibited, this study constitutes a methodological proof-of-concept: characterizing barrier functioning under regulated conditions without active exposure risk designed to provide a transferable framework applicable to sites where human exposure is real and risk management decisions are required. PTE concentrations were assessed in soil (pseudo-total, exchangeable, EDTA-extractable and wind-erodible soil fraction considered as surface soil) and leaf (total) samples collected from both barrier sides along with human oral bioaccessibility assessments of the wind-erodible fraction. Results revealed substantial contamination in soil fractions and leaves, with the wind-erodible fraction (< 250 μm) exhibiting significantly higher concentrations of As, Cu, Pb, Sb, and Zn (p ≤ 0.005). Exchangeable fractions remained low (< 1%), while those mobilizable were substantial, particularly for Pb (58%). Oral bioaccessibility assessments showed gastric phase extraction reaching ca. 1126 mg.kg−1 for Pb highlighting that bioaccessible Pb concentrations would represent a concern at any comparable accessible site. PTE accumulations were found in leaf tissues and leaf surface deposits on both barrier sides, suggesting trapping occurs despite the absence of unidirectional filtering gradients assumed in barrier studies. These findings demonstrated that spontaneous vegetative barriers contribute to PTE stabilization and capture even in a complex, diffuse pollution context, acting as trappers rather than filters. Their preservation and/or implementation should be prioritized in brownfield management strategies to reduce erosion-mediated PTE dispersion, particularly at sites where surrounding populations may be exposed.
Related
- Comparative evaluation of sample preparation and enrichment methods for culture and molecular detection of Burkholderia pseudomallei in naturally contaminated soils from Thailand over one year.
- Foliar application of microbial consortium formulations suppresses Phomopsis leaf blight, promotes vegetative growth, and modulates biochemical defence in strawberry (Fragaria × ananassa Duch. cv. Camarosa) under protected cultivation
- Go and grow: coordinated evolution of vegetative and reproductive traits facilitated niche diversification in Thymelaeaceae
- Temporal phenotypic responses of early vegetative maize to heat, drought, and combined stresses
- Global mapping of protein localization in vegetative Dictyostelium discoideum by subcellular spatial proteomics
BibTeX
@article{calmon2026vegetative,
title = {{Vegetative Barrier Acts as a ‘Trapper’ Rather than a ‘Filter’ for Potentially Toxic Element Contaminated Wind-Erodible Particles at the Vicinity of an Industrial Brownfield: Evaluation of a Nature-Based Solution}},
author = {Lucie Calmon and Pascale Prudent and Sophie Fabre and Clémentine Le Champion and Carine Demelas and Marie-Odile Khiat and Isabelle Laffont-Schwob},
journal = {Water, Air, and Soil Pollution},
year = {2026},
month = aug,
doi = {10.1007/s11270-026-09826-1},
url = {https://hal.science/hal-05749867v1},
note = {CC BY-NC-ND 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Vegetative Barrier Acts as a ‘Trapper’ Rather than a ‘Filter’ for Potentially Toxic Element Contaminated Wind-Erodible Particles at the Vicinity of an Industrial Brownfield: Evaluation of a Nature-Based Solution
AU - Lucie Calmon
AU - Pascale Prudent
AU - Sophie Fabre
AU - Clémentine Le Champion
AU - Carine Demelas
AU - Marie-Odile Khiat
AU - Isabelle Laffont-Schwob
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/08/10
JO - Water, Air, and Soil Pollution
DO - 10.1007/s11270-026-09826-1
UR - https://hal.science/hal-05749867v1
AB - Brownfields can represent sources of multiple contaminants and may present health risks through airborne particle dispersion and incidental soil ingestion for surrounding populations. Remediation with nature-based solutions to mitigate legacy industrial pollution is therefore a relevant step to consider and requires further evaluation. Vegetative barriers offer potential mitigation strategies, yet their effectiveness in diffuse, multi-source pollution contexts remains underexplored. This study evaluated a spontaneous perennial vegetative barrier contiguous to a former lead smelter in Marseille, France, situated within a historically industrial multisource contamination context. As public access to the site is formally prohibited, this study constitutes a methodological proof-of-concept: characterizing barrier functioning under regulated conditions without active exposure risk designed to provide a transferable framework applicable to sites where human exposure is real and risk management decisions are required. PTE concentrations were assessed in soil (pseudo-total, exchangeable, EDTA-extractable and wind-erodible soil fraction considered as surface soil) and leaf (total) samples collected from both barrier sides along with human oral bioaccessibility assessments of the wind-erodible fraction. Results revealed substantial contamination in soil fractions and leaves, with the wind-erodible fraction (< 250 μm) exhibiting significantly higher concentrations of As, Cu, Pb, Sb, and Zn (p ≤ 0.005). Exchangeable fractions remained low (< 1%), while those mobilizable were substantial, particularly for Pb (58%). Oral bioaccessibility assessments showed gastric phase extraction reaching ca. 1126 mg.kg−1 for Pb highlighting that bioaccessible Pb concentrations would represent a concern at any comparable accessible site. PTE accumulations were found in leaf tissues and leaf surface deposits on both barrier sides, suggesting trapping occurs despite the absence of unidirectional filtering gradients assumed in barrier studies. These findings demonstrated that spontaneous vegetative barriers contribute to PTE stabilization and capture even in a complex, diffuse pollution context, acting as trappers rather than filters. Their preservation and/or implementation should be prioritized in brownfield management strategies to reduce erosion-mediated PTE dispersion, particularly at sites where surrounding populations may be exposed.
SN - 0049-6979
SN - 1573-2932
ER -