Learning from the community: early medical students' territory-based immersion with community health agents in Brazil.
- 1School of Medicine, Sulamérica Faculty, Luís Eduardo Magalhães, Bahia, Brazil.
- 2School of Medicine, Sulamérica Faculty, Luís Eduardo Magalhães, Bahia, Brazil. [email protected].
- 3School of Medicine, Federal University of Western Bahia (UFOB), Barreiras, Bahia, Brazil. [email protected].
Abstract
Background
Early immersion of medical students in Primary Health Care (PHC) settings is vital for fostering socially accountable medical education. In Brazil, PHC is territorially organised, and Community Health Agents (CHAs) play a central role in mediating healthcare delivery. However, pedagogical descriptions of supervised, CHA-led student immersion experiences remain limited. This study addresses this gap by presenting an interpretive qualitative analysis of a structured, territory-based immersion designed for first-year medical students.Methods
Between March and October 2025, seventy-six first-year medical students participated in a structured territory-based immersion across eighteen PHC units in Luís Eduardo Magalhães, Bahia, Northeast Brazil. Integrated into a Problem-Based Learning (PBL) curriculum [Supplementary File 3], CHAs acted as co-educators. Students documented their learning in reflective journals, structured response forms, and formal assessment responses (∼45,000 words); all 76 enrolled students contributed to the corpus without exclusions [Supplementary File 4]. Data were analysed using Reflexive Thematic Analysis (RTA) as both the methodological framework and analytical method, following Braun and Clarke's six-phase framework [1, 2] and the RTARG reporting standards [3], underpinned by an interpretivist epistemology and informed by situated learning [4], Mezirow's transformative learning theory [5], Fink's taxonomy of significant learning [6], and Freirean critical pedagogy [7] as sensitising concepts. Analytical quality was assured through independent coding by two researchers, structured dialogical engagement, reflexive memoing, and triangulation across three complementary data sources, the first of which encompassed student-generated materials produced under three distinct conditions of accountability.Results
Three interconnected themes emerged: (1) Territory as a living determinant actively shaping health beyond abstract notions; (2) CHAs and the interdisciplinary PHC team as relational facilitators and legitimate knowledge holders, enacting a distributed knowledge model that integrates specialised expertise with local knowledge, challenging traditional educational hierarchies, and promoting horizontal collaboration; and (3) Emergence of empathy and social awareness, catalysed by reflective engagement and pedagogical tensions, including students' initial anxiety, emotional confrontation with structural inequality, and progressive development of critical empathy through CHA mediation and structured debriefing.Conclusions
Early, structured immersion experiences mediated by CHA co-educators deepen medical students' contextual understanding of PHC and foster essential humanistic competencies. These outcomes were inseparable from the emotional tensions, structural challenges, and critical dimensions of the experience-including initial anxiety, boundary discomfort, and the gap between structural awareness and agency-which are analytically significant dimensions of the learning process rather than peripheral to it. Grounded in situated learning, transformative learning theory, and critical pedagogy, this low-cost, scalable model offers a transferable approach to socially accountable medical education, especially for resource-limited settings. Future research should examine longitudinal impacts and the perspectives of CHAs as co-educational partners.
Related
- A global community of practice to improve public–private engagement in TB: the TBPPM Learning Network
- Health behavior profiles and potential support needs among community residents with clustered cardiovascular risk factors: a latent profile and explainable machine learning analysis for community-based prevention
- A Spatiotemporal Causal Machine Learning Framework for Quantifying the Impact of PM2.5 on Asthma at the Community Level
- Primary Care Quality and Inappropriate Community Antibiotic Use: A Double Machine Learning Instrumental Variable Approach
- Identifying Mild Cognitive Impairment from Routinely Collected Physical, Functional and Psychosocial Measures in Community-Dwelling Older Adults: A Comparative Machine-Learning and Regression Modelling Study in the Northern Japanese ORANGE Registry.
BibTeX
@article{paschoalini2026learning,
title = {{Learning from the community: early medical students' territory-based immersion with community health agents in Brazil.}},
author = {Zibeilde Ferreira Borges Paschoalini and Marcello da Silveira Paschoalini},
journal = {BMC medical education},
year = {2026},
month = jul,
doi = {10.1186/s12909-026-09858-5},
url = {https://europepmc.org/article/MED/42894158},
note = {CC BY-NC-ND},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Learning from the community: early medical students' territory-based immersion with community health agents in Brazil.
AU - Zibeilde Ferreira Borges Paschoalini
AU - Marcello da Silveira Paschoalini
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/07/01
JO - BMC medical education
DO - 10.1186/s12909-026-09858-5
UR - https://europepmc.org/article/MED/42894158
AB - Background Early immersion of medical students in Primary Health Care (PHC) settings is vital for fostering socially accountable medical education. In Brazil, PHC is territorially organised, and Community Health Agents (CHAs) play a central role in mediating healthcare delivery. However, pedagogical descriptions of supervised, CHA-led student immersion experiences remain limited. This study addresses this gap by presenting an interpretive qualitative analysis of a structured, territory-based immersion designed for first-year medical students.Methods Between March and October 2025, seventy-six first-year medical students participated in a structured territory-based immersion across eighteen PHC units in Luís Eduardo Magalhães, Bahia, Northeast Brazil. Integrated into a Problem-Based Learning (PBL) curriculum [Supplementary File 3], CHAs acted as co-educators. Students documented their learning in reflective journals, structured response forms, and formal assessment responses (∼45,000 words); all 76 enrolled students contributed to the corpus without exclusions [Supplementary File 4]. Data were analysed using Reflexive Thematic Analysis (RTA) as both the methodological framework and analytical method, following Braun and Clarke's six-phase framework [1, 2] and the RTARG reporting standards [3], underpinned by an interpretivist epistemology and informed by situated learning [4], Mezirow's transformative learning theory [5], Fink's taxonomy of significant learning [6], and Freirean critical pedagogy [7] as sensitising concepts. Analytical quality was assured through independent coding by two researchers, structured dialogical engagement, reflexive memoing, and triangulation across three complementary data sources, the first of which encompassed student-generated materials produced under three distinct conditions of accountability.Results Three interconnected themes emerged: (1) Territory as a living determinant actively shaping health beyond abstract notions; (2) CHAs and the interdisciplinary PHC team as relational facilitators and legitimate knowledge holders, enacting a distributed knowledge model that integrates specialised expertise with local knowledge, challenging traditional educational hierarchies, and promoting horizontal collaboration; and (3) Emergence of empathy and social awareness, catalysed by reflective engagement and pedagogical tensions, including students' initial anxiety, emotional confrontation with structural inequality, and progressive development of critical empathy through CHA mediation and structured debriefing.Conclusions Early, structured immersion experiences mediated by CHA co-educators deepen medical students' contextual understanding of PHC and foster essential humanistic competencies. These outcomes were inseparable from the emotional tensions, structural challenges, and critical dimensions of the experience-including initial anxiety, boundary discomfort, and the gap between structural awareness and agency-which are analytically significant dimensions of the learning process rather than peripheral to it. Grounded in situated learning, transformative learning theory, and critical pedagogy, this low-cost, scalable model offers a transferable approach to socially accountable medical education, especially for resource-limited settings. Future research should examine longitudinal impacts and the perspectives of CHAs as co-educational partners.
SN - 1472-6920
ER -