Skip to content
DraconiticResearch
Search Sources API
226,742 studies31 sourcesUpdated 36 min ago
Peer-reviewedCC BY 4.0Cureus

Calcium Silicate-Based Versus Conventional Sealers in Nonsurgical Endodontic Retreatment: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

3 more authors
15 affiliations
  1. 1General Dentistry, Al-Farwaniya Specialty Dental Center, Farwaniya, KWT
  2. 2Endodontics, Airbase Hospital, Dhahran, SAU
  3. 3General Dentistry, Dr. Sukainah Al Sulaiman Dental Clinic, Qatif, SAU
  4. 4Endodontics, Istanbul University, Istanbul, TUR
  5. 5Endodontics, King Faisal University, Al-Ahsa, SAU
  6. 6General Dentistry, Umm al-Qura University, Jeddah, SAU
  7. 7General Dentistry, Batterjee Medical College, Jeddah, SAU
  8. 8General Dentistry, Riyadh Elm University, Riyadh, SAU
  9. 9General Dentistry, Jazan Health Cluster, Jazan, SAU
  10. 10General Dentistry, King Khalid University, Abha, SAU
  11. 11Endodontics, Al Baha University, Al-Baha, SAU
  12. 12General Dentistry, University of Ha'il, Tabuk, SAU
  13. 13General Dentistry, Kuwait Ministry of Health, Al Jahra, KWT
  14. 14Endodontics, King Saud bin Abdulaziz University for Health Sciences, Riyadh, SAU
  15. 15Precision Medicine, Faculty of Pharmacy, Alexandria University, Alexandria, EGY

Abstract

This systematic review and meta-analysis aimed to determine whether obturation with a calcium silicate-based sealer alters periapical healing, postoperative pain, analgesic consumption, apical sealer extrusion, or tooth survival compared with a conventional sealer in permanent teeth undergoing orthograde nonsurgical retreatment; to establish whether any effect on healing is stable across loose and strict success criteria; and to determine whether the published evidence permits a causal statement about sealer chemistry independent of obturation technique.

Seven databases, two trial registries, and two grey literature sources were searched from inception to August 2026, with citation chasing and hand-searching. Randomized and non-randomized comparative studies of orthograde nonsurgical retreatment comparing a calcium silicate-based sealer with any non-calcium-silicate sealer were eligible. Loose (healed plus healing) and strict (complete resolution) radiographic success at ≥ 12 months were co-primary. The designs were synthesized separately. In two studies, pooling was conditional on a prespecified heterogeneity screen (I² < 50% and pQ ≥ 0.10); outcomes failing the screen were reported under Synthesis Without Meta-analysis (SWiM). Risk of bias was assessed with Revised Cochrane Risk-of-Bias tool for randomized trials (RoB 2) and Risk of Bias in Non-randomized Studies - of Interventions (ROBINS-I), and certainty with Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE). Nine studies were included; five contributed data (276 teeth). Under loose criteria, the two randomized trials disagreed (risk ratio (RR) 1.14, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.90-1.43 and 0.93, 0.82-1.07; I² = 51.4%) and were not pooled. Under strict criteria, both favored the conventional sealer and were consistent (I² = 0%), giving a pooled RR of 0.56 (0.27-1.15; 67 teeth), equivalent to 189 fewer complete resolutions per 1,000 teeth (310 fewer to 62 more). The exploratory ratio of RRs between criteria was 1.87 (0.89-3.90), an interval that includes 1. Postoperative pain did not differ at 24 hours (0.93, 0.53-1.64) or 48 hours (0.85, 0.43-1.67; 165 teeth). No sealer extrusion occurred in either arm of the only trial reporting it. No retreatment-specific survival data exist. The prespecified subgroup analysis of obturation technique could not be performed: no study contributing healing data matched the technique between arms. Available evidence represented 35% of the optimal information size for strict healing, 4% for loose healing and 0.8% for pain at 24 hours. Certainty was very low for all healing outcomes and low for pain.

In nonsurgical retreatment, the direction of the estimated effect of sealer chemistry differed between definitions of success: no difference under loose criteria, and a point estimate favoring conventional sealers under strict criteria that the data are too imprecise to confirm or exclude. Because the ratio of RRs includes 1, this difference is exploratory and does not establish that the effect depends on the criterion. Because sealer chemistry is confounded with obturation technique in every study reporting healing, the contrast measured is between obturation strategies rather than between sealers. The field is far from an answer, and a trial of approximately 192 teeth using strict criteria would be decisive.

Related

  1. Cone-Beam Computed Tomography (CBCT)-Guided Surgical Guide for Implant Placement Following Failed Endodontic Retreatment and Alveolar Ridge Preservation: A Case Report
    Keily J Portillo Avila, Zela Murray, Daymariher Orta Pedroza +2
    CureusPeer-reviewedCC BYFull textGeneral medicineEurope PMC
  2. Bioactivity and Regenerative Potential of Calcium Silicate-Based Endodontic Sealers on Human Periodontal Ligament Stem Cells: A Systematic Review of In Vitro Cellular Mechanisms.
    Fahad I Yaseen, Abdulaziz M Alribi, Yasser K AlGhadyan +8
    CureusPeer-reviewedCC BYFull textGeneral medicineEurope PMC
  3. Evaluation of the Impact of Osteoporosis and Rheumatoid Arthritis on the Outcomes of Nonsurgical Endodontic Therapy: A Prospective Cohort Study
    Ajay Chhabra, Sona J Parvathy, Himani Mehra +5
    CureusPeer-reviewedCC BY 4.0Full textGeneral medicinePMCEurope PMC
  4. Strategic Orthograde Biodentine Obturation and Regenerative Surgical Management of a Persistent Radicular Cyst Refractory to Nonsurgical Endodontic Therapy: A One-Year Follow-Up Case Report.
    Suraj Khose, Rushikesh Mahaparale, Prasad Shirke +4
    CureusPeer-reviewedCC BYFull textGeneral medicineEurope PMCPMC
  5. Combined Endodontic Retreatment and Intentional Replantation for External Cervical Resorption: A Four-Year Follow-Up Case Report.
    Ayman M Abulhamael
    Reports (MDPI)Peer-reviewedCC BYFull textGeneral medicineEurope PMC
BibTeX
@article{alshammari2026calcium,
  title = {{Calcium Silicate-Based Versus Conventional Sealers in Nonsurgical Endodontic Retreatment: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis}},
  author = {Omar Alshammari and Bayan A Rashed and Fatimah M Alghomgham and Shaheen W Al Hajaj and Turki W Almuhayfith and Aya A Hejazi and Souhip Al-Harbi and Khalid A Alghamdi and Mashael Mujalli and Mohammed A Alshehri and Khalid M Alzahrani and Maha A Alatawi and Latifah A Al-Ali and Abdulaziz Alribi and Ali S Metwaly},
  journal = {Cureus},
  year = {2026},
  month = oct,
  doi = {10.7759/cureus.117870},
  url = {https://doi.org/10.7759/cureus.117870},
  note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY  - JOUR
TI  - Calcium Silicate-Based Versus Conventional Sealers in Nonsurgical Endodontic Retreatment: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
AU  - Omar Alshammari
AU  - Bayan A Rashed
AU  - Fatimah M Alghomgham
AU  - Shaheen W Al Hajaj
AU  - Turki W Almuhayfith
AU  - Aya A Hejazi
AU  - Souhip Al-Harbi
AU  - Khalid A Alghamdi
AU  - Mashael Mujalli
AU  - Mohammed A Alshehri
AU  - Khalid M Alzahrani
AU  - Maha A Alatawi
AU  - Latifah A Al-Ali
AU  - Abdulaziz Alribi
AU  - Ali S Metwaly
PY  - 2026
DA  - 2026/10/13
JO  - Cureus
DO  - 10.7759/cureus.117870
UR  - https://doi.org/10.7759/cureus.117870
AB  - This systematic review and meta-analysis aimed to determine whether obturation with a calcium silicate-based sealer alters periapical healing, postoperative pain, analgesic consumption, apical sealer extrusion, or tooth survival compared with a conventional sealer in permanent teeth undergoing orthograde nonsurgical retreatment; to establish whether any effect on healing is stable across loose and strict success criteria; and to determine whether the published evidence permits a causal statement about sealer chemistry independent of obturation technique.  Seven databases, two trial registries, and two grey literature sources were searched from inception to August 2026, with citation chasing and hand-searching. Randomized and non-randomized comparative studies of orthograde nonsurgical retreatment comparing a calcium silicate-based sealer with any non-calcium-silicate sealer were eligible. Loose (healed plus healing) and strict (complete resolution) radiographic success at ≥ 12 months were co-primary. The designs were synthesized separately. In two studies, pooling was conditional on a prespecified heterogeneity screen (I² < 50% and pQ ≥ 0.10); outcomes failing the screen were reported under Synthesis Without Meta-analysis (SWiM). Risk of bias was assessed with Revised Cochrane Risk-of-Bias tool for randomized trials (RoB 2) and Risk of Bias in Non-randomized Studies - of Interventions (ROBINS-I), and certainty with Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE). Nine studies were included; five contributed data (276 teeth). Under loose criteria, the two randomized trials disagreed (risk ratio (RR) 1.14, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.90-1.43 and 0.93, 0.82-1.07; I² = 51.4%) and were not pooled. Under strict criteria, both favored the conventional sealer and were consistent (I² = 0%), giving a pooled RR of 0.56 (0.27-1.15; 67 teeth), equivalent to 189 fewer complete resolutions per 1,000 teeth (310 fewer to 62 more). The exploratory ratio of RRs between criteria was 1.87 (0.89-3.90), an interval that includes 1. Postoperative pain did not differ at 24 hours (0.93, 0.53-1.64) or 48 hours (0.85, 0.43-1.67; 165 teeth). No sealer extrusion occurred in either arm of the only trial reporting it. No retreatment-specific survival data exist. The prespecified subgroup analysis of obturation technique could not be performed: no study contributing healing data matched the technique between arms. Available evidence represented 35% of the optimal information size for strict healing, 4% for loose healing and 0.8% for pain at 24 hours. Certainty was very low for all healing outcomes and low for pain.  In nonsurgical retreatment, the direction of the estimated effect of sealer chemistry differed between definitions of success: no difference under loose criteria, and a point estimate favoring conventional sealers under strict criteria that the data are too imprecise to confirm or exclude. Because the ratio of RRs includes 1, this difference is exploratory and does not establish that the effect depends on the criterion. Because sealer chemistry is confounded with obturation technique in every study reporting healing, the contrast measured is between obturation strategies rather than between sealers. The field is far from an answer, and a trial of approximately 192 teeth using strict criteria would be decisive.
SN  - 2168-8184
ER  -