The bare necessities of a physically reasonable mathematical model for quantum theory
Abstract
What are the minimal requirements for a physically reasonable mathematical model for quantum theory or a potential extension? In addressing this question, rather than relying on the generalized probabilistic theories or other usual approaches, we propose a reset based on the following fundamental features: transition probabilities, which are typical of quantum theory, and continuous reversible dynamical processes (e.g., represented by a Lie group), which play the same crucial role in classical as well as in quantum physics. In doing so, we get back to the very elementary transition probability space framework originally introduced by Bogdan Mielnik in 1968 and combine it with the continuous reversibility condition. The primary class of valid spaces arises from the irreducible atomic JBW algebras, which encompass the irreducible atomic von Neumann algebras and the Jordan matrix algebras. The von Neumann algebras represent the model of common quantum theory. Beyond these, there is a non-standard valid space, where the exceptional Lie group E6 acts transitively. While E6 has been proposed as a candidate for internal symmetries in particle physics, we highlight that this model deviates from standard quantum theory in critical ways. Specifically, it fails to guarantee the existence of post-measurement states in all situations. Though the above postulates are powerful, they still allow for some physically meaningless models. A further feature of quantum theory (the correspondence between the pure states and the minimal projections) leads us to an additional requirement that rules out these models. However, a complete classification of the valid models remains one of the open issues, pointed out in the paper, which is intended for the mathematical and physical experts, inspiring them to tackle these problems.
Related
- Hanslick's Musical Formalism as a Mathematical Structure - Examining meaning in Music through the Lens of Category Theory
- A Mathematical Justification of the Theory of Linearly Elastic Plates
- Some New Notions of Mathematical Integral Inequalities: Theory and Applications
- A Mathematical Theory of Near-Field Super-Resolution
- Towards a mathematical theory of superposition
BibTeX
@misc{niestegge2026bare,
title = {{The bare necessities of a physically reasonable mathematical model for quantum theory}},
author = {Gerd Niestegge},
howpublished = {arXiv},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
doi = {10.48550/arxiv.2607.24474},
eprint = {2607.24474},
archivePrefix = {arXiv},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.24474},
note = {CC BY-NC-ND 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - UNPB
TI - The bare necessities of a physically reasonable mathematical model for quantum theory
AU - Gerd Niestegge
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/09/28
PB - arXiv
DO - 10.48550/arxiv.2607.24474
UR - https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.24474
AB - What are the minimal requirements for a physically reasonable mathematical model for quantum theory or a potential extension? In addressing this question, rather than relying on the generalized probabilistic theories or other usual approaches, we propose a reset based on the following fundamental features: transition probabilities, which are typical of quantum theory, and continuous reversible dynamical processes (e.g., represented by a Lie group), which play the same crucial role in classical as well as in quantum physics. In doing so, we get back to the very elementary transition probability space framework originally introduced by Bogdan Mielnik in 1968 and combine it with the continuous reversibility condition. The primary class of valid spaces arises from the irreducible atomic JBW algebras, which encompass the irreducible atomic von Neumann algebras and the Jordan matrix algebras. The von Neumann algebras represent the model of common quantum theory. Beyond these, there is a non-standard valid space, where the exceptional Lie group E_6 acts transitively. While E_6 has been proposed as a candidate for internal symmetries in particle physics, we highlight that this model deviates from standard quantum theory in critical ways. Specifically, it fails to guarantee the existence of post-measurement states in all situations. Though the above postulates are powerful, they still allow for some physically meaningless models. A further feature of quantum theory (the correspondence between the pure states and the minimal projections) leads us to an additional requirement that rules out these models. However, a complete classification of the valid models remains one of the open issues, pointed out in the paper, which is intended for the mathematical and physical experts, inspiring them to tackle these problems.
ER -