A dimensionless-entropy weight method for determining cloud physical parameter responses induced by aircraft cloud seeding
Abstract
To address the challenges in evaluation of aircraft cloud seeding effect, this study proposes a physical evaluation method that integrates multiple key techniques to achieve an integrated quantitative evaluation based on multiple indicators. This evaluation approach was applied to six aircraft cloud seeding operations conducted in Henan Province of China during 2023–2024. Results show that the six operations exhibited nonlinear growth patterns for dispersion in both the target and control areas, with rapid expansion at the initial stage followed by a slower rate. The dispersion rate, distance, extent and concentration of the seeding agent vary significantly depending on the meteorological conditions, such as atmospheric turbulence, wind speed, stability and humidity. For the six operations, the vertically integrated liquid water content (VIL) showed notably high entropy weights (0.06–0.43) in multiple operations (No. 2, 3 and 6), making it a relatively stable indicator for evaluating the cloud seeding effects. Due to complex cloud microphysical processes such as latent heat release from deposition, downdrafts, cloud dissipation and cloud development, the responses of cloud-top temperature to seeding varied considerably (− 44.56 °C ~ − 6 °C). The effects of cloud seeding on cloud effective radius and optical thickness are complex and vary substantially depending on specific seeding conditions. The responses of liquid water path were time-dependent, the seeding-induced responses of radar reflectivity exhibited distinct patterns, including delayed manifestation, strong enhancement, and ineffectiveness or being masked. The strong-echo area and the VIL in the target areas fluctuated and generally decreased over time, respectively. The change rates of hourly precipitation induced by seeding varied from 3.82% to 8.91%. The integrated physical inspection dimensionless index (PIDI, a physical evaluation index for evaluating cloud seeding effects) values for the seven indicators ranged from 15.0% to 69.7%, showing a smaller variation magnitude compared with the change rates of individual indicators, which reflects the synergistic effects of multiple indicators. This study provides a quantifiable and robust algorithm that mitigates the interference of natural variability, and its application to six case studies demonstrates its potential for advancing cloud seeding techniques and improving effect evaluation capabilities.
Related
- Contrasting physical drivers of chlorophyll a responses to summer marine heatwaves in the South China Sea
- Unified Explanation of Long-Period Ground Motion Using the Basin Sloshing Index (BSI): A Dimensionless Analysis of Large-Scale Sloshing Phenomena in Sedimentary Basins
- A New Way for Determining Earthquake Magnitude Based on Electromagnetic Radiation
- Determining the exposure of forest production zones to climate change in France?
- Evidence mapping of the causes and effects of habitat change attributed to offshore wind development is important for determining impacts on fisheries species
BibTeX
@article{sha2026dimensionlessentropy,
title = {{A dimensionless-entropy weight method for determining cloud physical parameter responses induced by aircraft cloud seeding}},
author = {Xiuzhu Sha and Xingyu Li and Ronghao Chu and Bo Cheng and Yanhua Liu and Jianfang Ding and Fan Zhang and Can Song and Yao Xiao and Shanhai Wang},
journal = {Scientific Reports},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.1038/s41598-026-75925-y},
url = {https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-026-75925-y},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - A dimensionless-entropy weight method for determining cloud physical parameter responses induced by aircraft cloud seeding
AU - Xiuzhu Sha
AU - Xingyu Li
AU - Ronghao Chu
AU - Bo Cheng
AU - Yanhua Liu
AU - Jianfang Ding
AU - Fan Zhang
AU - Can Song
AU - Yao Xiao
AU - Shanhai Wang
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/14
JO - Scientific Reports
DO - 10.1038/s41598-026-75925-y
UR - https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-026-75925-y
AB - To address the challenges in evaluation of aircraft cloud seeding effect, this study proposes a physical evaluation method that integrates multiple key techniques to achieve an integrated quantitative evaluation based on multiple indicators. This evaluation approach was applied to six aircraft cloud seeding operations conducted in Henan Province of China during 2023–2024. Results show that the six operations exhibited nonlinear growth patterns for dispersion in both the target and control areas, with rapid expansion at the initial stage followed by a slower rate. The dispersion rate, distance, extent and concentration of the seeding agent vary significantly depending on the meteorological conditions, such as atmospheric turbulence, wind speed, stability and humidity. For the six operations, the vertically integrated liquid water content (VIL) showed notably high entropy weights (0.06–0.43) in multiple operations (No. 2, 3 and 6), making it a relatively stable indicator for evaluating the cloud seeding effects. Due to complex cloud microphysical processes such as latent heat release from deposition, downdrafts, cloud dissipation and cloud development, the responses of cloud-top temperature to seeding varied considerably (− 44.56 °C ~ − 6 °C). The effects of cloud seeding on cloud effective radius and optical thickness are complex and vary substantially depending on specific seeding conditions. The responses of liquid water path were time-dependent, the seeding-induced responses of radar reflectivity exhibited distinct patterns, including delayed manifestation, strong enhancement, and ineffectiveness or being masked. The strong-echo area and the VIL in the target areas fluctuated and generally decreased over time, respectively. The change rates of hourly precipitation induced by seeding varied from 3.82% to 8.91%. The integrated physical inspection dimensionless index (PIDI, a physical evaluation index for evaluating cloud seeding effects) values for the seven indicators ranged from 15.0% to 69.7%, showing a smaller variation magnitude compared with the change rates of individual indicators, which reflects the synergistic effects of multiple indicators. This study provides a quantifiable and robust algorithm that mitigates the interference of natural variability, and its application to six case studies demonstrates its potential for advancing cloud seeding techniques and improving effect evaluation capabilities.
SN - 2045-2322
ER -