Common, consequential, and actively maintained: a neo-balance view of genetic variation
Abstract
A fundamental and still unfinished task of evolutionary biology is to understand the nature of genetic variation and the evolutionary forces that shape it. The traditional approach to this problem is through retrospective inference from patterns in contemporary, static DNA sequence data. The prevailing view that emerged from these studies and from theoretical research is that segregating genetic polymorphism is either deleterious or effectively neutral and thus governed primarily by purifying natural selection and stochastic forces such as genetic drift or draft. In this Perspective, we review emerging evidence that challenges this paradigm. In particular, evolution-in-action studies that directly measure selection at individual loci throughout the evolutionary process have revealed hundreds of loci with common polymorphism exhibiting strong fitness effects and suggest that these polymorphisms must be maintained through some form of balancing selection. These data call for a new framework for understanding population genetic variation, which we term neo-balance. We discuss the theoretical and practical implications of this new paradigm and outline an empirical agenda to incorporate these observations into the study of biological variation and evolution.
Related
- PAZy: an expanded and actively maintained database of experimentally validated plastic-active enzymes
- Parental Genome Assemblies of Suyunuo1 Reveal Structural Variation Underlying Edible Waxy Maize Evolution, Superior Hybrid Performance and Yield - Flavor Balance
- Cultural and social drivers of human genetic variation
- Natural Genetic Variation in a Multigenerational Phenotype in C. elegans
- Genetic variation in EIF2AK3 alters astrocyte-dependent stress tolerance in neurons
BibTeX
@misc{bitter2026common,
title = {{Common, consequential, and actively maintained: a neo-balance view of genetic variation}},
author = {Mark Christopher Bitter and Paul Schmidt and Dmitri Petrov},
howpublished = {EcoEvoRxiv},
year = {2026},
month = sep,
doi = {10.32942/x2kd7p},
url = {https://ecoevorxiv.org/repository/view/15208/},
note = {CC BY 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - UNPB
TI - Common, consequential, and actively maintained: a neo-balance view of genetic variation
AU - Mark Christopher Bitter
AU - Paul Schmidt
AU - Dmitri Petrov
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/09/28
PB - EcoEvoRxiv
DO - 10.32942/x2kd7p
UR - https://ecoevorxiv.org/repository/view/15208/
AB - A fundamental and still unfinished task of evolutionary biology is to understand the nature of genetic variation and the evolutionary forces that shape it. The traditional approach to this problem is through retrospective inference from patterns in contemporary, static DNA sequence data. The prevailing view that emerged from these studies and from theoretical research is that segregating genetic polymorphism is either deleterious or effectively neutral and thus governed primarily by purifying natural selection and stochastic forces such as genetic drift or draft. In this Perspective, we review emerging evidence that challenges this paradigm. In particular, evolution-in-action studies that directly measure selection at individual loci throughout the evolutionary process have revealed hundreds of loci with common polymorphism exhibiting strong fitness effects and suggest that these polymorphisms must be maintained through some form of balancing selection. These data call for a new framework for understanding population genetic variation, which we term neo-balance. We discuss the theoretical and practical implications of this new paradigm and outline an empirical agenda to incorporate these observations into the study of biological variation and evolution.
ER -