Multiscale spatial drivers of WNV human risk in Europe: climate acts globally, equines locally
Abstract
Background: West Nile virus (WNV) risk in Europe is shaped by climate and equine co-circulation, but the spatial scale at which these determinants operate has not been empirically characterised. Standard models impose uniform effects, masking local heterogeneity relevant for One Health surveillance design.
Methods: Human WNV incidence was modelled across 239 NUTS3 regions in five European countries (2010–2022) using Multiscale Geographically Weighted Regression (MGWR), which estimates an optimal spatial bandwidth independently per predictor. Determinants included summer and spring temperature, minimum winter temperature, warm-season precipitation, equine WNV co-circulation, and GDP per capita. MGWR was compared against OLS (R²=0.43) and standard Geographically Weighted Regression (GWR, R²adj=0.69, AICc=296).
Results: MGWR substantially improved fit (R²adj=0.75, AICc=242, ΔAIC=54 vs GWR). Climate determinants operated at near-global spatial scales (summer temperature k = 237 neighbours; winter minimum k = 234), consistent with continental vector ecology. Equine co-circulation was a strictly local predictor (k = 53 neighbours), with significant associations in 38.5% of regions concentrated in southeastern Europe (Greece median β = 0.39, Italy β = 0.17, Germany β < 0). The equine signal was independent of climate (ΔAIC=19.9) and amplified by warm temperature anomalies, identifying regions where integrated One Health data most improves risk prediction.
Conclusions: WNV risk determinants operate at fundamentally different spatial scales: climate establishes continental transmission potential while equine co-circulation signals local viral activity. Strengthening equine surveillance in warm southeastern European regions maximises predictive return of One Health integration, particularly as climate change expands WNV suitability northward.
Key messages: • WNV determinants act at different scales: climate sets continental risk, while equine cases signal local viral activity. MGWR modeling reveals that integrated surveillance is a strictly local tool.
• The equine signal is strongest in warm, southeastern Europe. Prioritizing One Health data in these hotspots maximizes predictive returns as climate change shifts WNV transmission suitability northward.
Related
- Multimodal urban park service accessibility and spatial distributional inequality through a multiscale assessment
- Exploring the nexus of climate-socioeconomic drivers of dengue transmission: a covariate-augmented SEIR-SEI mechanistic model
- Exploring the spatial nexus between air quality, climate change, and socioeconomic determinants of maternal mortality across the Asia–Pacific region
- Environmental Drivers and Spatial Patterns of Lassa Fever Cases in Nigeria: A GIS-Based Approach to Dynamic Susceptibility Mapping
- Multiscale Spatial Characterization of Glioma MRI with MUSE and Radiomics
BibTeX
@article{santos2026multiscale,
title = {{Multiscale spatial drivers of WNV human risk in Europe: climate acts globally, equines locally}},
author = {SJ Amaya Santos and CA Vargas Campos and C Bermudez Tamayo},
journal = {The European Journal of Public Health},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
doi = {10.1093/eurpub/ckag169.1167},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1093/eurpub/ckag169.1167},
note = {CC BY-NC 4.0},
}
RIS
TY - JOUR
TI - Multiscale spatial drivers of WNV human risk in Europe: climate acts globally, equines locally
AU - SJ Amaya Santos
AU - CA Vargas Campos
AU - C Bermudez Tamayo
PY - 2026
DA - 2026/10/01
JO - The European Journal of Public Health
DO - 10.1093/eurpub/ckag169.1167
UR - https://doi.org/10.1093/eurpub/ckag169.1167
AB - Background: West Nile virus (WNV) risk in Europe is shaped by climate and equine co-circulation, but the spatial scale at which these determinants operate has not been empirically characterised. Standard models impose uniform effects, masking local heterogeneity relevant for One Health surveillance design. Methods: Human WNV incidence was modelled across 239 NUTS3 regions in five European countries (2010–2022) using Multiscale Geographically Weighted Regression (MGWR), which estimates an optimal spatial bandwidth independently per predictor. Determinants included summer and spring temperature, minimum winter temperature, warm-season precipitation, equine WNV co-circulation, and GDP per capita. MGWR was compared against OLS (R²=0.43) and standard Geographically Weighted Regression (GWR, R²adj=0.69, AICc=296). Results: MGWR substantially improved fit (R²adj=0.75, AICc=242, ΔAIC=54 vs GWR). Climate determinants operated at near-global spatial scales (summer temperature k = 237 neighbours; winter minimum k = 234), consistent with continental vector ecology. Equine co-circulation was a strictly local predictor (k = 53 neighbours), with significant associations in 38.5% of regions concentrated in southeastern Europe (Greece median β = 0.39, Italy β = 0.17, Germany β < 0). The equine signal was independent of climate (ΔAIC=19.9) and amplified by warm temperature anomalies, identifying regions where integrated One Health data most improves risk prediction. Conclusions: WNV risk determinants operate at fundamentally different spatial scales: climate establishes continental transmission potential while equine co-circulation signals local viral activity. Strengthening equine surveillance in warm southeastern European regions maximises predictive return of One Health integration, particularly as climate change expands WNV suitability northward. Key messages: • WNV determinants act at different scales: climate sets continental risk, while equine cases signal local viral activity. MGWR modeling reveals that integrated surveillance is a strictly local tool. • The equine signal is strongest in warm, southeastern Europe. Prioritizing One Health data in these hotspots maximizes predictive returns as climate change shifts WNV transmission suitability northward.
SN - 1101-1262
SN - 1464-360X
ER -