A reassessment of the Pantheon+ and DES 5YR calibration uncertainties: Dovekie

@article{popovic2026reassessment,
  title = {{A reassessment of the Pantheon+ and DES 5YR calibration uncertainties: Dovekie}},
  author = {B Popovic and W. D. Kenworthy and M Ginolin and A. Goobar and P Shah and Benjamin M. Boyd and Aaron Do and Dillon Brout and D. Scolnic and M. Vincenzi and Suhail Dhawan and D. O. Jones and M. Smith and M. Rigault and B. Racine and Erin E. Hayes and Rebecca C. Chen and P. Wiseman and Lluís Galbany and Matthew Grayling and Leander Lacroix and C Barjou-Delayre and D. Kuhn and Cameron Lemon},
  journal = {Astronomy and Astrophysics},
  year = {2026},
  month = jun,
  doi = {10.1051/0004-6361/202555963},
  url = {https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202555963},
  note = {CC BY},
}

TY  - JOUR
TI  - A reassessment of the Pantheon+ and DES 5YR calibration uncertainties: Dovekie
AU  - B Popovic
AU  - W. D. Kenworthy
AU  - M Ginolin
AU  - A. Goobar
AU  - P Shah
AU  - Benjamin M. Boyd
AU  - Aaron Do
AU  - Dillon Brout
AU  - D. Scolnic
AU  - M. Vincenzi
AU  - Suhail Dhawan
AU  - D. O. Jones
AU  - M. Smith
AU  - M. Rigault
AU  - B. Racine
AU  - Erin E. Hayes
AU  - Rebecca C. Chen
AU  - P. Wiseman
AU  - Lluís Galbany
AU  - Matthew Grayling
AU  - Leander Lacroix
AU  - C Barjou-Delayre
AU  - D. Kuhn
AU  - Cameron Lemon
PY  - 2026
DA  - 2026/06/19
JO  - Astronomy and Astrophysics
DO  - 10.1051/0004-6361/202555963
UR  - https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202555963
AB  - Aims. Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) are crucial tools for measuring the accelerating expansion of the Universe, comprising thousands of SNe across multiple telescopes. Accurate measurements of cosmological parameters with SNe Ia require a robust understanding and cross-calibration of the telescopes and filters. A previous cross-calibration effort, ‘Fragilistic’, provided 25 photometric systems, but offered no public code or ability to add new surveys. We provide a publicly available open-source cross-calibration solution with an eye to the future. Methods. By jointly using the Pan-STARRs (PS1) and Gaia all-sky telescopes, we characterised the measured filters from 11 photometric systems – including CfA, PS1, Foundation, DES, CSP, SDSS, and SNLS – using published observations of field stars. For the first time, we derived uncertainties on effective filter transmissions and modified filters to match the data. With the addition of direct observations of DA white dwarfs, we simultaneously cross-calibrated our zero points across photometric systems and trained a new SALT model to propagate to cosmology. Results. With improved uncertainties from DA WDs, we find improvements to the calibration systematic uncertainty of ×1.5 for the Pantheon+ sample, with a new systematic photometric uncertainty of σ w (phot) = 0.013 for Flat w CDM, and modest improvements to that of the DES5YR analysis. We find good agreement with previous calibration and show that even these small calibration changes can be amplified by up to a factor of six in the inferred SN Ia distances; this is driven by calibration sensitivity in the colour–luminosity relations and SALT training. Initial results indicate that these changes cause d μ /d z = 0.041 ± 0.009 across our redshift range. These may have a potentially larger impact in w0/wa space and on inferences regarding evolving dark energy.
SN  - 0004-6361
SN  - 1432-0746
ER  -